Stone Street Grill

630 Stewart Ave, Garden City
(516) 280-9414

Recent Reviews

Cocoa L.

We went Thursday, March 14, 2024 for happy hour and the doors were locked! No sign on the door explaining why! Nothing! Private party I don't think so! It was pitch black inside. It was supposed to be the kick off to their St. Patty's Day celebration. We called the business number listed and there was no answer. Disappointed.

Gail R.

Tried to go to happy hour on Thursday 3/14/24...there were advertisements for a st Patricks day celebration. When we got there, the doors were locked!! No sign explaining why. Just locked!! We were not the only people confused. And dinnerless

They were closed, I think they closed down for good. I was not happen we had to find somewhere else to eat after we had reservations at stone street. They really need to update there website or leave a message on there answering machine that they are closed permanently.

ʝ

Second best Mac and cheese in the world. Best portion of French fries that aren’t soggy. Great wings. Great service. Best artwork near a bathroom in a 20 mile radius. Unfortunately It’s to original & unique of a spot to be popular with the locals. Only downside of going out to eat anywhere is the ball sports ! Always ball spots on a tv . Imagine movies or tv shows only. That will be the day I give a ten star review

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

R P

It’s nice to have a new sports bar in the neighborhood. Love the place. Wish them success.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

T F

You’d be surprised to find out that the worst part about this place isn’t the food. It’s actually the manager and wait staff. Absolutely rude and would never return. Nonetheless, the food itself tasted frozen and processed. The burger isn’t bad but the rest, absolutely not.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

M S.

I created a yelp just to write this review. I have come to this restaurant on three different occasions because I believe sometimes, you can have a bad day. However, every time I come here I am consistently met with the same issues - bad food and bad service. It is clear that they are not ready to serve to the public. The wings were a soggy mess. I have never described chicken wings as soggy before. The burgers are dry. Clearly frozen food you can just make at home. Additionally, service is slow and the staff is always so rude. I am trying to support a local business (especially because the place is always empty), but every time I come here, it seems like they are actively trying to drive customers out. From the bartenders, to the waitstaff, to the manager, I am always met with hostile, confrontational, and mean vibes.

Tyler F.

Will never go back. The food was absolutely horrible, essentially frozen food. The manager is EXTREMELY rude. Staff rude about splitting checks at the bar. Drinks priced at NYC prices.

Had a good time, and service was attentive. We started with the tacos and my wife had the Hawaiian skirt steak and I had the prime rib special. Both were cooked well and tasty. The s'mores gelato to end the night was tasty.

Allison Hoffman

First time here and I absolutely Love it ! The food and drinks are absolutely great! Nicole and Steve were awesome! I found my new hang out place. I had the rotisserie chicken, highly recommended!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pollo, Chicken Wings

Ricardo H.

I've been to SSG twice once with co-workers and this past weekend with friends. Each time everything was excellent! Our server, Steve was great and Nicole went up and beyond for us! The food was very tasty and cooked properly. My favorite were the wings! I will definitely come back.

James B.

Lisa and Nicky can make any drink you can think of even if you don't know what you want. The service couldn't be any better

Ricardo Hartley

Place was awesome. Went for a work event and had plenty of space. Nicole and Violet?.(sorry if I forgot the name!). were awesome. I'll definitely be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings

Notti Foster

Food and dessert was

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Crispy Wok Fired Calamari, Stone Street Stack Burger, Skirt Steak

Marc Rosen

good food, service and atmosphere. I would go back.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Load More