“I went there tonight for pizza after seeing other favorable reviews on Yelp and Facebook. I would certainly go back. I ordered a grandma pie with pepperoni, mozzarella sticks, baked clams and garlic knots. My entire family enjoyed everything, great sauce, great pizza. The owner and staff were all very friendly and accommodating. We will definitely be back!!!“
“Vinny the pizza guy! His awesome and has an amazing personality ,his pops too.On Sunday's ,I swing by to get a pizza pie created by him,just for me. He has always greeted me by saying "How you doing?" Big and loud. He make me ?“
“Hands down the best Pizzeria around/in the game The Pizza as well as the food is always Hot, fresh , and absolutely delicious, extremely generous portions, excellent prices As someone who is exremely picky with their Italian food this place exceeds all expectations Anthony really knows what he's doing highly recommend!“
“This was our first time trying this restaurant. Everything we ordered was delicious. We ordered pizza, baked pasta dishes as well as some Mexican items. Everything was perfect! The people that work add this beautiful clean pizzeria were all very courteous and kind. I felt the price for everything we got wasa little less than what we've paid at other local places.We look forward to going back again very soon as there were so many other nice things to try.“
“This is the perfect place to stop and grab a slice. Great pies. Local spot. Lots of variety. Super fast, super cheap. Amazing quality. I will say I throughly enjoyed the chicken buffalo but it was super mild. I was hoping for a kick. The pepperoni was amazing. I could have eaten 3 more slices. I'm gonna hit this place at least two more times while I'm here working to try the others. Bbq, veggie, garlic knots.. all looked amazing and the perfection on this crust and sauce leads me to believe they likely are. It's a self seating, get your own drink, and don't hold up the line kind of place. I can see how lunch with kids would be tough. Can't wait to try another slice!“
“The best pizzeria on Long Island in my opinion. Love stopping in for lunch or dinner with the children. The staff are always so helpful, there's always a great selection of top quality food, and they are awesome with my children. Can't ask for better! The place is always clean as well. Pictures from previous visits“
“I’ve been going here for over 10 years and always enjoyed my experience. The food is consistently getting better. Combine that with the atmosphere and you can’t lose. This is an old charming building which smartly has no tv sets, great atmosphere, candles on the table, table cloths, etc. I think you will love it.“
“This is my all time favorite place. Great for a quick bite or a sit down. I recently had a birthday dinner celebration here and not only did everyone absolutely love the food and atmosphere but the service was phenomenal as well. The owner is the nicest restaurant owner I have ever met. Every time my boyfriend and I dine there we say we just had the best meal of our lives. Then we go back again and it just keeps getting better. I am excited to continue living so I can keep eating their food.My top three entree picks:Penne Castello, Shrimp Fra Diavolo, and the Rigatoni alla VodkaAs an additional note: I am an Italian woman that's been eating Italian food my entire life... and this food is UP there.“
“Open, cozy, clean, and well lit. Nice music selection, classical and operatic ballads.Booth was comfortable. Service was friendly though a bit slower-paced. This allowed us time to chat and look at the menu, but if we were pressed for time or starving, it might have been an issue. Food was great! Spinach, strawberry, and feta salad and spinach salad with bacon and mushroom both were tasty and not overdressed. Grandma slice had lots of saucy tomatoes and peppers. I didn't specify crispy, but I did wish it were crispier. Fried calamari appetizer was served with a generous bowl of delicious marinara. A few of the pieces had a hard bit. Would definitely come back!“
“Ugh hate my fat fingers, should be 4 stars. Today was our first visit. We celebrate Palm Sunday with our married kids and grandkids. Very nice decor, all staff super friendly and attentive. Apps came out hot and well cooked. A large menu selection and everyone was pleased. Kids portions plentiful. The adult portions as well came out hot and food was fresh. Will be coming back in May for uncle birthday. Daughter in law and her friend order pizza from here often. Definitely worth a try. UPDATE..coming here Saturday for daughter in laws birthday, CAN'T WAIT. YUMMMM. Upped my review to 5 stars after todays birthdayndinnernfor ky daughter in law. Appetizer came out hot and entrees were hot,nplentiful and delicious. Will be back soon. UPDATE AGAIN....tonight we went for a so long dinner for my nephew and his son who are going back to Seattle tomorrow. And ONCE AGAIN they did not disappoint. We were 11 people in a totally full house and it was perfect. The service, the food hot and plentiful and the general ambiance is everyone enjoying themselves with a delicious meal. Thank you.ANOTHER UPDATE. Today we again had our family Palm Sunday dinner. Mama Lisa did not disappoint. Staff friendly, food abundant, hot, fresh and delicious. Thank you Mama Lisa.UPDATE 12/5/21 Came with family for my birthday