Restaurants near Mayville

Music for your Mouth 21 S Erie St, Mayville Cafe • $
21 S Erie St, Mayville

Customers` Favorites

Avocado Toast
Big Daddy Burger
Signature Cake by the Slice
Turkey Bacon Club Sandwich
Sausage Gravy & Biscuits
Cotton Candy Cheesecake
Guacamole

“We just had brunch here today, all of the food was delicious. Home made soups with lots of flavor, and delicious sandwiches. ? The service was also EXCELLENT! Family owned business that cares about its customers.”

4.8 Superb95 Reviews
Olde Corner Deli 6344 County Touring Rte 54, Mayville Sandwich Shop • $
6344 County Touring Rte 54, Mayville

Customers` Favorites

Italian Sub
Beef on Weck

“Just Visited today People are very friendly the atmosphere is light. Order and pay once food is ready.No wheel chair rampNo bathroomParking limited.There are Big Ice Cream Sandwiches in mini freezer. Looks yummy.Also have potato salads and othe cold salads.”

4.9 Superb26 Reviews
Truffle Honey Eatery 3943 NY-394 suite 2, Mayville Bar & Grill • $$
3943 NY-394 suite 2, Mayville

Customers` Favorites

Truffle Honey
Caesar Salad
Truffle Fries
Charcuterie Board
Wood Fired Burger
Brussels Sprouts
Breakfast Pizza
Chicken Wings
Smoked Caesar
Creamy Mushroom Chicken Pasta

“Second visit here, really good food and wine options. Refreshing to see this place sticking around, as there aren't many options around the lake....especially of this caliber.Shout out to Brooke for taking care of me at the counter bar (Nya:wëh Sgë:nö’.....Ja:göh!). Strongly recommended stop if visiting the area.”

4.6 Superb95 Reviews
Big Inlet Brewing 6169 Elm Flat Rd, Mayville Brewery • $$
6169 Elm Flat Rd, Mayville

“Such a fun spot! They have tons of beers, everything brewed on site. The Oh Fudge stout was our favorite. Located in a really cool refurbished barn. Phenomenal service. A must try if you're in the area!”

4.9 Superb18 Reviews
Skylar and Sophia's Lemonade Stand 5985 Fishermans Ln, Mayville Family
5985 Fishermans Ln, Mayville

“Outstanding lemonade for a very reputable price. These little girls work so hard to make their homemade lemonade. Made with fresh spring water and real fruit. What a great thirst qencher on a hot summer day.”

5 Superb4 Reviews

6
Docks

Docks 7 Water St, Mayville Seafood • $$
7 Water St, Mayville

“My husband & I were visiting the Chautauqua area and every other restaurant we went to was closed on a Saturday no less. We stopped at Docks by chance. The decor is not fancy but our meal was excellent and the service was great! We would definitely go here again.”

4.6 Superb7 Reviews
Boxcar Barney's 13 W Lake Rd, Mayville Ice Cream Shop • $
13 W Lake Rd, Mayville

“Good ice cream but they lie on there menu small 1 scoop,medium 2 scoops, and large 3 scoops and that is a lie. The small is the size of 3 scoops the medium is 6 scoops and a large is as big as a football”

4.4 Superb36 Reviews
Hartfield Bay Cafe 6040 E Lake Rd, Mayville Cafe • $
6040 E Lake Rd, Mayville

“A quaint, charming, cheap bar. Old school. Lazy dog included in the decorations. Outdoor pavilion with games, indoor pool table. Decent selection of cold beers in the old school fridge and a nice selection of pub grub.”

4 Good3 Reviews
Andriaccio's Restaurant 4837 W Lake Rd, Mayville Italian • $$
4837 W Lake Rd, Mayville

Customers` Favorites

Calzone
Calamari
Garlic Bread
Fried Dough
Shrimp Portofino
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Tiramisu
Pizza Logs
Caesar Salad
Linguine with Clam Sauce

“Ate here tonight, happy to see they were open on eclipse day. Husband’s shrimp portofino was 5 star, my beautiful grilled salmon on pearl cous cous was heaven. The asparagus cooked perfectly. Thank you!!”

