Comfort Food Restaurants near Lancaster, NY

“Our first time. We're "locals". We will DEFINITELY be frequenting! Had the Shep' Pie. Let me just say, mmm mmm MMM! The beef just melted and the sauce was exquisite! The veggies were perfectly cooked and everything was seasoned JUST RIGHT! No extra salt OR pepper needed!!! Other party members ENJOYED the thinger tenders, and thinger sandwich. (* explanation below)Their list of sauces is just WOW! It can be found on the chalkboard on the wall. ;) The fries, fresh cut of course (delightfully, a common theme of the menu!) Soups were PIPING hot! Also very, VERY good! We will definitely return and sample other items. * - Thinger - the are fresh made and not prepackaged. Party members indicated it was dark meat (thighs) or maybe a 50/50? I can not personally attest to that.“

“the food was amazing!! best scallops I've ever had, so light and fluffy and flavorful. small yet friendly place. will definitely be back“

“Great burgers and more ! Outside tiki bar and bands“

“I had a wonderful experience , I was passing through on my to Niagara Falls and I wanted something local and I found this amazing wonderful food and wonderful atmosphere staff was very nice and the boss/owner was just a loving and sweet lady made sure I was well fed !“