I've tried a ton of NY pizza places so my expectations might be a bit high. I had the plain slices and they were decent, not overly thick crust with a thin layer of cheese. Prices are more reasonable and they don't charge city prices. Garlic knots are a must have here, they give you a ton of tomato sauce as a dip. Like any pizza place, they offer a decent selection. Ton of seating here so no need to worry. No parking lot and paid meter parking.
Dan R
Ordered delivery through UberEats. Food was delicious but portion sizes were a bit disappointing. The penne alla vodka didn't even cover the whole bottom of the tin in a full layer. It maybe covered 80% in a single layer of pasta/sauce. The lasagna was two small squares, filling only about slightly less than 50%of the tin. The deep dish was fantastic, crispy, chewy, but not under/overcooked. I'm a little wary to get pasta again (especially for $20 when the portion was so small), but I'd def get the pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Carlos Danger
This place is so lgbtq friendly that they one of them working behind the counter, the taller guy with the glasses
Robert Intelisano
Carlo's pizza is a must try when in Middle Village! Excellent regular slice, pepperoni bites and very good value for the price. I suggest leaving with a jar of their special homemade sauce, since 1966!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Diane Distefano
Great food great guys Good prices.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Carlo's Upside Down Pizza Slice, Baked Ziti, Chicken Francese, Sicilian Pizza, Pepperoni Upside Down Pan Pizza Drizzled with Mike's Hot Honey, Vodka Sauce
MARIA MACALUSO
Love those guys always so friendly and professional.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dan D
Can be a little hectic inside during busy times and a wait for your order but it's always worth it for the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christina I.
Ever since I went to Italy, I've been trying to find pizza and other food that tastes just like it's been in Italy. I have yet to find that until this place. Their rice ball is almost exactly like the one I had in Italy. The people here are so nice and the food is so fresh. The service here is absolutely amazing very attentive very catering. I highly recommend coming here and trying the homemade sauce. It is just like an Italian grandma came to your house and cooked it for you. Highly recommend this place.
Joshua Grossman
Great local pizzeria solid choice on the avenue for
Good service/friendly staff, efficient process to order your food. I enjoyed my plain slice and a grandma slice. There was a good ambience, it was spacious with good seating availability. I would come back if I'm in the neighborhood again. And I'm definitely fascinated by the Garlic Knot sliders the offer.
Gordon Y.
Though it's a good slice, not sure about all the raves and the extremely high rating. Personally, I have been here several times and would rate it a solid 7/10. Unfortunately, I prefer a zestier sauce and theirs lack a zing. Regardless, I would stop by if I'm in the neighborhood, but unlikely drive out of my way.
Dorjee Gyaltsen
The experience is 10/10Workers are very friendly, understanding and well respected. It’s worth going there & Service is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marlene R.
I was crossing by the area and I noticed this pizzeria, I read the reviews and I was excited , I was hungreee for a good pizza slice to my surprise I was so disappointed, their pizza slice tasted like the supermarket bought sauce, RAGU ;( so disappointed
MTA Ethan Fan Support
I love this pizza restaurant in Middle Village. It definitely feels like I’m in the 60s. Really decent?
I've tried a ton of NY pizza places so my expectations might be a bit high. I had the plain slices and they were decent, not overly thick crust with a thin layer of cheese. Prices are more reasonable and they don't charge city prices. Garlic knots are a must have here, they give you a ton of tomato sauce as a dip. Like any pizza place, they offer a decent selection. Ton of seating here so no need to worry. No parking lot and paid meter parking.
Ordered delivery through UberEats. Food was delicious but portion sizes were a bit disappointing. The penne alla vodka didn't even cover the whole bottom of the tin in a full layer. It maybe covered 80% in a single layer of pasta/sauce. The lasagna was two small squares, filling only about slightly less than 50%of the tin. The deep dish was fantastic, crispy, chewy, but not under/overcooked. I'm a little wary to get pasta again (especially for $20 when the portion was so small), but I'd def get the pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
This place is so lgbtq friendly that they one of them working behind the counter, the taller guy with the glasses
Carlo's pizza is a must try when in Middle Village! Excellent regular slice, pepperoni bites and very good value for the price. I suggest leaving with a jar of their special homemade sauce, since 1966!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food great guys Good prices.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Carlo's Upside Down Pizza Slice, Baked Ziti, Chicken Francese, Sicilian Pizza, Pepperoni Upside Down Pan Pizza Drizzled with Mike's Hot Honey, Vodka Sauce
Love those guys always so friendly and professional.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Can be a little hectic inside during busy times and a wait for your order but it's always worth it for the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ever since I went to Italy, I've been trying to find pizza and other food that tastes just like it's been in Italy. I have yet to find that until this place. Their rice ball is almost exactly like the one I had in Italy. The people here are so nice and the food is so fresh. The service here is absolutely amazing very attentive very catering. I highly recommend coming here and trying the homemade sauce. It is just like an Italian grandma came to your house and cooked it for you. Highly recommend this place.
Great local pizzeria solid choice on the avenue for
Food: 5
love this place !!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Good service/friendly staff, efficient process to order your food. I enjoyed my plain slice and a grandma slice. There was a good ambience, it was spacious with good seating availability. I would come back if I'm in the neighborhood again. And I'm definitely fascinated by the Garlic Knot sliders the offer.
Though it's a good slice, not sure about all the raves and the extremely high rating. Personally, I have been here several times and would rate it a solid 7/10. Unfortunately, I prefer a zestier sauce and theirs lack a zing. Regardless, I would stop by if I'm in the neighborhood, but unlikely drive out of my way.
The experience is 10/10Workers are very friendly, understanding and well respected. It’s worth going there & Service is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I was crossing by the area and I noticed this pizzeria, I read the reviews and I was excited , I was hungreee for a good pizza slice to my surprise I was so disappointed, their pizza slice tasted like the supermarket bought sauce, RAGU ;( so disappointed
I love this pizza restaurant in Middle Village. It definitely feels like I’m in the 60s. Really decent?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5