4.2 Good79 Reviews
Bellini Lounge 215 W Lake Rd, Mayville Burgers • $
215 W Lake Rd, Mayville

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Wings

“What an amazing place to go. The place looked amazing and the aesthetic was outstanding. The service was great and just seeing how they treat you is an experience in itself. But the best part was the food. I can't describe how delicious it was. Keep it up!”

3.3 Good16 Reviews
Webb's Carryout + Cafe 115 W Lake Rd, Mayville Coffee Shops • $
115 W Lake Rd, Mayville

Customers` Favorites

Iced Caramel Macchiato

“The food was good overall. I had the chicken piccata and it wasn't what I expected. Just wanted to try something different. Should have gotten the prime rib since it is delicious. Service was great and the restaurant is beautiful inside and out.”

3.1 Average86 Reviews
Bemus Point Inn Restaurant 4958 Main St, Bemus Point American • $
4958 Main St, Bemus Point - 9.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cinnamon Bun
Waffles
English Muffin
Jumbo Cinnamon Roll
Hashbrowns
Steak & Eggs w Hash Brown Casserole & Toast
Homefries

“A Very pleasant experience. Great Food, Great Service, Great atmosphere! Highly recommended if you love good-old country style breakfasts, or some newer idea choices, or a sweet roll you'll need a take out container to bring the other half home (THEY ARE HUGE)! Great place!!”

4.9 Superb67 Reviews
Full Strength Coffee Company 55 E Main St, Westfield Coffee Shops • $
55 E Main St, Westfield - 6.04 miles

Customers` Favorites

Avocado Toast
Lemon Lavender Scone
Smoothie Bowl
Full Strength Bowl Eggs Bacon B Spinach Roasted Veggies and Cheese
Everything Bagel with Egg and Bacon
Lavender and Lemon Scone

“There are some fresh & tasty whole foods options on their menu. The drinks are often readily customizable for any dietary needs. It has a friendly and welcoming atmosphere with a cozy hometown feel. The service is always top notch.”

4.9 Superb49 Reviews
The Parkview 3 E Main St, Westfield American • $
3 E Main St, Westfield - 6.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Pot Pie
Eggs Benedict
Cobb Salad
Gourmet Grilled Cheese Sandwich with Soup
Tomato Bisque and a Ruben
The Parkview Cold Plate
Fantastic Chicken Salad
Chicken Pesto Sandwich
Citrus Shrimp Salad
Neptune Benedict

“Drove by at least 100 times. Decided to stop as my wife was hungry. Literally enjoyed everything about the place. My chicken pot pie was so good I took their buy 10 get one free offer. Spent $35 on brunch and another $120 to go. I'll be back next Spring for sure. Oh yeah the owner stayed late so I could retrieve my forgotten cell phone. Highly recommend reservations and recommend through and through. Mike”

4.9 Superb47 Reviews
The Cornerstone 104 E Main St, Sherman American • $
104 E Main St, Sherman - 8.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fish Fry
Sandwich
Sausage Gravy
Salad
Cherry Cobbler with Vanilla Ice Cream
Rodeo Burger and Fries
Breakfast Pizza
Homemade Bread
Western Burger

“Let me paint the picture for you. We walked in and to the left are 5 older gentleman having coffee and chatting away. Soft music playing and the bakery items right straight ahead. You know it’s a local favorite. We went headed over and found a seat. One waitress and she knew the names of the customers. She was quick to get our drinks and take our order. We had the French toast muffins. She answered all our questions and was very personable. You could tell she liked her job. The food was fantastic, the atmosphere was great, the service was excellent. We will definitely be making the trip again to eat here.”

4.9 Superb37 Reviews
Lake Life Café 22 Main St, Bemus Point Coffee Shops • $
22 Main St, Bemus Point - 8.73 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sandwich
Avocado Toast
Croissant
Frozen French Toast Latte
Sourdough Toast
Italian Panini
English Muffin
Cake Pop

“We stopped in over the summer for brunch and everything was delicious. The Iced Chai Latte was to die for, have to try their Oreo truffles. Vibe was cute, will go back whenever in town.”

