28 Best American Restaurants near Wantage

“Living close to the NY/PA/NJ border definitely has its perks.Decided to head over to Sussex County NJ to try something new for lunch. First of all, the beer flights are only $7, the downside is all beer is served in plastic cups, but the pours are nice size. They do have wine but nothing that this wine snob wanted, lol. The kitchen offers something for everyone. I had the hot Italian panini, my husband the pepperoni pizza, zero complaints. Big bonus there's was music on Sunday! Nice gentleman singing not your ordinary songs, like Eleanor Ribgy! Very cool.2nd Bonus.There's specific parking spots for motorcycles. So we will definitely be back on our scoot with some friends, scenic route from home is no highway. Nice outdoor seating and ice cream for kids, bring the whole fam, no dogs tho.“

“Stopped in for lunch. Atmosphere was comfortable. My server Jutay was amazing, very positive attitude. Had the soup of the day with fresh squeezed lemon, which elevated the taste even more. My burger was juicy and flavorful. My only suggestion would be to have those in the dining room, not be listening to their phone on speaker. I plan on visiting again!!“

“very good food and prices and a good atmosphere“

“Went for dinner tonight with my in laws. Food was great but the service was even better. Denise was FANTASTIC! Highly recommend and make sure you request Denise!“

“Went for dinner tonight with my in laws. Food was great but the service was even better. Denise was FANTASTIC! Highly recommend and make sure you request Denise!“

“We moved to Florida and we wish we could bring Cuginos with us. Well actually, don't judge... but we have packed up food to fly home with us a few times! We CRAVE the food and we look forward to dining here every time we visit NY. We love everything we have tried but a few of our favorites are the Pizza, Garlic Knots with Cheese, Thai Chili Wings well done, hot honey espresso slice with pepperoni, Eggplant Parm, Chicken Parm and Penne Ala Vodka. We have ordered trays of the Penne Ala Vodka and Eggplant Parm in the past as well, and it's a guaranteed hit at parties! My husband has always said you can put their Vodka sauce on a shoe and it will taste good. It's a family owned and operated restaurant. The owner Maria is an absolute gem and the staff is friendly and attentive. The restaurant is always clean and nicely decorated. This place remains at the top of my list and the quality of food is highly deserving of the best rating!“

“Great Breakfast! Friendly and happy service, no bums rush! Loved it!“

“not just breakfast ... delicious lunch and dinner too! dine inside delicious food great customer service Typically we get breakfast, which is always really good... we had lunch for a change this week & WoW, so delicious.“

“We were visiting from Massachusetts and found this place. The fried ice cream and funnel cake was delicious. The atmosphere was original 50s(I think) smdecor and staff was very friendly. Would highly recommend. Thank you“

“The food is amazing and they have the absolute best selection of their own beers. This place is the absolute best Brewery in the Tri-State Area“

“We went to Latour for our anniversary. Got a packaged deal with a 1 night stay at Minerals because we could only stay one night. The package included a credit for the 7 course dinner and wine pairing. Nothing bad to say about Latour. The chef made accommodations for myself because I'm allergic to shell fish and my spouse for not eating beef or pork and still keep it pretty close to the menu. The only dish that couldn't be altered was the pork because its portions are split between two people but that didn't bother me, the Chef substituted Oxtail me and Tortellini for my spouse, which were both on the 3 course menu. Trevor the sommelier, made adjustments with the wine pairing toatch the food and was awesome as was Blake and the rest of the wait staff. Definitely will be going back to do another 7 course dinner in the future.Dietary restrictions: Shellfish, pork, beef“

“It was absolutely an amazing experience!!! So romantic and beautiful! Would definitely recommend! The service, staff, and food were outstanding! Thank you for sharing your farm and food with us and giving us an amazing experience!“

“This food was delicious!“

“Best place great food great people well cleaned“

“We have been to Old Stone many times and are never disappointed. The setting is intimate and beautifully decorated. It is immaculately clean; the cases of home baked muffins, danish, pies and cakes literally gleam. We love their freshly brewed coffee. We’ve had great breakfasts there. But, we believe their lunch menu to be the best tasting in town. Everything is made to order. The home made soups are especially delicious. The tuna salad was freshly prepared with surprising bits of carrot in the mix...yum! The burger was massive. Lastly, the owners are friendly and accommodating. Check it out. You will be glad you did!“

“Great sandwiches! Delicious bread and they are big!! Highly recommend them“

“Stopped in for lunch and started with a cup of homemade chicken noodle soup which was full of chicken and fresh vegetables and tasted great, not overly salty like so many places. This was perfect! Also had the angus cheeseburger which was cooked to perfection and had fresh onions, tomato and lettuce. It was served with homemade cole slaw which was excellent and the fries were hot and crispy and seasoned perfectly! Good selection of draft beer too! Highly recommended!“

“There is not one bad thing to say about Texas Lunch! Even this picture doesn’t do it justice. The food is absolutely delicious in its own Texas Lunch, unmistakable way. Fresh ingredients, unbelievable flavors and all at a price you can’t find elsewhere. We ordered the TL burger with all of the fixings, chicken tenders, the Texas Dog, onion rings and fries. Everything came out hot and delicious. The fries, onion rings and tenders were crisped to perfection and the burgers and dog was the best we’ve had in a long time. The restaurant itself was immaculate and the servers are some of the friendliest people. We enjoyed it thoroughly and can’t wait to go back.“

“Tiffany’s BLT’s are the BOMB! Don’t miss out on them from the Cafe when you are hungry! 5 ⭐️Love it here!“

“Love this place. It’s definitely one of the better restaurants/bars in the area. Not like some other restaurants in the area, that charge you a percentage to use your CC. Not only that one particular owner takes tip money away from waitresses because you used your CC. Could you imagine the owner taking tip money away, because a customer used a credit card. Sad for those other restaurants. This place is honest and friendly.“

“Great food at s good price“

“We love this place. Great service and great food. Everything is fresh. Homemade bread and desserts! Waitresses are always friendly!“

“Food was excellent, really cute little place, drinks were also great! It's a hidden gem that more people should know about. I got beef Wellington which was excellent, brussel sprout appetizer and the chocolate platter, and not pictured was the poached pear dessert also super good and French onion soup was excellent as well! Would definitely recommend and go again! Little pricy though“

“The Tikka Masala and Butter Chicken dishes along with the garlic naan were simply delicious. The staff were polite, the food was fresh and hot and the prices are reasonable. My son and I will be back to indulge in the cuisine no doubt. Welcome to the community Front Street Cafe.“

“Awesome experience at the matamoras perkins yesterday 2 26 22 latoya was our waitress and she was a master at her craft , my wife and I had the best service from latoya she was excellent, the food was well prepared and looked so delicious on the plate, food was great , we go to alot of places to eat and this was just a great all around , and clean“

“Our granddaughters wedding reception was there and that did a wonderful job!“

“Beautiful restaurant, love it. Went for a friend's birthday party. Provided a relaxing atmosphere, food was delicious, very clean and the staff was extremely pleasant. Highly recommend.“

“If you are r are seeking a wifi cafe, upscale and trendy... You won't find it here. What you will find is great food, great value and personal staff. This is a classic gem, authentically nostalgic... And did I mention a historic scenic town? A classic diner experience. If you are r are railfanning, make this your food “