34 Best Caterers near Old Brookville

“Best BLT! Super delicious food and great service!“

“We had my daughter’s high school graduation party here and it was such a success!! Raj made the party planning process so smooth and easy and we weren’t worried about anything going wrong. He went above and beyond in making everything easier for us in every way. The venue was decorated absolutely beautifully. From the stage setup to the backdrop to the table centerpieces, everything was wonderful. All the guests could not stop commenting upon how gorgeous everything was. The food was also very good! Everyone had such a good time and talked so highly of the event. I can’t recommend Metropolitan Caterers enough; they made our celebration of this event so special!!“

“The Team at Antun’s made sure that my day was perfect! I’m the 70th Birthday Queen who would’ve forgotten her head if it wasn’t attached. The Masquerade Ball was outstanding. Antun’s made sure that we had everything we wanted, needed & so much more! Thank you all for making it so special! Love this place, great and friendly staff, Kemi made my day special, you will never be forgotten.“

“Made a reservation here for restaurant week. Apparently didn't need one. The place has its own parking lot with about a dozen spots. We entered the building which took us into the bar, which was bustling. The dining room was quaint, with some really nice booths and a fireplace that should have been lit. Our server was a good looking young man, pleasant, not overbearing with a sense of humor. We opted to include an additional appetizer of baked clams to our meal, along with the crab cake and winter salad, which I forgot to take photos of. My friend opted for the lamb chops while I had the branzino piccata. Yummy, although the menu never stated that the fish was served over a shrimp risotto. (I'm allergic to shrimp). Only 1 bone in the fish, so I was lucky. Our dessert consisted of tiramisu and rainbow cookie cheesecake. I was "fortunate" to get the last piece although not very cheesecake-y. All in all we had a nice dinner and will maybe return for another meal.“

“Absolutely the freshest seafood and excellent bar tender ???“

“My husband and I can happily say our wedding at Jericho Terrace was our favorite wedding we have ever been to! The venue is stunning with plenty of spots for photo opportunities, delicious food, and exceptional staff. The interior appearance was something that was very important to us since we were having both the ceremony and reception indoors given it was early April. Everyone we have come across is professional and passionate about providing the best experience possible. Of note, the maître d's, Raul and Anthony, continuously checked up on us throughout the evening and our bridal attendants, Alison and Kayla, were so caring and stayed proactive before we even knew what we needed. Our guests cannot stop raving about Jericho Terrace! I hope to be back soon as a guest to experience it all again (it goes as fast as everyone says it does).“

“Literally a 5 star experience and food is worth craving again. I don’t live in the area at all but I had it once and knew I had to come out and have it again. The staff is super friendly, patient and accommodating. And the coffee is amazing. You can make it yourself so it’s just the way you like. 10/10Dietary restrictions: Non-dairy options for coffee“

“I went there for my cousin’s wedding. Beautiful venue. Very spacious and on the lake. Very scenic. The food was delicious. The staff was great and friendly.“

“Gino was patient and took the time to explain to us all the different packages, in preparation for our wedding. After learning that my fiancé and I are both first responders, Gino extended his support and professionalism to us even more so! We are both looking forward to having him cater the dessert portion of our wedding, in addition to creating an unforgettable experience! Dolce and Gelato is the way to go!! Bravissimi!“

“Tracy and George are true masters of what they do! All of the food is fresh and delicious, the decor is always beautiful, and staff is just simply amazing and professional. I would highly recommend this business for any party or wedding reception that you may be planning. You will not be disappointed. ❤️“

