Delicious food and great service. The ambience was fun and lively. It was too noisy for us and the seating was very tight and not that comfortable, but we knew that going in. The experience was enjoyable despite that.
Jamie C.
I used to like coming here before or after a rehearsal, sit at the bar and have dinner and a drink. The bartenders have gotten progressively worse. The drinks are good, but the service is less than desirable. They will ignore you or completely forgot that you ordered. It's a shame but I guess I'll have to find another taco joint to frequent.
Delicious food for drinks. Service was excellent even though it got very crowded before we left. It seemed that the tables were too close for anyone to move around especially the waiter.
Justin Pontier
I've always had a soft spot for Playa Betty's – it's practically an institution on the Upper West Side. Every time I return, I'm pleasantly surprised by their ability to keep things fresh and exciting on the menu. Their latest addition, the brunch menu, is no exception. It's a true smorgasbord with options catering to all tastes, and each dish is a delightful fusion of beachy flavors.For the health-conscious, the breakfast burrito bowl stands out as a nutritious yet satisfying choice. On the flip side, the French toast is a sinful indulgence that is worth every bite. One thing not to miss is their customizable guacamole; where they bring you a tray full of goodies to allow you to tailor the guac to your exact preferences.Stepping into Playa Betty's for brunch feels like a mini getaway to the sunny shores of California. Highlights include their inventive twist on chicken and waffles with the fried chicken and churros, a refreshing cactus mimosa, and, of course, their stellar taco selection.If you're in search of a great brunch spot on the Upper West Side that ticks all the boxes – relaxed atmosphere, reasonable prices, and generous portions – look no further than Playa Betty's.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Onali F (Oni)
It was my first time at Playa Betty’s and I had a wonderful experience! Our server Joshua was super sociable and the atmosphere was great for a night out catching up with friends.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Queso
Haley Planicka
Can’t get enough of this place. Amazing food, wonderful atmosphere, and friendly staff- Joshua was the best!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They didn't keep a table for us... eventually seating us outside with people who hadn't made a reservation... the heat lamp was broken... it was freezing... food was cold and dry and looked like it had sat on the plate for about an hour. Overall awful
NancyD
Had 6pm reservations on a Friday but arrived about 20 minutes early. Taken to a high top table that would be shared with others not in our party. I asked if we could switch to a two-person high top instead which they accommodated. Server was friendly and knowledgeable. Ordered the totchos appetizer which would have been good if it was served hot (it was just barely luke-warm). Drink specials were good. Surprised that you had to ask for chips and salsa (it wasn't actually on the menu as an appetizer). Carne asada tacos were good. Overall good experience at a fun-themed and busy restaurant.
Chandani P.
It was my first time at this place. If you're looking for great mexican food THIS IS YOUR PLACE! Also, Joshua was my server and he was sooooo sweet and we even ended up talking about silly things in between ordering which was so phenomenal and made me experience ten times better. 10/10 recommended especially if you're tired of "boujee mexican food" that tastes like shit.
Floria Poe
Love their tacos!! The bartenders are great and made delicious drinks. They also have happy hour. It’s a mice place to hang out with your friends to enjoy drinks small bites.
We came at a busy day and time , a beautiful Sunday afternoon right before the show at Beacon Theatre. We sat outside since the weather was very nice. Staff did their best to serve as accurate and fast as possible. Of course there were mixups and waiting etc but they were so kind and did their best. We like the appetizers we ordered and margaritas were fine too. There was not even one table available and glad I made a reservation:)Kid-friendliness: There were many families with kids and they look like they’re having fun
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Queso
Trevor B.
Not a bad place to grab something. I ordered the Hang 10 Burrito. The steak was cooked just as I ordered. There honestly wasn't too much flavor though. I thought the fries on the burrito would be more flavorful. They needed more pico on the side to add to the burrito as well. The venue was nice, clean, and open. They had outdoor seating as well. In the basement they have a comedy club that opens in the evenings. The service was good.
Adecio D.
Great California style Mexican food! The queso with chorizo was a standout, as well as the chicken enchiladas. Their frozen Palomas are also great, maybe a little strong!
Monica S
Delicious queso and chips!! Churro ice cream sandwich is pricey for what you get. I liked the fish tacos and short rib tacos. This place is very popular and usually busy in the Upper West Side. A fun place to get Mexican food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Churro Ice Cream Sandwich, Queso, Side Queso
Sydney Breitkopf
Awesome food and great vibes here! Would definitely come back. Joshua and Janice gave great service, made eating here a wonderful experience!
