“The owner and the young guys working tonight were amazing. My coworkers and I were the only ones in the restaurant and they treated us like we were guests in their house. The pizza with all meats was the best I've had in a long time. When he said that he was gonna put all the meats they had on it, he wasn't lying. And it wasn't too much to where it took away from the consistency with the pizza sauce and crust. Altogether it was great and I would recommend to anyone wanting pizza dining in. And they deliver too!“
“I had heard good things, and then read good reviews... but nothing could've prepared me for "The Italliano"!!!! This is one of the best sandwiches I've had in my life. THICK, FRESH, and DELICIOUS. I will absolutely be returning and can't wait to try more things. Also, the people working were incredibly friendly, and I got the sense that they take a lot of pride in the great food and service they provide. So glad I came in!!“
“What a fun and quirky place! Loved the bar downstairs. It was filled with locals who you could tell have been coming here for years. The portions were gigantic and the food was really well made. The pasta was super fresh and seems homemade. Looking forward to trying more.Dine in: Yes“
“Great pizza and Cheech is the best! He has known myself and my children since they were very little. Went in recently and it was like talking to a family member. They do deliver so I do not know what that complaint was about. The delivery truck is outside the store. White Ford Escape with Jon Angelo's written all over it. If you think the pizza doesn't compare to city pizza, then don't eat here. I'm from the city and it's very close to the same. The portions of the meals are huge! I had to split an order of chicken parm with my daughter it was so big. Service is always friendly!“
“Nailed the sauces! That's everything to a Vegetarian! Carlos & his family have been feeding me, my family & friends for over 20 years. Scratch kitchen. Consistent fresh produce & ingredients in all of his dishes. I dine in for the lunch specials but also enjoy the dinners. Quick service when I eat alone or with a crowd. Tables accommodate a dozen customers often. Cozy ambience. Loyal, friendly staff service you with authentic caring smiles. Large parking lot right out front. Open later hours than most local establishments. Walkers and wheelchairs have easy entry. A Go To favorite even multiple times per week!“
“Northern nj native here, been on the search for the best pizza in the area for 8 years. Alas...Found it!!! You absolutely need to order the Grandma pie from Goshen Pizza Tomato Pie, it is phenomenal. Also, I use them for catering often and everyone always raves. Their penne vodka and sausage and peppers are also chefs kiss. Great, friendly service as well. Adore this place“
“What an amazing find after a day at Legoland. Unpretentious, sincere hospitality and solid food cook with passion. The owners/management were most welcoming even though we were just walk-ins in casual clothing. Our servers Jose and Yovardy were always on point, genuinely warm and attentive. Thank you for having us.“
“BEST DEAL IN LEGOLAND! ~$25 for a large pizza that feeds a family of 4 when it was over $65 for lunch at a certain pirate restaurant? I'm in!My wife and I are Long Island pizza snobs, so we didn't expect much. All we wanted was a reasonable meal our kids would eat. However, we were pleasantly surprised. While it didn't meet the standards of even the saddest Tri-State mom and pop joint, the pizza definitely topped the usual national chain suspects. The restaurant itself is cozy and entertainingly themed, and the staff was courteous.When we come back to Legoland, this will be our lunch.Vegetarian options: They have cauliflower crust, which we didn't try, and cheese and veggie pizzas. It's easy to avoid the pepperoni.“
“Always a pleasant experience and as a Vegan, regardless of menu stating V or not they always go above and beyond to ensure there's an option for every person. Even so many GF options as wellVegetarian options: Many vegetarian options possible“
“I drive through Goshen once in a blue moon. It was snowing this day and I figured pizza was the best choice for lunch. This was my first time at this pizzeria. I got a Sicilian slice and Bacon Chicken Ranch slice to go. Let me tell you. Delicious!!!“