Forget your average slice joint! This place blows the other "pizza places" out of the water. The crust is perfectly crunchy, and the chicken parm bread is crispy and fresh. Either they bake their bread or get it from Arthur Avenue, not sure, but it's that good. Hands down, the best pizza I've had in a long time. Picked it up on my way home from work, will drive there from Ossining 100%. I already ate the Chicken Parm sandwhich or I'd show a photo, will do next time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Max Lara
I’ve been there three times in the last couple of months and the last time was 3 days ago. Second time I ate there I was bothered by an upset stomach for the next few days but I didn’t think anything of it. Fast forward to the other day and I had two plain slices and they looked pretty old (not fresh). A few hours later I had the upset stomach again and today is my second day with the worst diarrhea I’ve ever had. I will never eat there again. They need to do better with their food.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
shea Gormley
Guy scammed me for a deal that was posted on the menu, it was “walk-in special” for two slices and a can for $6, he said it was for “school children only” yet it doesn’t mention ANYWHERE on the menu that the special (which was clearly posted with the others) is for school children only. Not going again, 1:00pm on a Tuesday with nobody inside should be a dead giveaway of how they do business.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Monica
So good!! We discovered Saw Mill Pizza through TooGoodToGo, and I’m so happy that the app brought us here.The food is as good as the staff is friendly, and I can’t wait to come again for the pizza soon :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Charles WB
Great food, fast service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
tortisecorpse
Service was great just did not like the
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Mr. D.
We tried Saw Mill pizza for the first time this evening. The owner was very friendly, kind and welcoming. We had a variety of different pizza slices and each one was delicious. We will be back.
Marie Graham
A good friend (former NYer) was visiting from CO, and was jonesing for some good pizza....really anything with good crust, sauce/fillings. CO altitude prevents dough from being anything but mundane. So we went here...had a slice of pizza, split a sausage roll. and took an order of garlic knots home to go for her mom. WOWZER! Pizza crust was thin and nicely done, toppings were in proportion. (Thinner crust with over abundance of toppings is not enjoyable, it's a mess) I had chicken buffalo slice, she had I think garlic and broccoli raab. We're going back on the way to the airport next week :)
jeannette jewell
I was in town visiting and stopped in this friendly neighborhood pizzeria with my mom. Everyone was super nice and attentive. The pizza was delicious! I'm also a lover of penne vodka and their's was made perfectly well! Would definitely recommend this place! They also have ice cream which was cool.
Michael Zier
Ordered a specialty slice from the prepared display, a General Tso Chicken slice Crust was tasty. The General Tso sauce had more salt than I could consume in 3 super sized fries. It tasted like the bricks deer hunters put out to attract bucks. Also, it was expensive. $5 plus tax for a slice of pizza. I suspect I need a bank loan for a whole pie.
Great, friendly, attentive! I ordered 3 plain pies cut in half for my class. They brought it exactly on time and even gave me a discount. Definitely will order again. !!! Hot, crispy, amazing cheese, and sauce. I definitely recommend !!!!
chris G
Granted it was late when I went to order food. The beef patty was ok, I was expecting a little more flavor and the dough seemed old. The chicken Parmigiano, the chicken patty is thin and was cooked to long as you can clearly see in the picture. Maybe my expectations was a little high since it had a high rating. The person who prepared my order was more interested with what was on TV then preparing my meal.
Forget your average slice joint! This place blows the other "pizza places" out of the water. The crust is perfectly crunchy, and the chicken parm bread is crispy and fresh. Either they bake their bread or get it from Arthur Avenue, not sure, but it's that good. Hands down, the best pizza I've had in a long time. Picked it up on my way home from work, will drive there from Ossining 100%. I already ate the Chicken Parm sandwhich or I'd show a photo, will do next time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’ve been there three times in the last couple of months and the last time was 3 days ago. Second time I ate there I was bothered by an upset stomach for the next few days but I didn’t think anything of it. Fast forward to the other day and I had two plain slices and they looked pretty old (not fresh). A few hours later I had the upset stomach again and today is my second day with the worst diarrhea I’ve ever had. I will never eat there again. They need to do better with their food.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Guy scammed me for a deal that was posted on the menu, it was “walk-in special” for two slices and a can for $6, he said it was for “school children only” yet it doesn’t mention ANYWHERE on the menu that the special (which was clearly posted with the others) is for school children only. Not going again, 1:00pm on a Tuesday with nobody inside should be a dead giveaway of how they do business.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
So good!! We discovered Saw Mill Pizza through TooGoodToGo, and I’m so happy that the app brought us here.The food is as good as the staff is friendly, and I can’t wait to come again for the pizza soon :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food, fast service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Service was great just did not like the
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
We tried Saw Mill pizza for the first time this evening. The owner was very friendly, kind and welcoming. We had a variety of different pizza slices and each one was delicious. We will be back.
A good friend (former NYer) was visiting from CO, and was jonesing for some good pizza....really anything with good crust, sauce/fillings. CO altitude prevents dough from being anything but mundane. So we went here...had a slice of pizza, split a sausage roll. and took an order of garlic knots home to go for her mom. WOWZER! Pizza crust was thin and nicely done, toppings were in proportion. (Thinner crust with over abundance of toppings is not enjoyable, it's a mess) I had chicken buffalo slice, she had I think garlic and broccoli raab. We're going back on the way to the airport next week :)
I was in town visiting and stopped in this friendly neighborhood pizzeria with my mom. Everyone was super nice and attentive. The pizza was delicious! I'm also a lover of penne vodka and their's was made perfectly well! Would definitely recommend this place! They also have ice cream which was cool.
Ordered a specialty slice from the prepared display, a General Tso Chicken slice Crust was tasty. The General Tso sauce had more salt than I could consume in 3 super sized fries. It tasted like the bricks deer hunters put out to attract bucks. Also, it was expensive. $5 plus tax for a slice of pizza. I suspect I need a bank loan for a whole pie.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great, friendly, attentive! I ordered 3 plain pies cut in half for my class. They brought it exactly on time and even gave me a discount. Definitely will order again. !!! Hot, crispy, amazing cheese, and sauce. I definitely recommend !!!!
Granted it was late when I went to order food. The beef patty was ok, I was expecting a little more flavor and the dough seemed old. The chicken Parmigiano, the chicken patty is thin and was cooked to long as you can clearly see in the picture. Maybe my expectations was a little high since it had a high rating. The person who prepared my order was more interested with what was on TV then preparing my meal.
Great pizza, def try the grandma slice.
Great NY style slice :)
Good pizza and came very fast. Would reccomend.