Amazing spot! Classic, not trendy, vibes. Good for families and groups with awesome vodka pasta! Birthday dessert is sick.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
P. J. Laurence Carroll
****Michael’s Of Brooklyn Restaurant****Hello, I am MR. BIG RED, and I want to share what a Great Night on The Town, I had last evening, with my friend, Scott Ruscillo. We dined/partied at Michael’s of Brooklyn Restaurant, and immediately were made to feel at home, as we were treated like Kings!!! The ambiance is very warm, classy, spacious, yet quite comfortable. The food is absolutely exquisite, scrumptious, delicious, course after course, dish after dish, with beautiful presentations.We started off with a Campari & Soda with Lemon, and a Bourbon Concoction from the Cocktail Menu. More Campari, and a Tangueray Negroni followed. Then Scotty and I sampled: The Chilled Crabmeat Cocktail & delightful Fried Calamari Appetizers. For the entrées, my Boy had a perfectly cooked Medium Rare Filet Mignon, with Asparagus. I chose The House Special, a melt-in-your-mouth Veal Chop Parmigiana, with a side of Spaghetti Bolognese.Two and a half hours into our meal, we made room for dessert. Scott had the largest Lobster Tail, stuffed with Whipped Creme and drizzled with Chocolate Ganache Sauce, that I’ve ever seen. He paired that with a Frangelico Coffee. I had an Assorted Sherbet dish with 5 Amazing flavors of Sherbet, and paired that with a Double Espresso and Romana Sambvca…...I purposely parked two blocks away, in Marine Park, Brooklyn, as I knew I would need a stroll after this tremendous dinner, and I have no problem walking City Streets around Midnight, even though I’m carrying a Louis Vuitton “Murse” clutch. My friends know what I bring to the party…..LoLoLoLoLoL.My dear friends, Matthew Mari, Esq. (Famous Defense Attorney), and Billionaire Businessman, Political Talk Show Host, John Catsimatidis and a whole host of politicians also dine here. As a former Finance Chairman of The New York Conservative Party, I can see why. Additionally, I understand that this is a favorite restaurant of Andrew Dice Clay’s and of Joe Piscopo’s, amongst a whole host of other celebrities. The Management; Chef, Kitchen Staff and Waitstaff are most Attentive, Amazing and Uber Professional. Michael, John and their Staff made our visit to Michael’s simply I N C R E D I B L E ! ! ! I highly recommend this establishment. YOU WILL NEED TO MAKE RESERVATIONS. Ask for Michael, and tell him MR. BIG RED from Table #1 at Park Side sent you….Bon Appétit, my friends!!! Thank you to all of the Great Folks at Michael’s for making our “Boy’s Night Out” a Spectacular one, across the board. We’ll be regulars!!!Kindest regards,MR. BIG RED.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Braised Short Ribs & Fried Gnocchi, Baked Clams, Marinara, Veal Alla Michael's
robin redmond
Although we had reservations we had to wait almost 1/2 hour for a table. But that’s the only complaint. The food was amazing, the staff was super friendly and out party of 6 really enjoyed.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Laura Noto
A#1......Everything!Dietary restrictions: They will pretty much make anything to your needs.Kid-friendliness: YesWheelchair accessibility: Yes
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tiramisu, Veal Scaloppini Sorrentina, Braised Short Ribs & Fried Gnocchi, Grilled Pulpo, Bread Basket, Lamb Chops, Baked Clams, Coconut Cake, Marinara, Risotto Mare, Lobster Bisque, Michael's Seafood Hot Antipasto, Fried Lobster All Michaels, Chicken Parmesan, Veal Alla Michael's, Homemade Tortoni, Chicken Alla Michaels
Ashley Marie Coscia
Michael's of Brooklyn on Avenue R... Just sounds inviting, doesn't it... This warm upscale italian eatery since 1964 did not disappoint! Were we're greeted by Yo Cuz, ;) if you know you know.... The service was exceptional, every dish, we left nothing behind... In addition to having no clue what a wonderful meal I was in for, I had Spumoni for the first time!!!!! >SCREAM< it was so good, no actually like the best!!! (no I don't live under a rock) just started to live a little!So good! Just so good!
