Gay Bars near Fire Island, NY

Ice Palace Nightclub Gay Bar • $$
1 Main Walk, Cherry Grove

“Great entertainment-the club has been largely rebuilt by new ownership, with sound system upgrades, air conditioning, and just long neglected maintenance overall. The espresso service in the morning is great, and the entertainment in the club is great, featuring nationally recognized acts: Paula Poundstone, Patti Lupone, Joey Arias, etc. The Friday night Underwear Party is the biggest and most successful ongoing event in all the surrounding communities.“

3.8 Good5 Reviews
Cherry's On The Bay Gay Bar • $$
158 Bayview Walk, Cherry Grove - 3.08 miles

Customers` Favorites

Good Morning Burger
Seafood Platter

“This is one of the best places to go on fire island for sure! Some great food and drinks and all the staff is great! There’s also drag shows at various times and that is awesome entertainment !!! This isn’t for everyone, you need to be aware that this is a gay area of fire island and so if you can’t handle that then stay home. However everyone is friendly and accepting and there’s never any issues or problems, you just have a great time! There’s a dance floor and outdoor area for dining,drinking or just hanging about.dress is very casual or as fancy as you would like to be. Either way it is a great time and only around in the summer…“

4.1 Good58 Reviews
Marina's Bar + Grill American •
42 Harbor Walk, Fire Island Pines - 4.18 miles

“Really nice atmosphere. The brunch menu is a little small, but the options are pretty good. My friends and I got a carafe of mimosas, they were $42 so not bad. There's basically a full bottle of prosecco and triple sec in it, so extremely strong for a good price. My brunch burger was pretty good, the burger was a little over cooked but overall good. The garlic fries are fabulously seasoned and very crispy so I loved them.“

3.8 Good4 Reviews
The Blue Whale Gay Bar • $$
Harbour Ln, Bay Shore

“Really nice atmosphere. The brunch menu is a little small, but the options are pretty good. My friends and I got a carafe of mimosas, they were $42 so not bad. There's basically a full bottle of prosecco and triple sec in it, so extremely strong for a good price. My brunch burger was pretty good, the burger was a little over cooked but overall good. The garlic fries are fabulously seasoned and very crispy so I loved them.“

2.6 Average5 Reviews
Pavilion Gay Bar •
36 Fire Island Blvd, Sayville

“A nice venue with an amphitheatre-like interior for events and parties.Stunning architecture with a wrap-around balcony overlooking the Pines harbor.Service was unphased at the bars and relatively unfriendly at the entrance. Door is cash only and there is just a single ATM so it takes a long time to get inside.Overall a fun place.“

2.3 Poor6 Reviews
Sip·n·Twirl Gay Bar • $$
36 Fire Island Blvd, Fire Island Pines

“I never have a bad time here, but that's largely because of the crowd. Sometimes the music is incredible, like when Susan Morabito spun that Sunday of Pines Party. During the week it can be the only spot to meet other people or deads-ville. Either way, go and check it out. It can be fun.“

1 Poor2 Reviews
Loading...

Fire Island’s related cuisines

map Map