Godfather's Pizza Express

1900 S Mountain Rd, Tucumcari
(575) 461-1777

Recent Reviews

Shell Brockman

This is now the second time we ordered pizza on line. First time we excepted the excuse. And waited an hour or more to get our pizzas. This time nope. We want our money back and we will go some where else.And on top of that, they got rude about it like it was our fault. Then wasnt going to give all of our money back, praise the lord we had our email confirmation and order details. If your not going to check for on-line orders, then dont offer it. Simple as that.Had to give 1 star to post

Christina Gholson

Wow the pizza was on point tonight, super delicious! Ordered the bacon cheeseburger pizza with extra cheese, a pepperoni pizza with extra cheese and cheese sticks and everything was very tasty. A little pricey but it was completely worth it! :) My husband forgot to tip before he left after picking up the pizza which turned out to be a good thing cause the pizzas were so good I sent him back to give a nice tip which is way more than if he'd remembered lol. :) Thank you for making our pizza night great!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Melisa Rose

Just stopped by here ! I haven’t even left the parking lot and two of my Chester biscuits are damn near digested and I’m going in on this godfathers pizza ? . Great service there were 2 men and a woman behind the counter. The two men serviced me I hate that I didn’t catch their names but awesome

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Samantha Romero

Ordered our pizza online they sent a confirmation number to our email said go at 645 pm went and our order was not made ! Why offer online ordering if you don't have anyone pulling those orders up to be made! Waste of time! A whole staff and not one of them could pull up online orders ! So do not order online cause they definitely won't be making that order for you!! Smh thankfully I didn't pay online I pressed the pay cash !

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Melissa f247

Individuals working had zero clue how to function at life. Ordered pizza and wings, took over an hour as they made the pizza but just never put it in the oven.Pizza was okay but poorly made, very little sauce, pepperoni, then a metric ton of cheese that covered the pepperoni completely. Wings were decent.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Hot Wings

Veronica Blea

I ordered a thin crust extra sauce, pepperoni, bell pepper and mushroom pizza the other night, it was absolutely delicious, thank you Sam for the awesome pizza!

Da Dao

Awesome food and service! Thank you!

Lc Press23

A BIG shout-out to SHERI , tonight she made my night , thanks for offer yourself and making us the pizza 20 minutes before close , you are a wonderful kind person ? God Bless you.

Ana Perez

A BIG shout-out to SHERI , tonight she made my night , thanks for offer yourself and making us the pizza 20 minutes before close , you are a wonderful kind person ? God Bless you.

Babbal Malhi

they close at 9:20pm

Stephanie Jay

Things were going kind of slow however the gentle man that took our order also made our pizza and he made it well worth the wait. He didn't have a name tag, props to him (in the photo), thank you so much!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Veggie Pie

Chris Sesas

My psychic powers acquired while passing through the meth clouds on rt66 wouldn't allow me to order telepathically, and wouldn't you guess, no phone number either. Not sure how they expect to make sales.

Gurwinder Pattar

Small pizza ? not good

Gurinder Singh

Good customer service but someone forgot the cut the pizza.

G S

New review 7/13/22, ordered hot stuff pizza pick up, mgr only charged for mini, but pan not oiled stuck, so fixed me a new Mexico one and mgr was nice enough to come out and apologize again, got it home, no pepperoni, no jalapenos, very little Italian sausage, disappointed

Load More