Delicious food and great service. The ambience was fun and lively. It was too noisy for us and the seating was very tight and not that comfortable, but we knew that going in. The experience was enjoyable despite that.
I used to like coming here before or after a rehearsal, sit at the bar and have dinner and a drink. The bartenders have gotten progressively worse. The drinks are good, but the service is less than desirable. They will ignore you or completely forgot that you ordered. It's a shame but I guess I'll have to find another taco joint to frequent.
Delicious food for drinks. Service was excellent even though it got very crowded before we left. It seemed that the tables were too close for anyone to move around especially the waiter.
I've always had a soft spot for Playa Betty's – it's practically an institution on the Upper West Side. Every time I return, I'm pleasantly surprised by their ability to keep things fresh and exciting on the menu. Their latest addition, the brunch menu, is no exception. It's a true smorgasbord with options catering to all tastes, and each dish is a delightful fusion of beachy flavors.For the health-conscious, the breakfast burrito bowl stands out as a nutritious yet satisfying choice. On the flip side, the French toast is a sinful indulgence that is worth every bite. One thing not to miss is their customizable guacamole; where they bring you a tray full of goodies to allow you to tailor the guac to your exact preferences.Stepping into Playa Betty's for brunch feels like a mini getaway to the sunny shores of California. Highlights include their inventive twist on chicken and waffles with the fried chicken and churros, a refreshing cactus mimosa, and, of course, their stellar taco selection.If you're in search of a great brunch spot on the Upper West Side that ticks all the boxes – relaxed atmosphere, reasonable prices, and generous portions – look no further than Playa Betty's.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
It was my first time at Playa Betty’s and I had a wonderful experience! Our server Joshua was super sociable and the atmosphere was great for a night out catching up with friends.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Queso
Can’t get enough of this place. Amazing food, wonderful atmosphere, and friendly staff- Joshua was the best!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They didn't keep a table for us... eventually seating us outside with people who hadn't made a reservation... the heat lamp was broken... it was freezing... food was cold and dry and looked like it had sat on the plate for about an hour. Overall awful
Had 6pm reservations on a Friday but arrived about 20 minutes early. Taken to a high top table that would be shared with others not in our party. I asked if we could switch to a two-person high top instead which they accommodated. Server was friendly and knowledgeable. Ordered the totchos appetizer which would have been good if it was served hot (it was just barely luke-warm). Drink specials were good. Surprised that you had to ask for chips and salsa (it wasn't actually on the menu as an appetizer). Carne asada tacos were good. Overall good experience at a fun-themed and busy restaurant.
It was my first time at this place. If you're looking for great mexican food THIS IS YOUR PLACE! Also, Joshua was my server and he was sooooo sweet and we even ended up talking about silly things in between ordering which was so phenomenal and made me experience ten times better. 10/10 recommended especially if you're tired of "boujee mexican food" that tastes like shit.
Love their tacos!! The bartenders are great and made delicious drinks. They also have happy hour. It’s a mice place to hang out with your friends to enjoy drinks small bites.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Taco Dinner Platter
Restaurantji Recommends
We came at a busy day and time , a beautiful Sunday afternoon right before the show at Beacon Theatre. We sat outside since the weather was very nice. Staff did their best to serve as accurate and fast as possible. Of course there were mixups and waiting etc but they were so kind and did their best. We like the appetizers we ordered and margaritas were fine too. There was not even one table available and glad I made a reservation:)Kid-friendliness: There were many families with kids and they look like they’re having fun
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Queso
Not a bad place to grab something. I ordered the Hang 10 Burrito. The steak was cooked just as I ordered. There honestly wasn't too much flavor though. I thought the fries on the burrito would be more flavorful. They needed more pico on the side to add to the burrito as well. The venue was nice, clean, and open. They had outdoor seating as well. In the basement they have a comedy club that opens in the evenings. The service was good.
Great California style Mexican food! The queso with chorizo was a standout, as well as the chicken enchiladas. Their frozen Palomas are also great, maybe a little strong!
Delicious queso and chips!! Churro ice cream sandwich is pricey for what you get. I liked the fish tacos and short rib tacos. This place is very popular and usually busy in the Upper West Side. A fun place to get Mexican food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Churro Ice Cream Sandwich, Queso, Side Queso
Awesome food and great vibes here! Would definitely come back. Joshua and Janice gave great service, made eating here a wonderful experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Queso