50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Brightwaters

“Excellent place, decoration and pleasant atmosphere, good decoration, clean areas, I liked the experience, the food was delicious, the only thing is that the waitress who served us was very invasive and interrupted the conversations, she pressured us to collect the dishes, maybe they should guide the staff a little more As for the service because this is a place to take your time and it is not fast food.Parking: It is easy to access. It's outside the restaurant.“

“Vegetarian options: Chef is always so wonderful when we ask to adjust popular apps to be vegan friendly.Wheelchair accessibility: My MIL is in a wheelchair and they always go above and beyond to make her happy and always find a place for her chair.“

“The pizzeria is like our second home.The staff, food, atmosphere… everything is outstanding.We come here more than once a week. We may be addicted. Uncle Benny and Trifecta 4 Life!!!In the winter, the crowd at the bar is welcoming and the bartenders are always so personable.In the summer, they have live music and an awesome outdoor area to enjoy.They also run specials each week (buy one get one pizza Mondays and buy one get one pasta Wednesdays). They are also great supporters of local law enforcement! We are proud to have this amazing family and business in our neighborhood!Thank you for everything Pizzeria of Bay Shore!Shout out to all the staff: Cassie, Max, Hilary and all of the amazing crew. We love you guys!Dietary restrictions: Options for all.“

“Had a beautiful table by the window. Cali and Drew did a beautiful job. Food was delicious. It was a perfect Easter dinner. Food, drinks and dessert was delicious.Wheelchair accessibility: Yes I would say this is a wheelchair accessible. Double doors,ground level. There was a couple of people in wheelchairs when I was there.“

“For top-notch pizza and exceptional service, head to Catusco Pizza in Huntington Station. Their pizzas are flavor-packed with a perfect crust and fresh toppings. The menu also features appetizing options, including gluten-free and vegan choices. The friendly owner makes every visit memorable. Catusco Pizza is a must-try spot in Huntington Station. (Try their vodka slice and the penne a la vodka and thank me later)“

“So last night we order the islander combo normally the food is delious I don't know they where busy and rushing but the pizza was terriable small slices asked for half pepperoni on one of the pizzas n it was placed on there n got garlic knots they where burnt n the sauce literally was all oil ! So very disappointed they really need to take there time n pay attention to orders n how the food is prepped a little“

“Please order the Prosciutto Focaccia you won’t regret it. Amazing dish. Service is amazing. All staff very attentive and friendly. Drinks are really good too. I discovered this place after picking up pizza kits from my daughter’s school and thanks to that this will be my new favorite pizzeria. Thanks all for your hard work. You are doing an amazing job.“

“We’ve ordered through uber eats twice and have been so happy every time! The margarita pizza and the vodka pie are both great.I was prompted to review with 5 stars because i ordered a ginger ale, and they didnt have any. Not only did they read the order instructions and replace it with a sprite, they also left an apology note on my drink! They not only have stellar food, but they clearly have great people working for them too.“

“This is the 2nd time I've visited MaBella, and it was another delightful experience! The chicken franchise was delicious, as was the warm bread. The service is impeccable, the water glasses are quickly refilled, and the servers are friendly and attentive without being overbearing. We split dessert, and the NY Cheesecake was wonderful, as was the Affogato! We'll be back!“

“A lot of fake reviews so here’s a real one.This is a unique slice, it’s very saucy. Never seen so much sauce on a slice, amazing to dip there god-tier garlic knots in.2 slices, a knot, and a soda for 10$ is amazing value too.Pizza isn’t cooked properly every time so it can be soggy. But this spot NAILS garlic knots. This is the best knot on the island.Pizza could be a 5/5 or a 3/5 depending on your pie - there isn’t consistency“

“Great new Pizza spot in West Islip that I've been going to more & more compared to other Pizza spots in the area. I've only ordered the regular Cheese Pizza Pies there & it's the closest thing to something you would get at some of the well-known Pizza places in Manhattan or Brooklyn. ??“

“Cheesy goodness. If you're ever craving some delicious pizzas and pastas, definitely stop by. They have such incredible food. We were obsessed with the fried cauliflower and the thin crust pizza. The pasta was amazing as well. Can't wait to try the rest of their menu! Appetizers - Hot 'n Crispy - Garlic Knots - Caesar Salad Entrees - Grandma Ala Vodka - Fiorentina“

“We had a very friendly waitress. She recommended the rice balls, and they were excellent. There was also a tv in the dining room and they changed it to the NASCAR race for me. The bread was nice and the garden salad was surprisingly tasty. Usually tomatoes are pale white and bland this time of year, but they had some nice ones in the salad. My entree was the Chicken Monachina. The portion size was very generous. Maybe a little more cheese than I would've liked. The chicken was of good quality and had no gristle. I will come again if I am in the area.“

