The Molly Pitcher Club

675b 9th Ave, New York
(646) 490-7329

Recent Reviews

Joe Peterson

Was only gonna stop by for a glass with the team on our way down to a different bar, but the music and staff locked us in here for a few hours! Robert is a great bartender. 10/10 time.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Alex Wider

Very chill atmosphere, very nice server and bartender, and good music. Excellent if you're looking for a chill place to get food and drink. Robert the bartender was a great drink mixer and good company!

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Josh S.

Amazing service! Bartender was willing to make a drink that was not on the menu and nailed it. The bar has a great vibe. I would highly recommend the Molly Pitcher Club.

Lauren S.

great vibe! smells great as well! service was incredible. definitely recommend! Bartender was able to complete a specialty order as well.

Marcos M.

Popped in, got a great burger and had a great conversation! Very fun cocktail bar with a good low volume, and the drinks were great!

Lara M.

Had a great time here. I like how they arrange the place and how music is just right for the ambiance. Spicy Margarita was my fave. Dave at the bar was good.

Evan K.

Carissa was awesome! Amazing experience!! Very attentive and we felt ourselves very comfortable!

Gary S.

A was very happy with the food, service and atmosphere. Cerissa P was very attentive, kind and helpful. A great meal and a great time!

Stacey Besse

Stepped in this gem for some drinks. The ambience was intimate and cozy. The drinks were delectable? Definitely worth the visit!

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Gilad Levy

awesome bar!!

Kristina B.

Had the pretzel roll and Shark Week, which I decided wasn't for me, so I got a spicy margarita instead and *that* was quite good. Stopped in on a Wednesday and on a whim. Service was lovely, vibe was chill.

Jillian B.

Me and my group for friends stopped into Mollys for some cocktails! We had an amazing experience and got the bluberry smash and whiskey sours. They were made to perfection by the bartender Samantha and her outgoing and fun energy really made Mollys a great time!

kevin gonzalez

This place is a hidden gem. We stumbled upon this place on a Sunday looking for a a happy hour and it was HH until 10pm! No where in the neighborhood can compare. Came back on Wednesday around 6pm and they were having 75 cent wings!!! Craaazyyyy I’ve never seen that anywhere. Great happy hour prices with the wings. The bar tender, Kareem, knew exactly what to make for everyone. I’d HIGHLY COME BACK.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sanket Shah

Avoid. Beer kegs all soured / spoiled. Bartender did not acknowledge or understand what was happening. Refused to comp the beers, even though multiple people said they tasted seriously off. Gave some weird line of reasoning, like "it's only nine dollars!". really dude?the kicker...the bar charges a 3% "processing fee" on top of tax/tip, which they have literally no explanation for (because there is none). Nickeling and Diming at its worst, while poisoning patrons and taking their money. What an absurd and tone deaf team, from ownership to service staff. truly unbelievable.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Morgan

This was a great experience but this is not the place to go to for a steak. The customer service was on point and I really liked the environment but this steak was horrible. My friend loved the pasta!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Load More