One of the best bakeries in my area. It's been there for so long so good and everything is always fresh. My number one bakery to go to!
Alice B.
Everything I got sucked!! Their "famous" rainbow cookie cake was stale. This is was for Christmas!! Cookies and cakes weren't up to par and after dropping over $100, they wanted like $3 or $6 for a bag. I was coming in from Jersey and they gave me like 5 assorted size boxes plus bread. Like for realllzzz??? GTFOH!!! Not worth it at all!! Never again!!
peter zafonte
Went in there for one thing and walked out with three bags!! OMG so good!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nordia M.
Great customer service. Also, the cannoli cake sold here is amazing. It's perfect for those who don't like super sweet desserts and prefer their frosting to be light and fluffy. I challenge you to only eat one cannoli cake slice!
Robyn Z.
They make a perfect NY cheesecake. Creamy, not too dense, not too sweet, absolutely addicting. Cannolis are great too.
Amanda D.
Disclaimer: an Italian here coming from a family who has a bunch of pizzerias but we aren't experts at baking, just experts at eating Italian pastries. You don't have to be an expert to realize that their pastries are not fresh. I have no idea how they have high reviews. Everytime I've been here I've been disappointed. I absolutely wanted to like this place. Eggclair, mini fruit tart stale. Red velvet cake, dry. Their canolli s are good.
Alfredo Montero
The ladies behind the counter were extremely nice and very helpful but let’s talk about those pastries. Oh my God so good. just go and try it you wont be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Cookies, Bakery, Italian Pastries
Vito Balestrate
Great pastries.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Pastries
Adriana De Pitkin
This was our first time visiting this Williamsburg Italian bakery. We ordered the Lobster Tail, St. Joseph Zeppole & Rainbow Cookies. And we ordered cappuccinos which were perfect. Everything was amazing. Also, the atmosphere was chill with plenty of indoor seating; kept very clean. The staff were super nice & friendly! Can’t wait to return and try more things! Also, we ordered a few things to-go; and our favorites were the Cannoli, Pignoli & Pistachio Cookies.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Cookies, Bakery, Lobster Tail, Italian Pastries, Rainbow Cookie Cake
Wen D.
I am not Italian and have no experience with Pastry, but Fortunato's i am quite fond of. Their Cheesecake is what my folks always came here for (Birthday Cake Substitute). And i'm very sure i could identify their Cheesecake in a blind taste test with 110% accuracy. My favorite thing is the cake box with their brand and logo. And that Rainbow Cookie... Hard to explain but, it's a multi-layered cake disguised as a "Cookie". Moist without feeling dense. Firm yet absolutely delicate. A fine destination to end your night for Dessert in the area. Or to pickup along the way from home after school.
Recommended dishes: Italian Cookies, Bakery, Italian Pastries, Chocolate Cake, Birthday Cake
Anton Revich
I got there now 13lb cannoli and it comes with 20,30,50 or 50 mini cannolis, this was a hit at parties and the cream is one of the best Iv had. If you wanna be the super star of any party order this bad boy and for 20 mini cannoli it’s $80!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery, Italian Pastries
Dennis Sensale
Great place , price, quality and atmosphere. Best bakery in Brooklyn if not the whole east coast. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Cookies, Strawberry Shortcake, Bakery, Marzipan, Lobster Tail, Italian Pastries, Cream Puff, Tiramisu, Rainbow Cookie Cake
James L.
Best pastries in all of NYC at reasonable prices. Worth the trip!! Rainbow cookie crumb cake is freaking amazing.
Silvio D.
Like the coffee and pastries. The place is q bit narrow since they moved all the tables to the outside. But everything is excellent
One of the best bakeries in my area. It's been there for so long so good and everything is always fresh. My number one bakery to go to!
Everything I got sucked!! Their "famous" rainbow cookie cake was stale. This is was for Christmas!! Cookies and cakes weren't up to par and after dropping over $100, they wanted like $3 or $6 for a bag. I was coming in from Jersey and they gave me like 5 assorted size boxes plus bread. Like for realllzzz??? GTFOH!!! Not worth it at all!! Never again!!
Went in there for one thing and walked out with three bags!! OMG so good!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great customer service. Also, the cannoli cake sold here is amazing. It's perfect for those who don't like super sweet desserts and prefer their frosting to be light and fluffy. I challenge you to only eat one cannoli cake slice!
They make a perfect NY cheesecake. Creamy, not too dense, not too sweet, absolutely addicting. Cannolis are great too.
Disclaimer: an Italian here coming from a family who has a bunch of pizzerias but we aren't experts at baking, just experts at eating Italian pastries. You don't have to be an expert to realize that their pastries are not fresh. I have no idea how they have high reviews. Everytime I've been here I've been disappointed. I absolutely wanted to like this place. Eggclair, mini fruit tart stale. Red velvet cake, dry. Their canolli s are good.
The ladies behind the counter were extremely nice and very helpful but let’s talk about those pastries. Oh my God so good. just go and try it you wont be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Cookies, Bakery, Italian Pastries
Great pastries.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Pastries
This was our first time visiting this Williamsburg Italian bakery. We ordered the Lobster Tail, St. Joseph Zeppole & Rainbow Cookies. And we ordered cappuccinos which were perfect. Everything was amazing. Also, the atmosphere was chill with plenty of indoor seating; kept very clean. The staff were super nice & friendly! Can’t wait to return and try more things! Also, we ordered a few things to-go; and our favorites were the Cannoli, Pignoli & Pistachio Cookies.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Cookies, Bakery, Lobster Tail, Italian Pastries, Rainbow Cookie Cake
I am not Italian and have no experience with Pastry, but Fortunato's i am quite fond of. Their Cheesecake is what my folks always came here for (Birthday Cake Substitute). And i'm very sure i could identify their Cheesecake in a blind taste test with 110% accuracy. My favorite thing is the cake box with their brand and logo. And that Rainbow Cookie... Hard to explain but, it's a multi-layered cake disguised as a "Cookie". Moist without feeling dense. Firm yet absolutely delicate. A fine destination to end your night for Dessert in the area. Or to pickup along the way from home after school.
Restaurantji Recommends
Best bakery in all
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Cookies, Bakery, Italian Pastries, Chocolate Cake, Birthday Cake
I got there now 13lb cannoli and it comes with 20,30,50 or 50 mini cannolis, this was a hit at parties and the cream is one of the best Iv had. If you wanna be the super star of any party order this bad boy and for 20 mini cannoli it’s $80!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery, Italian Pastries
Great place , price, quality and atmosphere. Best bakery in Brooklyn if not the whole east coast. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Cookies, Strawberry Shortcake, Bakery, Marzipan, Lobster Tail, Italian Pastries, Cream Puff, Tiramisu, Rainbow Cookie Cake
Best pastries in all of NYC at reasonable prices. Worth the trip!! Rainbow cookie crumb cake is freaking amazing.
Like the coffee and pastries. The place is q bit narrow since they moved all the tables to the outside. But everything is excellent