The Mermaid Inn

$$ • Seafood

570 Amsterdam Ave, New York
(212) 799-7400


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for The Mermaid Inn

We have never missed at the Mermaid Inn. We like to sit at the bar which has plexiglass dividing every two seats. The bartender Landy is friendly, professional and just want you want in a bar tender; never pushy but attentive. We appreciate their happy hour with excellent beer @$6 and signature cocktails or wine @$9; Clams and oysters @$1.25 ea. We share appetizers such as calamari salad and Portuguese squid, perfectly dressed with veggies. This is topped off with full review

Excellent service. At the front desk and throughout the dining the staff was just wonderful - helpful, patient and attentive. Great value for the happy hour. However, I’ve eaten there before and the lobster rolls were much better. These were a bit salty, as was the calamari. Unfortunately, the coffee was not hot. The oysters were delicious and the chocolate mousse finale is a delightful treat.

Wonderful for a date night! Every single thing we ordered was delicious. Such a great value, especially if you come early for the happy hour deals and stay for dinner. Our server, Jesse, was outstanding. Overall just a great dining experience, hard to find in the city.

More Reviews(479)


Monday 4:30 - 10PM
Tuesday 4:30 - 10PM
Wednesday 4:30 - 10PM
Thursday 4:30 - 10PM
Friday 4:30 - 10PM
Saturday 11AM - 2:30PM
4:30 - 10PM
Sunday 11AM - 2:30PM
4:30 - 9:30PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.