7 Best Bakeries near Hampton Bays

Familia Bakery Colombian •
252-9 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays

“Enjoyable find of a Colombian bakery that has been here 8 months already. Would have stopped in sooner if had noticed sooner.People come for their beef empanadas made here.They also make Choladas so so - way to tough a customer spoiled up island in Hicksville - not in the same league but tried it and enjoyed it. The owners family manufactures Macarons in Pachogue and has them here in many flavors. Not a fan of sugary sweet macarons but the hosts always convince me to try and I can never eat them LOL sooo sweet. But the Nutella and another she recommended were ok. The Nutella slightly easier. Yes stop in and get a slice of cake here - tres leches, caramel cheesecake slices etc.“

4.8 Superb29 Reviews
Krieg's Bakery Bakery • $
39 W Montauk Hwy #7, Hampton Bays

“The best in town and a lot of others. Excellent service unbelievable home made delicious baked goods. It’s hard not to get it all try the cookies and if you are lucky enough to see a apple turnover there get two so good you will regret not buying three.“

4.1 Good34 Reviews
Antojitos bakery Bakery • $$
40 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays

“Delicious. Generous portions. Friendly service. We left incredibly full with leftovers. "Mata hambre" is for real.Loved the arroz con pollo and the kid enjoyed the open- faced Colombian arepa. Fun music and great view of the busy street out the window.We will be back.“

3.7 Good18 Reviews
Hampton Coffee Company Coffee & Tea • $
194 Mill Rd, Westhampton Beach - 7.71 miles

“Staff is great. Coffee is awesome.I pass by here at least every few weeks and always make it a point to stop in. I get a latte with oat milk. It gives me the pick-me-up that I need. They sell their coffee in bags as well. I highly recommend their breakfast blend but all of them are good.If you’re local or just in the area, definitely make it a point to stop here and order anything on the menu.“

4.8 Superb23 Reviews
The Treatery Long Island Bakery •
1564 Main Rd, Jamesport - 6.5 miles

“I was introduced to Christina from The Treatery by Danielle at The Montauk Distilling Co. The Treatery catered mine and my wife Brittany’s Rehearsal Dinner held at the Distillery this past September 2023. The girls at The Treatery did an AHHHHmazing job, with a huge assortment of dips, chips, snacks, sandwiches and boujee desserts, our guests were so impressed. Everything was delicious and displayed so beautifully. Thank you ladies for making our Wedding Weekend kickoff utterly delicious!!T&B“

4.6 Superb28 Reviews
Dari-Land Ice Cream Shop • $
51 Main Rd, Riverhead - 8.23 miles

“This is my favorite ice cream shop. I’ve been coming here since I was a young child and I still do because their service has always remained the same! The people are so sweet and kind, plus their servings are REASONABLY GREAT portions unlike other places.“

4.5 Superb33 Reviews
Ali Katz Kitchen Bakery • $
55 County Rd 48, Mattituck - 8.47 miles

“Every time I order from Ali Katz Kitchen I am not disappointed. This recent order of mac & cheese was excellent. Although it was frozen solid when I picked it up, it cooked up perfectly. This simple dish is just one example of the consistent quality of every thing made at Ali Katz.“

4.8 Superb9 Reviews
Loading...
map Map