Italian Restaurants near Oyster Bay

1
Gioia

Gioia Pasta Shops •
94 South St, Oyster Bay

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Cauliflower
Mushroom Lasagna
Sizzling Shrimp
Gramigna
Ravioli
Polenta

“I walked in with the hopes of being able to snag a seat at the bar. Tim, one of the managers, greeted me. When I told him there were no seats available at the bar, Tim worked to try to get me a table. I waited about 10 minutes and was lucky enough to snag two seats at the bar. The bartender Luis was terrific. I had a perfectto Negroni. It was delicious. The bread was amazing as were the three different dipping butters and oil. We shared the mozzarella with prosciutto and the cauliflower. Both were amazing, but I have to say that I'd go back for the grilled cauliflower. We shared an order of the ravioli and the Gramigna. Both were outstanding, light and flavorful but I would get the gramigna again. It's such a warm and welcoming spot, and it's clearly well run. Highly recommend.“

4.4 Superb97 Reviews
Mario's Pizzeria of Oyster Bay Pizza • $
253 Pine Hollow Rd, Oyster Bay

Customers` Favorites

Personal Cauliflower Pizza Pie
Mario's Baked Ziti Slice
Penne Alla Vodka Pizza
Eggplant Parmigiana
Chicken Parmigiana
Baby Arugula Salad
Gluten Free Pizza
Chicken Primavera
Mozzarella Sticks
Artichoke Pizza

“Nice and easy pizzeria in the area :) I step in at quite night, self order and they bring our food to the table. This is just my test and my own opinion. I don't like the food at all but nothing wrong with the food and how they prepare it. My Italian husband love the food, he actually brings my order home and finish it later. I get shrimp in garlic oil and when the food comes, it isn't like I expect at all. So, all I want to say is I just like food that is not in thick flour and not too oily. Order I get, maybe it is an Italian style and that is how they prepare the food. Anyway, service is good, friendly and very family style.“

4.3 Superb54 Reviews
Cafe Al Dente Italian • $$
62 South St, Oyster Bay

Customers` Favorites

Linguine with Clam Sauce
Fried Artichoke Hearts
Seafood Fra Diavolo
Eggplant Parmigiana
Mozzarella Stack
Pasta Bolognese
Chocolate Cake
Caesar Salad
Warm Salad
Meatballs

“The food was delicious and the servers were very attentive, delicious chicken franchise, and amazing pesto chicken sandwich. Even though it was lunch time three of the four of us ordered off of dinner menu. None of us like the desserts, but two of them did like the ice “

4.3 Superb41 Reviews
J. Michaels Tuscan Steakhouse Steak House
160 Mill River Rd, Oyster Bay

“We met with friends at this restaurant for a meeting. This place was recommended to us by a friend. Well, we were not disappointed. The crew welcomed us with a smile and we felt very good. The meal was delicious. We loved this place very much and we shall absolutely come back again. Warmly recommended.“

4.5 Superb2 Reviews
Autentico Italian • $$$
124 South St, Oyster Bay

Customers` Favorites

Selection of Meat and Cheese
Fresh Mozzarella And
Eggplant Parmigiana
Spaghetti with Clams
Grilled Branzino
Vegan Hearts Of
Pasta Bolognese
Charcuterie
La Piadina
Biscotti

“Went to Autentico with my wife the other night on a recommendation from a close friend. Very friendly service and staff and the food was excellent. I particularly enjoyed my spaghetti with clams. The closest we have had since our honeymoon in Italy. We were told the chef is from Italy and that makes sense I can’t there is just something different about the way it was prepared. Would highly recommend!“

4.2 Good50 Reviews
Mama Mia’s Pizza & Pasta (Formerly Pietro’s Oyster Bay) Pizza • $
342 Lexington Ave, Oyster Bay

Customers` Favorites

Brooklyn Sicilian Pie Slice
Sausage and Peppers
Eggplant Rollatini
Margherita Pizza
Rice Ball
Meatballs
Grandma
House

