25 Best Italian Restaurants near Cicero

“We ordered through Doordash, the delivery did not take long at all and the food arrived hot. We got bbq wings (extra crispy) and the grandma's pizza. The wings were okay, decent quality but definitely not extra crispy. No big deal. The pizza was AMAZING. Fresh sauce, melty cheese, fresh basil, Italian seasoning, with a nice Sicilian style crust. So glad this place isn't too far from home! We will definitely get dinner from there again.“

“I’ve gone here for years and never reviewed because I never really think about voicing my opinion but I decided to finally. As a long time customer the food is amazing I’m never disappointed, I always get the same thing pizza, wings, mozz sticks and a 2 liter and it’s all amazing each time. The people are really cool and focused that’s how you know they care about what they do. They treat you with respect and appreciation this is the type of business you want to support because you know you’ll never be let down when you wanna order some good pizza.“

“I previously made a review that I was unsatisfactory with my experience and I have to say after going back I definitely have changed my mind. I was promptly asked about my not so great experience and they made it right. The food was amazing as it was the first time but service this time was perfect and attentive. This is officially on our list to make a reservation at every time we are in town. Love this place! Thank you pastabilities crew for everything“

“Small, family owned business. We've been ordering delivery for a few years but decided to go in to order tonight. We're so very glad we did! We chatted with the owner, Tim, while our order was being prepared. Extremely nice man, the staff is awesome. Wednesday will be pizza night from Amore from now on! The food is so much better than the "other place on the corner" and more wallet friendly. Support local!!“

“It’s consistently rated the best restaurant in Syracuse, and there’s a pretty good reason: it’s really, really good. The staff is friendly, the atmosphere is nice, and the food is delicious.For the quality of food you receive, it’s also shockingly affordable. 2 entrees, 2 alcoholic beverages, and an appetizer was about $75.00.I would say that’s a pretty great deal for one of the best places around.“

“Wife and I had an appetizer of the day, brie with blueberry jam, and for the main course the Bolognese and Zozonne pasta dishes. The appetizer was delicious, as was the Zozonne. The Bolognese was good, but a little heavy on the rosemary for my wife. The service was excellent as was the atmosphere. Though all the tables around us were full, you could still easily hold a conversation.“

“This is where I go if I’m feeling a bit out of it or down-always come out feeling better. Also go there to celebrate -tonight for live music with the band Keep Up-Who are 5 stars as well!-Great food & staff with a family atmosphere. You can go wrong.Parking: If it’s ever too crowded parking across the street is an option for freeKid-friendliness: They love kids!“

“Delmonico's never disappoints with service or food! The only issue we had was it was freezing where we sat, the waitress advised whomever and the ac stopped for a few minutes but then kicked back on. Oh well, not stopping a return visit!!“

“This is my favorite local restaurant! The food is amazing Everytime. New featured drinks often. I've tried a lot on the menu and haven't had anything that wasn't delicious. It's not a huge place, which I prefer. The atmosphere is cozy and relaxing, staff is on point!. The owner is usually there and very engaging and friendly! Try it you won't be disappointed.“

“This is our 3rd time eating there. They knocked it out of the park. Started with homemade rolls with garlic butter. Dinner came with a choice of salad or soup. My wife got the beef vegetable which was delicious. I was going to get the same but their salads looked to good to pass. It was loaded. Dinner didn't take too long and was delicious. I got the Italian trio. Chicken parm, lasagna, eggplant parm with pasta. My wife got linguini in lemon garlic sauce. Delicious. Both with huge portions.“

“Il Limone is one of the best authentic Italian restaurants in town. Every time you sit down to eat, you are guaranteed a great experience. If the delicious food isn’t enough to keep you coming back, the family who owns the restaurant will make you feel as if you are apart of the family. The staff makes sure you are satisfied, ensuring that you leave with a smile on your face and a full stomach.“

“If you’re looking for old school Italian dishes you need to visit Joey’s Italian Restaurant! We started with the calamari steak. It was incredibly delicious and cooked to perfection. We then had the tortellini carbonara which was amazing, and large enough to feed 2 people and we still brought home leftovers. Table-side Caesar salad made for a fun presentation. You won’t regret checking this place out! Our waitress Adeana was so attentive and personable.“