4.9 Superb36 Reviews
Portage Pie 42 N Portage St, Westfield Bakery • $$
42 N Portage St, Westfield - 6.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

Key Lime Pie
Apple Crumb
Concord Grape and Peach Pie
Peach Blueberry Pie
Blackberry

“I was so excited to discover that our airbnb was only 8 minutes from Portage Pie while we were visiting NY for the solar eclipse. I've been a fan of owner Connie's posts in a pie baking community on Facebook for many years, so it was serendipitous that I was so close to her shop without even knowing it. We arrived on Sunday morning right at 11 when they opened. I was worried the selection would be limited since we did not pre-order, but they had many extra fruit pies and cream pies for us to choose from. We got an apple crumb and a cherry pie. The crust is so crispy, and the fruit fillings taste fresh and just like homemade. Our cherry pie was still warm when we got it. I highly recommend Portage Pie for quality that is so hard to find in modern-day bakeries!”

4.9 Superb29 Reviews
Village Restaurant 5447 E Lake Rd, Dewittville Breakfast • $
5447 E Lake Rd, Dewittville - 3.26 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cinnamon Roll Pancakes
Sausage Gravy

“Great food and reasonable prices, in a casual, friendly, atmosphere. Service is consistently excellent. The food is always very good and comes in generous portions.”

4.8 Superb28 Reviews
Red's Best Pancake House 2749 County Touring Rte 15, Sherman Breakfast • $
2749 County Touring Rte 15, Sherman - 10.87 miles

Customers` Favorites

Extra Sausage
Great Pancake and Sausage Breakfast with Coffee and Orange Juice
Pancakes with Homemade Sausage

“Upon our arrival, we had no wait to be seated. The waitress told us we had perfect timing because they start getting busy around 9. The waitress was very friendly and enthusiastic to be serving us. The food took about five minutes to arrive to our table. The food had lots of flavor, and the syrup was warm, which is always great.My daughter said that five stars isn't enough for this wonderful breakfast experience.”

4.9 Superb16 Reviews
Guppy's Restaurant & Tavern 4663 NY-430, Bemus Point Seafood • $$
4663 NY-430, Bemus Point - 6.45 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fish Tacos
The Buffalo Chicken
Stromboli
Corn Cake
Chicken Alfredo
Quesadilla
Bacon Cheeseburger with Steak Fries
Beer Battered Haddock Fish Fry
Meatball Sub with Fries
Mussels Appetizer

“No words. You just have to go see for yourself. Our server, Natalie, was great. And the owners also checked on us. Very humble people. There's a Bluetooth speaker inside each gondola.”

4.6 Superb67 Reviews
Brazill's on Main 7 E Main St, Westfield American • $$
7 E Main St, Westfield - 6.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Stuffed Mushrooms
Pan Seared Sea Scallops
Maple Brined Grilled Pork Chop
Bacon Wrapped Shrimp
Maple Mustard Grilled Salmon
12 Oz Steak Dinner Special
20 Beer Braised Short Ribs
Steak with Whiskey Sauce
Braised Beef Short Ribs
Bruschetta Crostini

“Steak with Whiskey Cream Sauce, mash potatoes and snow peas. And a raspberry pie with vanilla ice cream. Amazing food, drinks and great service!!Parking: Free street parking out front or free parking lot around back”

4.6 Superb61 Reviews
21 Brix Winery 6654 West Main Road, Portland Wineries • $$
6654 West Main Road, Portland - 8.01 miles

“Felt so welcome when visiting during a rainy March weekday. My daughter and I shared a flight and Bavarian pretzels. This location is exactly what you want a winery tasting location to be like: large, open seating area with a large bar in the center; clean and shiny floors, walls, furniture; smiling faces who are willing to chat and discuss the wines; a gift shop with branded souvenir items, and just all around cozy environment even though it’s really large. They’re building an addition for events and more summer activities, so I look forward to visiting again during the summer.”

4.6 Superb45 Reviews
Annex 25 25 E Main St, Westfield Bar • $$
25 E Main St, Westfield - 6.04 miles

“What a charming and elegant place in Westfield! I would definitely visit again for great music and cocktails. A must-visit if you are looking for quality night life in Lake Erie wine belt.”