“Have been a regular at Branchinelli for years. Food is always great. Service is good. Even when there is a line to wait, you are called within a reasonable time. Would recommend to everyone. If it is just Pizza, full meal or catering, can't go wrong“

“I just left Spasso's Pizzeria and had a very nice experience there.Ordered a pie for pickup at 4pm. At 5:30 Spassos called to confirm I was still picking it up (I was caught up with work and didn’t leave the house until about 5:45).When I got to Spassos, the owner told me that they didn’t want me to have a cold pie, so they made me a fresh one and had me keep the original one as well.They were extremely generous (considering it was my fault the pizza was cold and I didn’t mind).Just thought it was really sweet and wanted to acknowledge them for doing so.Thanks again Spassos!“

“We have lived in Oakdale for 6+ years and have always complained that the only thing we didn't like was the lack of good pizza/italian takeout! We finally expanded our search a little bit and luckily found this place. I am really picky about the pizza - if you're going to splurge, it better be worth it! And this pizza is so worth it. Every topping you could want & all the basics were perfect.Everything was phenomenal, fresh, delivered really fast, priced great, and service was amazing (called to check on custom request via online app to make sure they understood 100% correctly - we all know this is not always the case!). Cannot recommend highly enough. Give them a try - you will be so happy.“

“I got the spinach and artichoke pizza slice and the chicken marsala slice they were both delicious. im gonna be getting from here when I'm in the mood for pizza since it's close to my job. It's a part of a gas station, so it was kinda surprising that it was so good !“

“This hidden gem looks like a hole in the wall do not be fooled the food is excellent. The staff amazing and fun and more importantly, the owner is always their! He also great his guests and knows all the regulars names he really cares about his guests. It is not fancy but homey, cozy and fun we love this place! The prices amazing!“

“The owners, Mike & Terry are wonderful souls who care deeply about the community they serve, always going above and beyond to support KiDS NEED MoRE and other local causes. They also have absolutely the most delicious food and the staff is so friendly and fast. My wife loves the eggplant. Everytime I come home with Joe's Pizza I am a hero in my house!“

“Got there just as the sun was setting on Thursday evening with my son. The wait staff was accommodating, attentive, and pleasant. He had a slice, and I had a pasta dish. All was to our liking, I would go back.Kid-friendliness: There were other families there at that time.“

“I've lived in the area for years and never been inside this place until two weeks ago. The inside of the establishment has this classy old-school charm about it. It was a tiny bit confusing because they had the podium in the front by the door and the sign on it said to wait there I noticed everybody walked in anyway so I just went. Maybe they can hide that somewhere else until it's that time of the night or something? Anyway, one of my favorites slices is the grandma slice and I had to try theirs because it was suggested over and over to me by many people. So after finally trying one slice, I ended up buying a whole pie and taking it home. Yes, it's a tiny bit expensive in comparison to the other places locally but the quality of pie is worth the extra money. If you want to be taken back in time and enjoy a great slice then come here.“

“We stopped for lunch it a quaint shop at the end of the strip stores just east of Keith Lane. They have lots of pizza choices. We tried 5 slices. The zucchini onion was a large slice w good sauce and cheese. A good bite. The sausage and broccoli rabe could use more broccoli rabe but it was good square slice. The chicken piccata was great good flavored sauce and chicken cooked well. The Mac n cheese was good square slice w good flavors. The Chicken Alfredo had good sauce flavor but there was a burnt taste not sure if it's a smoky taste but wasn't my fav. We did love the Mac n cheese pinwheel but the start was the pepperoni pinwheel. I love that you can pick your own spices it's in the table. Also you can pick your own drink. Grateful that the work was receptive to the chicken Alfredo slice. You order and within mins foods out hot and flavorful. They're staff is hopping and they're deliver guys were running around a lot. Good Place will be back soon.“

“Great chicken parm and pasta was cooked Al dente sauce was nice too Marc has always been good to me and my family at almarcos it was a pleasure to try out Marcos will be in more often also they are the only Long Island pizzeria with a drive thru hope to see this place thrive God bless“

“Last night we tried The Pizzeria of Islip for the first time, and it was amazing! We ordered the Family bundle, buffalo knots, and the mini cannoli's. Everything was delicious and the portions exceeded our expectations! We certainly will be adding this business to one of our go to places!“

