Jersey Mike's Subs

1223 NY-300 Suite 203, Newburgh
(845) 762-3762

Recent Reviews

Amelia

DO NOT EAT HERE UNLESS YOU WANT FOOD POISONING!!!! Place is FILTHY, the workers are beyond rude. We ordered 4 sandwiches today from this location and not a single one was edible. Bread hard as a hockey puck, slimy old tasting cold cuts and sour old tasting bacon. Never again. Please don’t spend your hard earned money here!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jason Anderson

Had a truly pleasant experience here. The guy who took my order and also made the sandwich was professional, polite, checked to make sure I was certain of order and said goodbye is a way that I felt good walking out. His service alone would make me want to revisit this location!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sandwich, Cheesesteak

Bo Redd

First time made a gr8 impression...will be back...scrumptious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gdhuvfg Jufschnjn

Gross and unsafe food handling practices. Whoever is the owner or manager seriously needs to go over with their staff the proper procedures when it comes to handling food. Like taking off their gloves when they handle money or maybe not keeping the knife they use to cut food by the register. The sad part is that the staff clearly do not care. If theyre willing to do those things in front of customers then what are they doing when there arent any customers around..

Service: 1

Cynthia DelValle

I wish they were friendlier, changed their gloves and wore their hair in a cap. I felt intimidated and rushed, watch them handle bags, register and food without changing their gloves and came home to a sandwich with hair in it.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Fernanda Durrell

This was my first time ordering from here and I must say I was very satisfied!!! The food was very delicious. I will definitely be ordering from them again.

Chuck

By far the worst location, I have ever been to. The sandwiches are the smallest regular sandwiches I have ever seen. I ordered a Buffalo chicken sandwich and got a sandwich that had gravy and no hot sauce. When I asked the counter person if this was a Buffalo chicken sandwich, I was yelled at by the 2 female employees and told I was banned from the location, which is OK with me because if they choose bad employees, why would I want to go back. And as I am writing this, the 1 female employee came outside and began yelling and threatening to call the police for harassment, which I hope they did. GARBAGE EMPLOYEES!!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Rhythm_ Ron

DO NOT GO HERE UNLESS YOU WANT TO ARGUE! There’s a very disrespectful girl who “feels she’s entitled” to talk and treat customers and with disrespect because her dad is the manager. This establishment is going to go down hill if this girl continues to work there! If I could give this place 0 stars I would! No professionalism what so ever! You can’t talk to people who’s patronizing your business any kind of way and think they are not going to respond! Trust and believe they won’t ever have to worry about me, my family, or any of my friends spending one red cent at this location!

Service: 1

Paul Howe

I was doing Uber eats and I was very thirsty. The lovely ladies there was so generous and gave me something to drink. I wanted to use my card and pay for it... but they refused.All my business will give to this place

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Don WOo

Great sandwiches, better to door dash than actually go to the location. This place gets ridiculous during lunch, I've seen lines out the door.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Sandwich

Colin “shaggy” MAC

I was perhaps overhyped for this restaurant, but after being SHOCKED by the cost I was unimpressed / felt the subs didn't quite justify the $$$

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Sandwich, Cheesesteak

Ruben Sandoval

It was 10 minutes to 9:00, they close at 9:00, so they hate me and made me feel bad for being there…

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Michael Joseph

The subs are good but everything else is terrible. Place is dirty and unorganized although they seem overstaffed by unfriendly employees. The prices are much higher than local deli's or pizzerias and the food isn't any better. Shop local and don't support this franchise chain sub shop. Poor service and high prices.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

McKiah Harvey-Hall

My co workers and I had placed a mobile order. It was only 4 subs and some chips. Once the order was placed it said it will be done at 11:58. I arrived at 12:05. A couple people were ahead of me at pick up which is fine. Their Lobby and line was full of customers dining in. Again not a problem. It looked like they were possibly understaffed, which I understand being in the customer service business, its not easy.. I waited patiently till they got all of the customers in line out. Meanwhile people had walked in after me in the regular line and got serviced first. The lobby then began to fill up with other customers looking for their mobile order or Uber eats. I was there till 12:50… we all got completely ignored, everyone was getting frustrated. It seemed to be that the girl who handed our food out was new, she was getting yelled at by the manager and her other coworker. I finally arrived back to work and realized some of our order was missing. A sub and a couple chips. None the less, don’t come here on a lunch break if you are expecting to get in and out quickly , mobile orders won’t do anything. Not sure if I will return.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 1

Patrick Cassidy

Incompetent management. Employees were friendly and got my order right. However they only had two working in the middle of a weekend lunch rush. Waited over 45 minutes for a pickup order and decided to have to cancel it. Management should’ve had atleast four employees behind the counter. Line was almost going out the door and couldn’t keep up with any mobile order. Felt bad for the two kids behind the counter.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 1

Load More