5 Superb7 Reviews
Tap Room & Grill 43 E Main St #1303, Westfield Bar • $
43 E Main St #1303, Westfield - 6.04 miles

“Friendly bartenders. Cheap drinks. Pool table. They don’t serve food anymore but you can order from Lena’s next door and they will bring it to you at the bar.”

4.8 Superb11 Reviews
Nickel Plate Depot 131 Central Ave, Brocton Bar • $
131 Central Ave, Brocton - 10.14 miles

“Everything was excellent. Food was great, so was service. Right close along rr tracks, trains come thru fast. Can't wait to come here again and get a patio seat. Train Action!!”

4.6 Superb25 Reviews
Larry's Cantina Restaurant 11-13 N Portage St, Westfield Bar & Grill • $
11-13 N Portage St, Westfield - 6.05 miles

“Larry's is a pillar of the community in Westfield! No frills, Cash only (there's an ATM just inside the door), simple but excellent bar food that comes out hot and fast! Their wings are incredible - I recommend the "Bernie's Special Sauce" On any given night there can be 2 - 40 people. There's the bar to the right that seats about 10, maybe 12? Then a bunch of tables/hightops/standing shelves. Bartenders are quick, nice, no-nonsense. No fancy cocktails here, basic brews, spirits, and great food! Light bar fare, burgers/wings/fried apps maybe a fish sandwich here and there. If you like wings and hometown bars, stop in for an hour and take in the scene. Only open evenings.”

4.6 Superb22 Reviews
Westfield Main Street Diner 40 E Main St, Westfield Diner • $
40 E Main St, Westfield - 6.01 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pancakes
Grilled Cheese
Hash Browns
Breakfast Sandwich
Egg Meat Toast
Cinnamon Roll
Home Fries

“I was extremely comfortable and felt at home. The atmosphere is family-friendly, and the staff is extremely attentive. The food was delicious, especially the fries. The prices are very reasonable. I highly recommend ?”

4.5 Superb65 Reviews
St. Stephens Cafe 2 W Main St, Brocton Cafe • $
2 W Main St, Brocton - 9.84 miles

Customers` Favorites

Belgian Waffle

“Amazing food, great manager, great staff. I highly suggest trying the frozen Chai and Stop Me it's like a morning treat in a cup.Parking: There is a parking lot and drive-thru around back. The parking lot has 35+ spaces, and there is plenty of free street parking.Kid-friendliness: The management and staff are incredibly nice to my kid and offer a small play area for the kids to have some fun in. My kid always gets excited when we dine in.”

4.6 Superb20 Reviews
Calarco's Restaurant & Lounge 15 Market St, Westfield Italian • $
15 Market St, Westfield - 6.06 miles

Customers` Favorites

Coleslaw
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Chocolate Pecan Pie
Antipasto
Meatball Float Platter
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Cajun Broiled Haddock
Meatballs in Sauce
Spaghetti Sauce
Sausage Dinner

“I've been a regular customer for years and the food has always been consistently good. Over the years they have always remembered me and the friends that I have brought in. They're very nice people.If there is a problem with this business, beyond being a little dated (which is easy to overlook), is the lack of a manager that would oversee the service and dining room issues.The owner is the cook, which explains the good food, but the inconsistent service, dirty tables and other service issues that others have complained about could be easily fixed if someone in authority was watching. Lack of management is their Achilles heal.(That, and a tiny $6 side salad which we were told was the same size as their garden salad which baffled one member of our party. They spent $17 on a cup of soup and a tiny salad. I was embarrassed for them because they couldn't explain the difference between the two salads on their menu. A manager could have fixed that - but I digress.)”

4.5 Superb52 Reviews
Farmer's Daughter 8373 US-20, Westfield Ice Cream Shop • $
8373 US-20, Westfield - 6.26 miles

“I absolutely love this place! The fresh cut curly fries are amazing, and I always get a really good hot dog. The ice cream is also amazing and they make the best sundaes!”

4.6 Superb17 Reviews