dinner. It was crowded but it did not detract from our service. We were greeted right away and ordered drinks and appetizers. Everything was perfect. The owner stopped by our table several times. The staff came out with my dessert that had a candle and sang happy birthday to me. You are never taken for granted here especially if it's crowded. YOU MYST TRY MAMA LISA, you will not be disappointed!UPDATE APRIL 11 2022. We had our family tradition of Palm Sunday dinner at Mama Lisa. We are 6 adults and 4 children. We were not disappointed. The staff is amazing and accommodating. The food, oh the food, is always perfect. Fresh, hot, and plentiful. We all leave full and happy. YOU WILL NOT BE DISAPPOINTED.UPDATE Palm Sunday 2023 was another we are a family if 10, 6 adults 4 children 12 to 3, and there were two other tables with more and the restaurant was full. Our server Ally was engaging and patient through the entire process. If course the food was PERFECT came out hot and plentiful.If you have a family event, this is the place to go, reasonable prices and delicious and accommodating. ENJOYUPDATE 2024 PALM SUNDAY another perfect celebration. Our waiter Eric was a joy to deal with. We all have our favorites from year to year and they don't disappoint. Our 4 grandkids get the chicken fingers and French fries which are plentiful and perfectly cooked. Thank you again for making our tradition going on perfectly.“
“I had the pleasure to stop in Crust around the Corner this past Sunday and I was very happy I did. The slices were perfect. The owner treats you with respect and is happy to serve you. I noticed how clean they also keep the place. Its a win win if you stop in for a visit next time you are hungry.“
“we used to go here all the time, and then we moved to Farmingville. Sometimes we take the trip out there which is not too far I now order on Uber eats and they have the best food and garlic knots! The house dressing is by far hands-down, the best I’ve ever had, my daughters asked me to order it tonight and I have been sick for a few days and couldn’t eat so I decided to get there chicken noodle soup. OMG! This is the best chicken noodle soup that taste like you made it at home, with fresh vegetables and fresh chicken , it is extremely tasty and really helped me“
“Highly recommend coming here best pizza place ever the staff here are so kind. Don’t be afraid to ask anything they’ll do it. They are Always asking me when I sit down and eat “how’s the food” it’s always delicious. They are great cooks“
“I love Papa Nick's but what a disaster. Look at this slice of pizza. Portnoy would have a melt down. This slice should of never been allowed to leave this pizzeria. Its almost like walking out your front door wearing crocs. It just shouldn't have happened. The only reason why I gave 5 stars is to support my local community.“
“We chose them to catering a party as their menu was diverse than a regular Italian restaurant. We ordered Eggplant Parm, Chicken Piccata, Roast Beef and Gravy, Baked Ziti, Pork Tenderloin stuffed with spinach and feta, Grilled Veggies, Roasted Potatoes, and an Italian Hero. Our guests LOVED the food, as did we. Many asked where we ordered from so they can use for their upcoming gatherings. We will absolutely use them again in the future, and will certainly be visiting more often for take out.“
“Awesome place, food and service was top shelf.And the price was super compared to the amount of food and drinks that were orderedParking: Located around back with plenty of spaceKid-friendliness: 2 Grandkids enjoyed the place and loved their food“
“Had a wonderful dinner here a couple nights ago. Their soups are off the chart’s delicious. Calamari crazy good and huge portion. They give you a complimentary delicious homemade bread with butter, olive oil & a tomato spread. Food was delicious. Staff was amazing. Huge portions of delicious food.“
“Came to just pick my dad up some soup since he was sick (he said the soup was amazing, we got their special of the day it was chicken with orzo) and ended up grabbing a slice for myself since I was starving. I don't know what this slice is called but it turned out to be one of the best slices of pizza that I've had in awhile. Asked for it extra hot and so it was crispy on the bottom. Thick chewy dough (in a great way) and the crunch from the bottom, unreal. Sorry for the half eaten pizza pic, as I was scarfing it down I knew I had to leave a review for it“
“Wonderful food and relaxing atmosphere. I has the chicken special, which comes with entree, salad, side, dessert, and coffee for a very reasonable price. My ceasar salad was great. The bread with olive oil dipping sauce was tasty. My Chicken Marsala was hot, juicy, delicious, with no hint of oversalting. My angel hair side was hot and cooked to perfection. For dessert, the cannoli is to die for. Little explosions of sweetness and creaminess. The decaf is an honest cup of coffee. Not too strong, not too weak, no weird flavoring, and accompanies the cannoli perfectly.I’ve had the same meal here twice and it was fantastic both times.“
“This place is a gem. Food is fantastic, portions are large, service is great. It's the closest thing to a home cooked meal you'll get at a restaurant. Try the Alfredo sauces and the soups, they're especially good but honestly everything I've ever had there is tasty.“