This was my second time at this restaurant. The first time my friend took me there for my birthday, the food was delicious and the service excellent. This time I took my husband there for his birthday, my husband is not easily impressed. When we got there is said this is lovely, I said to him Waite until you order your dinner. At the end of dinner he looked at me and said I'm empress.
Mandy
My family and I have only been here for lunch, over the last month we dined in 3 times with reservations. The food is delicious and on the expensive side. Our recent visit left a sour taste in our mouths. We had let our server know early on that we would be ordering 2 additional meals to go around the time we'd order dessert, yet when we were done eating the 2 waiters in the restaurant would not acknowledge us. The busboys were very attentive in wrapping our leftovers, but understandably unable to take any food orders. My father tried to get assistance for almost 20 minutes, the dining room was empty besides us with the exception of one other guest, whom one waiter was speaking to with his back to us for the entire time we were attempting to order. We come from restaurant backgrounds and this was shocking behavior, considering how quiet the restaurant was and the cost no longer seemed appropriate for the service level. We had hoped to keep this restaurant as a weekly visit but have totally reconsidered ever returning.
Laura Is Here
Me and My Husband decided to try out Michael’s for the ball drop on New Year’s Eve 2024. We had the best night of our lives here. The food was incredible, The service was amazing and the place was packed and fun. We also didn’t want to judge this place by this one night considering it’s New Year’s Eve, and it was packed and it could be a little hectic and crazy because of the holiday, but they did not disappoint at all. We are still talking about how amazing this whole experience was. The whole feel of the restaurant was just perfect. The food was absolutely fantastic, and everything came out in perfect timing. Our waiter John was outstanding and made us feel very welcomed. There was live music which made the night even more perfect, and the decor was phenomenal. I also love that we could get very dressed up and how classy this place is. We will be returning on January 20th for my birthday celebration. ? and I can’t wait.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
NancyV
The best Italian restaurant in Brooklyn. Service is top notch and food is amazing. I patronize this restaurant often and never have had a bad meal. This is where Italians go to eat when they want a truly home cooked meal. Highly recommend!!!
Amazing spot! Classic, not trendy, vibes. Good for families and groups with awesome vodka pasta! Birthday dessert is sick.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
****Michael’s Of Brooklyn Restaurant****Hello, I am MR. BIG RED, and I want to share what a Great Night on The Town, I had last evening, with my friend, Scott Ruscillo. We dined/partied at Michael’s of Brooklyn Restaurant, and immediately were made to feel at home, as we were treated like Kings!!! The ambiance is very warm, classy, spacious, yet quite comfortable. The food is absolutely exquisite, scrumptious, delicious, course after course, dish after dish, with beautiful presentations.We started off with a Campari & Soda with Lemon, and a Bourbon Concoction from the Cocktail Menu. More Campari, and a Tangueray Negroni followed. Then Scotty and I sampled: The Chilled Crabmeat Cocktail & delightful Fried Calamari Appetizers. For the entrées, my Boy had a perfectly cooked Medium Rare Filet Mignon, with Asparagus. I chose The House Special, a melt-in-your-mouth Veal Chop Parmigiana, with a side of Spaghetti Bolognese.Two and a half hours into our meal, we made room for dessert. Scott had the largest Lobster Tail, stuffed with Whipped Creme and drizzled with Chocolate Ganache Sauce, that I’ve ever seen. He paired that with a Frangelico Coffee. I had an Assorted Sherbet dish with 5 Amazing flavors of Sherbet, and paired that with a Double Espresso and Romana Sambvca…...I purposely parked two blocks away, in Marine Park, Brooklyn, as I knew I would need a stroll after this tremendous dinner, and I have no problem walking City Streets around Midnight, even though I’m carrying a Louis Vuitton “Murse” clutch. My friends know what I bring to the party…..LoLoLoLoLoL.My dear friends, Matthew Mari, Esq. (Famous Defense Attorney), and Billionaire Businessman, Political Talk Show Host, John Catsimatidis and a whole host of politicians also dine here. As a former Finance Chairman of The New York Conservative Party, I can see why. Additionally, I understand that this is a favorite restaurant of Andrew Dice Clay’s and of Joe Piscopo’s, amongst a whole host of other celebrities. The Management; Chef, Kitchen Staff and Waitstaff are most Attentive, Amazing and Uber Professional. Michael, John and their Staff made our visit to Michael’s simply I N C R E D I B L E ! ! ! I highly recommend this establishment. YOU WILL NEED TO MAKE RESERVATIONS. Ask for Michael, and tell him MR. BIG RED from Table #1 at Park Side sent you….Bon Appétit, my friends!!! Thank you to all of the Great Folks at Michael’s for making our “Boy’s Night Out” a Spectacular one, across the board. We’ll be regulars!!!Kindest regards,MR. BIG RED.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Braised Short Ribs & Fried Gnocchi, Baked Clams, Marinara, Veal Alla Michael's
Although we had reservations we had to wait almost 1/2 hour for a table. But that’s the only complaint. The food was amazing, the staff was super friendly and out party of 6 really enjoyed.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
