The Penny Pub

79 W Main St, Bay Shore
(631) 969-4061

Recent Reviews

Jay Ososo

Mike And Allison were great! They did a catering event for the Irish American Celebration ?? ? ? ? at the H Lee Dennison Building at 3/27 2:00 pm - 4:00 pm. They were both professional,.kind, smiling a lot, and had a great sene of humor. Mike and Allison great outfitd on support the Irish American Celebration. They brought the atmosphere with them. Allison the bartender deserves every tip she gets. Mike and Allison worked hard catering.They have a small kitchen and their quality of Irish American Food is top notch. I recommend Fish And Chips, Corn Beef Sliders, Irish Epinonada, and Sheppards Pie.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Dublin Dip, Buffalo or Irish Whiskey BBQ Chicken Quesadilla, Penny Pub Chicken Club, The Penny Burger

octavia walker

Always come for the food was here on 2/20 and my id was scanned but a few weeks ago was not, so my issue was that people walked in and did not have to scan the id but my id was then my fiancé drinks cognac and they so not serve that so we asked what they have on the menu the bartender did not offer they margarita Monday special at all n charged us for a double if casamigo but we surely never asked for a double I was unleashed with how we were treated by the bartender he wasn’t rude just not servicing us professionally offering us what we could have we paid $16 for one drink even they gave a flight special on Monday for choose 4 for $14 I felt he did as he pleased I’m not use to this as I been coming here. Since I was 21 and I’m 32 now. Please ensure you are giving guest all the options and thank you keep up the great work

Atmosphere: 2

Service: 1

Thomas Thomson

Great bar, very clean, bar tenders are really friendly. Haven't had the food yet, but what I've seen come out of the kitchen looks very edible.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tom Valentin

Food is excellent. Good service. As for the tap beers...not sure if the lines are not cleaned or what the issue is, but the beers always taste flat with a weird after taste.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Dublin Dip

John

Got a burger with bacon and cheese, and order of fish and chips, and an order of friesEverything came out amazing but if I am paying $8 for fries I expect a separate container with fries, not 10 fries thrown into the same container as the burgerTarter sauce for the fish was amazing ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Fish & Chips

Peter Worthington

Great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Dublin Dip

Joey Brown

I visited yesterday afternoon for the first time and I’ve lived nearby for 20 years. It was Happy Hour just after 3pm and the special was $1 off all drafts. I ordered one Blue Point Blueberry Ale.I’m sorry, but $7 for a local draft beer with a dollar off is too much when the same beer is less expensive just about anywhere else, around $4-$5

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 4

Seagull on a soapbox Poops

I visited yesterday afternoon for the first time and I’ve lived nearby for 20 years. It was Happy Hour just after 3pm and the special was $1 off all drafts. I ordered one Blue Point Blueberry Ale.I’m sorry, but $7 for a local draft beer with a dollar off is too much when the same beer is less expensive just about anywhere else, around $4-$5

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 4

M Gomez

Yummy food! Open late, and great service.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jessica Diaz

Hosted a birthday celebration at Penny’s and it was perfect! Food was great, the drinks were perfect and the service was exceptional!! 10/10 !!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

karen na

Ladies beware moldy toilet paper in bathrooms. I want to upload a pic but it wont let me

Melody Cooney

The Penny Pub is our most favorite bar in town! Awesome food & well made drinks. Great manager & staff! Such a very hard working group & it can be very crazy & packed pub at times but the staff always handles it amazingly well! When we go there we look forward to seeing them all! They like my family when I go there. Last night when we went to the pub we didn’t see one of our favorite bartender Jake . I asked where is Jake tonight & was told he was let go because he can’t work at different bars in the same town! What? Who makes these rules up? It’s hard to get really good, friendly hard working employees these days. Please reconsider & bring Jake back at the Penny!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Samantha Marie

The penny pub is a great bar for any occasion and a great local experience! Their attentive staff and persistent customer service will draw me back in time and time again. Mike the bartender and George the bar back have made my experience wonderful! I look forward to my next visit at the penny pub

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

D R

First time ordering, great food. Order delivery off their website - cheaper than third party delivery services. One con? Smaller than I expected portions of the fried Mac & boneless wings.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dan Pinto

This bar was a blast to visit we rolled in from Philadelphia with 12 guys after a local event we came up for ended.. bartenders and locals were friendly. We had great service and mixed drink were well made. Beer's were ice cold and poured the way they should be.. they have a section in the back of the bar were we played pool, darts, huge jinga listened to great music.. We highly recommend this pub. This pub was clean with no sticky floors... A++

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Load More