“So happy we found this place. Were always looking for great Pizza nice crust not too thick. So many different choices always ready & the specialty rolls, capellini cakes are so delish.. and everything is a fair price especially for the good quality you get.They give back alot to those whom may need help as well and that means something to have a business give back to the community. Were not even local but drive over every week for our take out & always pop in when we are passing through.Everyone's always friendly and counter help always knows whats out so they are helpful to suggest thigs to try..“

“It was 5:15 pm on a Saturday night, and it was freezing outside and very windy. Upon walking into Babylon Village, the cold winds hit my face as I was looking for a place to have dinner at. I then came across Bella Pazza. From the moment I walked into the store, I was greeted with a very warm welcome from the owner, Aldo. Aldo was very friendly and answered thoroughly any questions I had about the menu. Aldo treated me like family.I ordered the mini rice balls, sicilian style rice balls, mozzarella sticks, a garlic knot slice, and a cheese slice, and let me say, everything that I had ordered was amazing. The decor in the restaurant really enhanced the dining experience and led it to be the true and ideal Saturday Night Dining Experience.I strongly recommend this restaurant to anyone who is looking for incredible Italian food and a breathtaking ambience for when it comes to dining. Excellent job Aldo & Bella Pazza!“

“Great place to take the family. I took my two little nieces to celebrate my bday and the staff was amazing, they were patient with answering my questions, and I was happy to see the level of cleanliness of the facility.We did the 90minutes of play and a medium pizza. Luckily the 90mins come with one pause. Chuck E Cheese came out a couple of times and of course super gregarious with the toddlers!We went from 1015-1230 so it wasn’t crowded!Kid-friendliness: Ages 2-10 were there. As an adult I still had fun, and they do have beer options.“

“This is a great local pizzeria. You can sit down at tables and order other Italian foods, but their pizza is excellent. Crispy thin crust and good cheese and sauce. I've never been disappointed. Conveniently located on 109 with a decent sized parking lot. Good place to stop when you're on the go. Friendly service too.“

“It’s the vegan option for me. They have cauliflower crust, vegan cheese and plenty of vegetable options.Vegetarian options: Cauliflower crustVegan cheeseMore vegetable optionsParking: Parking is small but wasn’t crowded or filled up around the time I went.“

“One of the best pizza spots on Long Island. I go out of my way to drive here when I want pizza. Listen, there is pizza in almost every shopping center, and most of it is trash. This place is worth the drive if you don't live in Copiague. ?“

“Every time I order for them, they hit it out of the park! It’s our new go to spot for everything! Pizza, pasta, calzones, & dinner rolls…everything just comes out so damn good! Delicious, hot, fresh, and on time ? We’re so happy our family found the perfect spot ❤️ Thanks for the great eats ??“

“Great pies from Nico's. Very impressed. Went in for a few IPAs from Root and Branch and tried a pie from Nico's. Absolutely delicious. Great char on the pie. Added a little hot honey. Was really good. Would recommend coming here for the pizza even if you're not into IPA beer. Yes it was that good. By the train tracks in Copiague“

“Can’t say enough good things about our experience. First we came in on a Friday around 6:30 with our toddler, our waiter Nick immediately saw that she was starving and said he would throw her dish in first, which came out astronomically fast. Nick was super friendly & attentive, our pizza took a while to come out which my husband and I were ok with but the manager noticed herself and came over and offered us a free dessert, it got to the time where my toddler had to go lol so we just opted for the check and since we couldn’t take the dessert they gave us 20% off. We made sure to give Nick tip off the pre discounted price because he was that great. Just great service and attentiveness all around. Thank you and we will be back!“

“Always the best food! We have catered a few times the food is always amazing and delicious! Our favorites are Chicken Cutlet Pie, Baked Ziti, Ravioli, Chicken Rolls! Delivery is always fast and food is always hot. Staff is super friendly! My family won’t go anywhere else!“

“Do yourself a favor an order the egg plant parm roll. It's amazing and has become a new family favorite. We've ordered takeout from here a few times and the pizza is really good. However, I don't love the mushroom topping because the mushrooms taste like they're the mushrooms from a can (I'd prefer fresh, but that's just me). I'll continue to order from here.“

“It is one of the most hidden gems on Long Island. If I tell you the food is so fresh. I mean you have to wait for it to come off fresh off the grill. The flavors are so mouth watering. Thank god it’s 25 mins from my home or I’d be there weekly. I do warn you that if you taste their tzatziki you can never go anywhere else. It’s to die for!!!“

“OMG We were at my daughter's home in East Northport and i ordered a few pizzas from Milano for the first time and we are all in love!! Best pies that we have had on the island! Their pizza is not greasy or heavy and everything is very fresh. The chicken Marsala pie and the regular pie were tops - best I have had and we also ordered a tri-color pie to try and it was delicious!! We plan to dine in to try their entrées. If I could give 10 stars I would!“