A#1......Everything!Dietary restrictions: They will pretty much make anything to your needs.Kid-friendliness: YesWheelchair accessibility: Yes
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tiramisu, Veal Scaloppini Sorrentina, Braised Short Ribs & Fried Gnocchi, Grilled Pulpo, Bread Basket, Lamb Chops, Baked Clams, Coconut Cake, Marinara, Risotto Mare, Lobster Bisque, Michael's Seafood Hot Antipasto, Fried Lobster All Michaels, Chicken Parmesan, Veal Alla Michael's, Homemade Tortoni, Chicken Alla Michaels
Michael's of Brooklyn on Avenue R... Just sounds inviting, doesn't it... This warm upscale italian eatery since 1964 did not disappoint! Were we're greeted by Yo Cuz, ;) if you know you know.... The service was exceptional, every dish, we left nothing behind... In addition to having no clue what a wonderful meal I was in for, I had Spumoni for the first time!!!!! >SCREAM< it was so good, no actually like the best!!! (no I don't live under a rock) just started to live a little!So good! Just so good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Braised Short Ribs & Fried Gnocchi, Grilled Pulpo, Crab Cakes
Great food but my cousin got her plate 20 mins after the whole table
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Food and service was delicious. Can’t wait to return. I highly recommend this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bread Basket, Baked Clams
Great food, drinks, and service. Get here earlier for on-site parking otherwise that's the only hassle.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tiramisu, Lamb Chops
Great food. Couteous staff. Fine atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tiramisu, Baked Clams
From the bread basket to the main course delicious food and great service. That cappuccino and wine selection you just can’t go wrong.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
The best old school Italian around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This was my second time at this restaurant. The first time my friend took me there for my birthday, the food was delicious and the service excellent. This time I took my husband there for his birthday, my husband is not easily impressed. When we got there is said this is lovely, I said to him Waite until you order your dinner. At the end of dinner he looked at me and said I'm empress.
My family and I have only been here for lunch, over the last month we dined in 3 times with reservations. The food is delicious and on the expensive side. Our recent visit left a sour taste in our mouths. We had let our server know early on that we would be ordering 2 additional meals to go around the time we'd order dessert, yet when we were done eating the 2 waiters in the restaurant would not acknowledge us. The busboys were very attentive in wrapping our leftovers, but understandably unable to take any food orders. My father tried to get assistance for almost 20 minutes, the dining room was empty besides us with the exception of one other guest, whom one waiter was speaking to with his back to us for the entire time we were attempting to order. We come from restaurant backgrounds and this was shocking behavior, considering how quiet the restaurant was and the cost no longer seemed appropriate for the service level. We had hoped to keep this restaurant as a weekly visit but have totally reconsidered ever returning.
Me and My Husband decided to try out Michael’s for the ball drop on New Year’s Eve 2024. We had the best night of our lives here. The food was incredible, The service was amazing and the place was packed and fun. We also didn’t want to judge this place by this one night considering it’s New Year’s Eve, and it was packed and it could be a little hectic and crazy because of the holiday, but they did not disappoint at all. We are still talking about how amazing this whole experience was. The whole feel of the restaurant was just perfect. The food was absolutely fantastic, and everything came out in perfect timing. Our waiter John was outstanding and made us feel very welcomed. There was live music which made the night even more perfect, and the decor was phenomenal. I also love that we could get very dressed up and how classy this place is. We will be returning on January 20th for my birthday celebration. ? and I can’t wait.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best Italian restaurant in Brooklyn. Service is top notch and food is amazing. I patronize this restaurant often and never have had a bad meal. This is where Italians go to eat when they want a truly home cooked meal. Highly recommend!!!