“Whitby Castle in Rye, NY is the absolute best & most perfect place for a wedding & we very highly recommend it as your wedding venue! We got married in March 2024 on a Saturday afternoon at Whitby & it was better than we ever could have imagined thanks to the breathtaking venue & all the amazing managers & staff. We looked at 10 wedding venues in Tri-state area before finding Whitby, & we knew we had to get married there the minute we saw it. First was the gorgeous castle & grounds (flawlessly manicured lawns on Rye Golf club & striking views of LI Sound), & how the venue provided accommodations for all weather types. Next was the wedding package, which included everything needed & was the best price for all options; we couldn’t find a better price anywhere.From our first meeting w/ Niki, the Catering Sales Manager at Whitby, we knew we made the right choice. Niki handled everything w/ the venue throughout the process, including catering, vendors, amenities & all options available through Whitby. Niki took the time to get to know us & thoroughly explained the numerous elements to consider when planning our wedding. She made us feel as if she genuinely cared about us & our wedding (because she did). We later met w/ the Ops Manager, Ralph, about 3 weeks before the wedding & he was just as awesome. Ralph had all the particulars laid out for every aspect of our wedding & provided a comprehensive timeline & wedding plan. Niki & Ralph were incredibly professional & knowledgeable, & also exceedingly responsive & accommodating.Weather was no concern on our wedding day because of how Whitby operates. They have complete & functional outdoor heating throughout the wraparound patio that hosted much of cocktail hour, despite it being high 50°. We had wonderful sun on morning of our wedding, but it was windy & our ceremony would be on colder side in afternoon. We did not want our guests to sit in the cold, so we had an indoor wedding, & it was beyond stunning. The magnificent arch windows in the reception hall gave us astonishing light & scenic views for the ceremony. Regardless of weather, they set up for both options, to have our wedding inside or outside. We thought this was amazing considering how unpredictable weather can be. Some venues tend to have multiple weddings to maximize space, but we appreciated that Whitby treated us as the main event.In addition to astounding views & spectacular customer service, the entrées & various food courses were outstanding. I am not sure which our guests raved about more, the delectable food or marvelous views. We also have nothing but phenomenal things to say about Rosa, the bridal attendant at Whitby. Rosa was exceptionally attentive & helpful throughout the day. Niki, Ralph, Rosa, & our maître d', Gabriel, were all extremely organized & prepared for every scenario. There were so many moving parts & minute details involved in our wedding, but Gabriel was so on top of everything & made it a day to remember. The service was impeccable & all Whitby staff were tremendously kind & helpful. Nearly all our guests told us how it was not only the most beautiful & fun wedding they have ever been to, but the best party. Whitby gave us a wedding beyond our dreams. We couldn’t be happier w/ our wedding & we know it was all because of the venue & their fantastic team. We very highly recommend Whitby Castle as your wedding venue!Sincerely,Mr. & Mrs. David & Elissa Figueroa“

“great food... fast and...very courteous“

“Best catering service! The food was excellent, my guests raved about it. Florie & Mario were the best waitstaff ever. On top of everything. Would use Royal Catering for every occasion. Thank you all. Liz“

“Best deli in Elmont. There hero's are on the money. And the prices are not to be considered the " bidenflation!! They have hilarious names for their hero's. You will be very satisfied with them.Parking: There's always parking either by the front or on the side.“

“THE Royalton Mansion-- If I could rate them 10 stars I would! The best kept secret on Long Island. The most beautiful venue with such a care for detail with the best bang for your buck with pricing. From the day we had our first meeting with the Royalton they have been fantastic and after my Husband and I walked in the first time we knew it was where we were supposed to be married. Mike T and his entire staff were perfect. Their attention to detail is unmatched. Mike T told me we didn’t need a wedding planner or coordinator with them and he was right. He took his role above and beyond! Every question and pre-wedding concern I had was answered quickly and ever worry I had they calmed my fear. The food was amazing and every aspect of the menu completely customizable. We had so many dietary restrictions and Mike was able to accommodate everyone without any issues. The grounds are beautiful both inside and outside. We planned for our ceremony to be in their beautiful garden but unfortunately mother nature had other plans and the move to inside was still as beautiful. Our family and friends are still raving about how beautiful it was, how amazing the food was and how the staff were phenomenal. Michelle, the bridal attendant was also phenomenal and helped the day run so smoothly! We had an unfortunate incident thar required a guest to be removed from the wedding. The professionalism and approach that Mike T took to handle the situation was perfect to the point that I had no idea of the circumstance and to those involved were blown away on how well it was handled by himself and staff and to ensure all our guests were safe as well. I can not recommend The Royalton enough.“

“My husband and I decided to try the food at Maya Grill, not knowing what to expect. We were delighted to receive such a friendly greeting upon our arrival and our food and the service we received were outstanding. I strongly recommend the Maya Grill.“

“Solid deli, everything you'd expect, but they get 5 stars from me simply for having the best cole slaw you'll find. Sounds like a crazy thing to leave a review about but I've gone in here many times to simply get Cole slaw to have as a side for meals I've made at home“

“My first time here and it was absolutely delicious! Everything was so fresh, flavorful and cooked perfectly. We had the vegetarian meatballs, zucchini chips, grilled chicken sticks, grilled lamb sticks and more. I loved the atmosphere. My sister is gluten free and there were so many options for her (including a separate fryer to insure no allergy). You must try this place!Dietary restrictions: They have a separate fryer for gluten free fries, etc. All their food is labeled as gluten free on the menu with so many options.“

