19 Best Delis near Bayville

“Sadly, this place has now changed hands after a kitchen fire caused it to shut down. Anthony and his crew will be sorely missed, as this was THE BEST deli of all time on all of Long Island. Yes, I've been to any deli thats ever gotten any decent review. No, none of them compared. I wish Anthony and his family the best. RIP Talentis. ?“

“This cozy spot in Bayville offers a charming community atmosphere, often frequented by friendly older folks who enjoy cracking jokes. It adds to the experience! You can even play the New York Lottery while enjoying some pizza. However, if this place is closed, it might be best to head home or order from nearby options through food delivery apps.“

“We love the chicken pesto panini is a must when we got out for competitions, and bacon ? egg ? and cheese on the roll, and the cheese and steak onions with jalapenos is delicious. ? and they support the community.Kid-friendliness: I have my five-year-old eating a sandwich and no problems.“

“We ordered breakfast catering from Makerie for our staff at La Jolie Salon. Kirsten was so accommodating and friendly. She delivered the food hot and right on time. The food was delicious and our staff loved it! We will definitely be using the Makerie for many more events in the future!“

“My husband and I stopped here a couple weeks ago on a trip to visit family. I was 8 weeks pregnant at the time and struggling with morning sickness. I got a breakfast sandwich here and I have not been able to stop thinking about it since, it was that good. The bagel was fresh and toasted perfectly, the eggs were cooked to perfection, not burn even with a tiny about of runny yolk remaining. The bacon was melt in your mouth delicious without crumbling into your lap. My husband got a sub sandwich and he said it was better than his favorite deli from his hometown. I think we will make this a regular stop. I highly recommend.“

“I moved here from Long Island and haven’t really been able to find a deli comparable to the ones there. I was so surprised with this place I called right after I ate my sandwich to let them know how good it was. Sliced thin cold cuts and fresh bread! Finally a place that knows how to do it right in this area! Highly recommend. Such a gem!“

“Nice little local spot. I stopped along at work for extra breakfast, the bacon egg and cheese on a roll is heaven on earth. The roll was so fresh it was soft on my teeth. Eggs are runny as they should be and bacon was crispy in a good way not a hard time. The price of things is not bad at all for Greenwich if I must say. Staff is polite nothing fancy to see here with decor, families or women to hang out but it’s a no frills old school type of local spot.“

“Fantastic family owned Deli. Fresh made hero sandwiches, soups and more. If they have the New England clam chowder available take time have a bowl it is absolutely delicious maybe better than the Chowder my mother makes ( please don't tell her that). Friendly staff and food at a reasonable price. I highly recommend this Deli“

“Great casual food, including pernil (slow-roasted pork) available daily, along with great hot buffet choices, hearty sandwiches and fresh salads. The jalapeño salad goes great with the pernil or on a sandwich, and the avocado salad is fantastic.“

“A bit overpriced but consistently good food. You can make your own chopped salad, or order yourself a sandwich. Cafe Bella has a couple of small tables in the middle of the floor for those in need of a quick bite on-the-go. There is a credit card minimum of $10 which they are very strict about.“

“One of the best Deli’s on Long Island. Large variety of food and salads. Clean building and friendly staff. They even have a brick oven for pizza and calzones. A little expensive but definitely worth it. They even own the restaurant (Franina’s) next door. Great food from both places.“

“Stella Blue is like taking a step back in time to when things were chill. The atmosphere is nostalgic and the food is always fresh. They have amazing vegetarian and vegan options available too so there’s something for everyone. They have indoor and outdoor seating.“

“BEST bec in the village hands down. variety of food for sure, depending on your desire. the italian hero is my go to *chef kiss* but when I would like to feel "healthy" I'll pick up a salad (always freshly made and or packed to grab & go) definitely friendly staff. not sure what old angry lady someone else was mentioning. I always see a young man at the register *shrug* ** PS: prices are bound to go up, this is NY!“

“Was that just the best Reuben that I've ever had in my life? I don't think I remember one as good. I haven't put my finger on whether it was the dressing the sauerkraut or the meat, but it was unbelievably delectable ..I will travel out of my way to come here!“

“I just want to express my sincere and heartfelt gratitude to the Sabelli staff. I've been at home all week battling COVID and relying on delivery apps for my meals, and unfortunately, the costs have been adding up. However, this evening when I ordered a pint of soup from Sabelli, I was pleasantly surprised to find two pints in the bag. I cannot express how much this meant to me and how it felt like a true blessing from God. You lifted a huge load from me. May He continue to bless you, your business, and all of your loved ones always. Thank you.“

“Good, fat sandwiches and great service. The turkey was very fresh and tasty. Also, I had ordered a gluten free sandwich online and they called to confirm that it was an allergy as to prevent cross contamination. I sincerely appreciated this gesture.“

“Rockridge Fan Poem:If you want to start the day off right,Rockridge breakfast will bring you to the light.A Kaiser roll with the egg and bacon,Will truly get your heart shakin!With an Island coconut coffee on the side,So good you better open your mouth up wide!TLDR: Best breakfast in NY for a great price, coffee was awesome,“

“Excellent service. i've been ordering delicious hot sandwiches to be delivered to my father during Covid. Clear and quick on phone, exceptionally speedy from order to door and often confirm delivery. Dad is very happy with the meals. I am very very grateful.“

“BEST SANDWICHES (best bread and meats) !It's a deli It's a butcherIt's a farmer's marketIt's a pasta house It's a home store If you speak Italian you will feel at home. I love this place. It's an experience.“