“First time here at this pizza place. Plain cheese isn't my favorite and do recommend pepperoni or sausage helps with the taste of the cheese mix. It's nice that you can see your pizza made in front of you if you order one direct than a slice. Have a good selection of Pure Leaf ice tea that I liked. Service is good and great with regular customers.“

“We had a birthday party at Twin Trees III and the service and food were exceptional. Not only did the kids get great pizza to share but the adult's meals were delicious. We had a back room to ourselves and they even cut and served the birthday cake we brought.Kid-friendliness: Kids menu“

“Food was great -- the marina reminded my husband of an Italian restaurant from his childhood. I had the antipasto salad -- which was ok, but the olives were the canned sliced kjnd -- not much flavor. Orecchiette with vodka sauce was tasty. They let my 17 yo (who is a super picky eater) order from the kids menu, so that was appreciated. Service was prompt & friendly. Other reviews mentioned that it had more of a bar vibe -- there was live music so that was a little much for one of my kids, but we knew to expect it. (We're traveling and finding a restaurant that appealed to everyone, was open and not too far off our route was a little tricky, but Brick & Brew fit the bill!). Would love to come back & try something from the wood fired oven!“

“We wound up here by accident. We were trying to go to a restaurant down the road and found out it was carryout only so we found Attilios! Our Server was lightning fast and very attentive. The food portions for the price was great. And just the fact it was hidden in the corner of an apartment building but had a very chic modern look but made you feel like you were 5 star dining. Overall a really good experience and would definetly recommend.“

“The food is delicious. Their red sauce is the best in Syracuse imo. It's currently take-out service only and it is well done. Everything you need is included or offered. The folks are extremely nice, very friendly and pleasant. Prices are very very reasonable too!“

“If you're in this area you definitely have to try this place. The sauce is really good definitely I would try the fried meatballs The garlic bread perfect. I have yet to try the calzone or any other food but I'm pretty sure it will be amazing“

“I'm a regular customer and love the food(favorite= Chicken Vesuvio). Great daily pizza slice specials- always fresh and delicious. Reasonable prices. Great, friendly and hard-working staff. Fun atmosphere when it's busy. I always enjoy going there“

“Whenever we visit our son in the metro Syracuse area, we always love to go to Carrabba’s!! The food and service are always excellent! Well cooked and so tasty! The serving crew are absolutely stellar!! Katrina R. is a super star ?!! Attention to detail, attentive to needs of the customer and always so kind and courageous!! We always love to see her!! Bravo again ! Carrrabbas!“

“I had the Lasagna. The portion was very large and it was pretty good. It could have been warmer but I didn't want to complain since it was slammed on a Sunday night with everyone in town for the eclipse. The house salad and dressing were very good. The bread was also nice and was served with butter and seasoned olive oil.“

“5 stars for this place.I have pretty low expectations when it comes to pizza shops but time and time again I am amazed at how great the pizza is here. It's some of the best I've ever tried. The Margherita is #1.Faleminderit shumë!“

“This place is hands down awesome, the food, the service, ambiance, can't even explain how good it is. Food is always awesome and done to perfection. Not many restaurants in the Syracuse area can even compete with this place. And the owner Charlie is one of the best. Always calls to see how your meal and experience was extremely nice guy. A lot of places have closed in our area. But the wife and I either go here. Or to the other steakhouse up the street. Daniella's located in the best western at the fair. Both places are phenomenal. Highly recommend. Great for live entertainment at times and all you can eat crab legs a few times a month. Located in the fair at the Old empire room.“

“I just left after having dinner and dessert. Not only was this some of the best food I’ve had, it was the best service! I had the pink vodka ravioli and the coconut butter cake (both 10/10). Sam, our waitress, knew the menu like the back of her hand. I was just accepted into Syracuse university, and not only did she take the time to share and chat with us about the city, but she even left such a kind note on our receipt. Truly such a great experience. Sam was absolutely amazing. Out of all the places I’ve eaten at in Syracuse, I HIGHLY recommend Francesca’s.“

“I recently had the pleasure of dining at Mario Salvo's Pizza, and I must say, the pizza was beyond incredible! It's a gem that I wish we had up north. What sets this establishment apart is not just the delicious food, but also the staff. They were extremely kind and went out of their way to make our experience enjoyable, especially with our small child. It's truly a family-oriented place, and I wholeheartedly recommend Mario Salvo's Pizza to anyone looking for a memorable dining experience. 4326 E Genesee St, Syracuse, NY 13214“