“Just walked in to grab a quick bite to go. Purchased the Penne a la vodka slice and a plain slice. Both were delicious and I truly loved their Vodka slice the mostThe guy at the front was super friendly and kind as well. Hope to go back for a dine-in experience“

“I received a page full of coupons for this place so I decided to go. I got one of the family meals to try a few things from there and see how it was. The coupon included an XL pizza (18"), 6 garlic knots, 6 zepoles, an eggplant parmesan, and pasta with sauce. All of this for about $30 after tax. That alone is a great deal. The pizza and eggplant parmesan were both great and so were the garlic knots. The zepoles weren't real zepoles but they weren't too bad and the pasta was good but the sauce was just sauce. No herbs cooked into the sauce nor cheese on top. That's okay though because I fixed it up when I got home. I'm definitely gonna go back and use some more of these coupons though because they're great deals and this place has good food.Parking: More parking in the back of the pizzeria.“

“Mangia has been our family's "go to" Italian for 30+ years. The meat balls are the best and the eggplant rollatini is world renowned. We've had a few family celebrations there. Never disappointed. The owners are sweet as can be. The pizza is to die for. Classic New York neighborhood Italian .“

“The pizza is the best i have ever had!! Just as good as grandmas!!!The staff is knowledgeable in all food. The owner was my cheff at off the hook seafood and galley! He was written up many times by Joanne Remnick in Newsday for the best seafood on Long Island three years straight.“

“My daughter and I used to be regulars in this pizzeria. They offer a dish I have found nowhere else I've ever eaten. So I just so happen to look them up on here. All the food is great but the Chicken mona Lisa steals the show. My hours used to be crazy but the family would allow my daughter and I to dine while they were cleaning up and technically closed for the day. My daughter is now 24 and has a son of her own but we still reminisce about the good times in this establishment. The family atmosphere was as 2nd to none. To any of the family or staff that remember us we thank you for all the great food and the hospitality you have provided us a wonderful memory. Next time I'm in LI I'll be sure to stop in.“

“Placed order for small catering party. had penne a la vodka, chicken franchaise and a salad (their Italian dressing was awesome). All was so delicious, the sauce on the chicken I could not get enough of. everything was perfect!! Will definitely have them cater our future parties.“

“Had the pleasure of visiting some friends in Ocean Beach this past holiday weekend and one night we decided to visit Town Pizza for some late night snacks. The store was packed but the line moved very quickly. We tried a few slices of the Town Round, as well as a pie of pepperoni (pro-tip, ask for boom boom sauce and cold cheese, you will not be disappointed!). Town pizza quite possibly has the best pizza I ever had and the staff is super friendly and accommodating. We can not wait to visit Ocean Beach again and get our favorite pizza! Thank you boys!!“

“It was my husband and I first time there and we absolutely loved the Supreme pie we ordered. We will definitely be regulars at Salvatore's. Can't wait to try more of their food everything looked delicious!Parking: We found a parking spot right out front“

“Hello my name is Santiago , this restaurant was very helpful and generous and very Knowledgeable on what they do and how they treat their customers it made me feel like I was at home and I will continue to keep bringing this business attributes and business so this Pizzeria will be great to experience will got positive atmosphere vibes so please stop at this local pizza place cause it’s more then a restaurant it’s a family oriented business ?“

“Hands down the best pizza place in the area. I tried the others nearby but after trying victors it’s all I will eat. They have a big selection of slices available , I usually get the brick oven pizzetta which is delicious. Their garlic knots are some of the best around. They also have pasta nights and chicken nights where there are specials on those dishes. It can be extremely busy sometimes, but the service is good and the guys behind the counter are all funny and treat you like family. Highly recommend!“

“The food was absolutely amazing and the service was great. Menu has a wonderful variety of food at a great price point. Very happy with my experience here and will be revisiting again soon.Parking: You can park on the street on behind the main street strip they have free parking lots that can get full quite quickWheelchair accessibility: Leveled floor“

“We just returned from having dinner at Villa. It was my granddaughter Quinn’s pick for her B’day dinner. The food was delicious and the service was excellent. Joe and Tony treated her so special she didn’t stopped smiling. As a gift Tony surprised her with a tray of freshly made zeppoles. They were incredible. Thank you for making her birthday so memorable!Kid-friendliness: They are warm and friendly! Willing to help with whatever you need.“

“Nice little pizzeria with good pizza and garlic knots. My favorite slices they have is their Buffalo chicken. Actually spicy, no blue cheese or ranch. Just like it is supposed to be made. I can easily eat a pie of their Buffalo chicken by myself.“