“I've ordered food from Mama Mia's for both my office and family, and let me tell you, they never disappoint. Whether it's takeout or delivery, they are consistently great - always on time, and the food tastes fresh and delicious. Marlo, the new owner, is truly the best!“

4.1 Good14 Reviews
Stellina Ristorante Italian • $$$
76 South St, Oyster Bay

Customers` Favorites

Bucatini All'Amatriciana
It Was Fried Artichoke
Bresaola Di Wagyu
Quattro Formaggi
Truffle Risotto
Lava Cake
Calamari
Branzino
Gnocchi
Burrata

“Food was amazing as always. Started with the Burrata and the shrimp/calamari. Split the bucatini and veal stuffed angelotti. Deconstructed cannoli is fabulous. The only negative is we were not aware about the 1.5 hr table limit which was strictly enforced. Will definitely be back but will take a later reservation the next time.“

4.2 Good204 Reviews
Umberto's of Oyster Bay Pizza Takeaway • $
25 E Main St, Oyster Bay

Customers` Favorites

Margherita Pizza
Buffalo Chicken
White Pizza
Pizzetta

“4.5 stars really. We really enjoyed our pizza. The regular and vodka were delicious. Grandma's crust is thin andhas a perfect xhew and crunch. Mmmm. Vegan pizza, dense w vegetables. Vegan cheese ok, could be better, but passable. A number of vegan/vegetarian options available. Would return and recommend to friends.Vegetarian options: A number of vegetarian/vegan options available clearly listed.“

3.9 Good46 Reviews
Angelo's Italian Restaurant Italian • $$$
9 Union Pl, Huntington

Customers` Favorites

Pei Mussels and Shrimp over Linguine Fradiavolo
Lemon Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken
Spaghetti Carbonara w Chicken
Steak with Gorgonzola Potato
Creme Brulee Cheesecake
Braised Short Ribs Over
Chicken Parmigiana
Veal Saltimbocca
Grilled Octopus
Seared Ahi Tuna

“If you want a real dining experience versus just a meal, this is the restaurant for you! Attentive service with a list of specials that are a menu all on its own! The dishes are presented beautifully. Every bite sends your tastbuds into a world of pure delight. We will SO be coming back! Thank you JT, Chef and staff for a most memorable dining experience!“

4.9 Superb98 Reviews
Pietro's of East Meadow Pizza • $$
476 E Meadow Ave, East Meadow

Customers` Favorites

Pietro's 9 Inch Round Sicilian Pizza
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana
Pistachio Ricotta Cake
Sweet Chili Calamari
Rigatoni Alla Vodka
Drunken Shrimp Parm
Extra Cheese Pizza
Nutella Empanadas
Stuffed Artichoke
Margherita Pizza

“(Edited my og review because it was poorly written and rushed.)So there I was, on a spontaneous adventure, when suddenly, BAM! Google throws me a curveball - "Nutella Empanada." You bet I was intrigued. It was like the universe daring me, "Bet, let's go."Stumble into this place, and it's like I've walked into the heart of the local scene. This guy, just oozing neighborhood vibes, hits me with, "You're not from around here, huh? Welcome to the best Italian spot in town." And he didn't stop there - gave me the lowdown on all the hidden gems nearby. This dude was living and breathing local charm, and I was here for it. The lobby? Packed with the coolest cats you could meet.Turns out, snagging a table at this joint is usually like finding a unicorn - pretty darn rare. But guess what? They worked some magic and got us in... into an outdoor igloo, no less! Yeah, you read that right. An igloo! (Peep the pics for proof - it's as rad as it sounds.)Now, let's talk food. Holy smokes, it's delish. The staff? Angels in disguise, I swear. Super friendly, on-point, and ready to make your experience top-notch.Oh, and if you see anything with Vodka sauce on the menu, just do yourself a favor and order it. It's a solid 10/10. Trust.All in all, this spot isn't just a restaurant; it's a local legend. Do yourself a favor and drop by. You won't regret it.“

4.6 Superb310 Reviews
Loading...
map Map