“Beautiful venue! Very classy and elegant.“

“Thank you so much to Sameer and the rest of the crew everything was amazing!!! Steve our waiter was great as well. From the beginning of the process until the end everyone was amazing!! Havana Central will always be our first choice for events and I will always refer friends and family as well.“

“Olivia's food is amazing - delicious, healthy, fresh, and a HUGE helper for busy people. She is the consummate pro, and wonderfully attuned to the needs of her clients. Her meals are truly fabulous self-care and also make wonderful gifts. Cannot recommend her highly enough!“

“Shahi Catering is FANTASTIC!! Authentic Indian food and just delectable! Our corporate catered food was absolutely top-notch. Highly recommended!“

“Absolutely the best!!! So much fun for the family and really really good German food .“

“Best food on Broadway in Betgpage bar none. Fay & Jose knock it out of the park on every single recipe. My family are always greeted warmly and treated excellant during every meal ….. and we eat there often. Keep up the great work !!“

“The view is gorgeous and the food is amazing! This is a classy and elegant venue right on the LI Sound!!“

“Great tasting food, especially the chicken fingers, which is probably their best selling and most famous item. But they make great sandwiches and subs to order or from their list as well. In particular, their macaroni salad is great.Always busy, but never too long of a wait. They have a special line if you're just getting chicken fingers.“

“Dreamstreet catered my daughter's bridal shower of 65 women. The food was out of this world, everyone was raving about it. I didn't want just typical party platters and they did not disappoint. Danielle was a pleasure to work with and came up with a menu that I was very happy with. I will definitely use them again!!“

“I gave my mother a surprise birthday party on February 10, 2024. The manager was very accomodating and fulfilled all of my request. The house DJ was awesome. The room was set up perfectly. The food very tasty and nice and hot. the staff was very pleasant. I brought my own cake and the staff cut, plated and served it free of charge. Money well spent.“

“I've been to this location a few times now. I must say, this is now a fave spot that I can enjoy anytime of the day or week.Food:I can speak for the sandwiches, they are unique and constructed with fresh tasty ingredients (that result in a delicious flavor that you will crave in the future).I highly recommend the Mamma Mia Pizza Bagel:Chicken cutlet,melted mozzarella, roasted peppers, baby spinach, pesto mayo on a pizza bagelAND also the Angry BLT:Crispy bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, avocados, chipotle aioli, everything seeds on a toasted bagel*Both come with a side*The coffee is delicious and fresh anytime of day, and they have so many drinks to choose from. I usually go with the Hal's or Fruit Punch Snapple.Can't wait to try the Pancakes or French toast, everything looks drool-worthy. Check their full menu out!Staff:They are very helpful, and make great sandwiches. They also keep the shop very clean too (someone is always cleaning or restocking something).Inside:There's plenty of seating, a restroom, and a decent sized parking lot (not too large, but perfect for their location).“

“Teddy's never fails to impress my guests!!! I ordered a shrimp platter, the turkey, wings, mozzarella sticks, & calamari that was out of this world! They told me how long to heat everything and it all came out moist, delicious and honestly, the calamari was AMAZING! Next year I will order the mashed potatoes too! The quantity, quality, and delivery were perfect and worth every penny!!! And Debbie...well she makes everything so easy to order! I have to give her a little shout out too...thank you Debbie! I give Teddys the highest possible recommendation for any future event!“

“Passed by this place, the place doesn't look classy but the breakfast and lunch I ordered there; they were on point... they are friendly take care of you fast, the food is basic but delicious, I would recommend this place, but because I like cozy.“

“I received a takeout menu from this Deli and was impressed with the prices of the sandwiches. Even though the menu I had was outdated the revised prices were still reasonable.I love tuna fish and when it has just the right amount of mayonnaise along with chopped celery - you have great makings for my kind of tuna sandwich.I tried their chicken salad theirs is very good as well. Large choice of deli meat sandwiches at reasonable prices.“

“Best heroes ever. I went in and gave the owner free will to make my heroe. It was the best with flavor and everything. They also have a nice selection of cheap easy wine and Italian beers like forst. This is a must stop if you want a really good Italian hero or Italian goods and cold cuts.“

“1st time going today. It was well worth the stop. I had the half rack will pulled pork and Mac and cheese. It was splendid. Exceeded my expectations. I'm so glad Glen Cove now has our own BBQ spot! I will be a regular“