Classy, refined, exclusive and delicious. I almost don't want to let the cat out of the bag, but I also cant in good faith gatekeep such a great steakhouse. You can tell, a ton of care and attention went into developing a relaxing, enjoyable speakeasy environment. The steaks, sides and drinks were all excellent. They didn't miss a thing at this place. The host even chased us out the front door to thank us and invite us back when he missed us walking out. Wow. If you're in town, reserve a table. Just be careful who you tell!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lump Crab Cakes, Bone Marrow Butter, Creamed Spinach
Stefanie Baum
We just left Easter Chef’s Tasting Brunch and it was such an enjoyable experience. JP is an exceptional FOH manager. Give the man a raise immediately, hard workers, dedicated like him are hard to come by (now, more than ever). We were so delighted by the menu, I don’t want to share details of it to not ruin it for anyone else, but the cutlery between courses almost served as a clue for the course to come. I cannot wait to come in for dinner, this is without a doubt a memorable dining experience in Patchogue. Cocktails were phenomenal.
I think they have a contender for best restaurant in Long Island with this one. Clean, ultra friendly atmosphere, perfectly dimmed lighting, the wait staff had big smiles and PERFRCT timing, the lobster mac and cheese had an overwhelming amount of lobster and the portion was large. Everything my fork went down it came up with some amount of lobster. I had to laugh out loud. Best I've eaten hands down. The OYSTER ROCKEFELLER is heavenly. I can't say enough about the crew and the ambiance. Moments after finishing a drink you'll be offered another, the timing is spot on. They don't miss! Every dish tasted nothing like the next, but all extremely fresh. The wait staff discreetly and quickly cleaned the table as we progressed through a dinning experience. This was nothing short of a culinary performance. They impressed me and my date on another level. Everyone seemed to enjoy their job so they must treat the crew well. And no need to awkwardly ask for a to-go container, they offer to wrap everything up for you. I'll stop now, but I've got more to say!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Curtis Sclafani
Great good and service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Doug Hebert
I must tell you that this restaurant is exquisite! Marvin the Spartan behind the bar is a mixologist who is second to none! Danny, Jack, Casey and Mel have catered to our every need. JP is such an accommodating host that you'd never know he owns the place! There is no bad choices here! Be sure to attend their private events! We will never miss one!
Recommended dishes: Oysters Rockefeller, Apple Cobbler, Bone Marrow Butter, Creamed Spinach, Italian Cheesecake
Julian Benjamin
Awesome place, great atmosphere, great drinks and delicious food.
Hands down best food I have ever had. Lamb chops melt in your mouth. Drinks outstanding and bar tenders were crafting drinks to perfection and mash potatoes are smooth buttery and velvety! The tomahawk for two was cooked to perfectionI’ve had tellers, insignia and this place BLOWS them out of the water ! ALL of the staff and service was personalized and top notch! We were greeted and seated right away and they made us feel very welcomed! Can’t wait to go back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matt
We went for my birthday celebration and enjoyed it immensely. The seating was a little tight but convivial. It filled in as we ate and got louder but with a good vibe. Interesting drinks, superb Oysters Rockefeller and great filet mignon. Thanks
RobertS
Best steakhouse on Long Island. Everything on the menu is incredible. This time i had 4 shrimp cocktail-huge and tender, very tasty. Oysters Rockefeller- served piping hot, awesome flavor. Split the porterhouse for 2 with my wife and we both loved it! Medium rare of course, accompanied by creamed spinach and lobster mac-n- cheese. All were insanely delicious!! No room for desert but would have ordered the NY Cheese cake. Next time. Gonna try to go back again once/month. :-)
Honestly wanted a really good steak and we ordered a tomahawk. Food was exceptional for appetizer and sides however the steak itself was not good at all. Actually all i tasted was the char on the outside which was just burnt pieces of steak
EricW
Chops was excellent our server Haley was very attentive and made our anniversary special . Food was excellent the veal chop was amazing and the Wagyu ribeye . We loved the smoked old fashioned and they had an excellent wine selection . Top notch
Charles Massimo
Great experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Scott Sferrazza
Good steak but it was not a 20oz cut and definitely not seasoned properly zero salt. . Oysters were amazing. The tiny bernaise steak sauce was not seasoned properly either. Broccoli was horrible. Good drinks and Service was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Nicholas Carlozzi
Sat at the bar as there were no open tables. Loved it. Bartenders were both super friendly and attentive. Food is outstanding. Apps, steaks and even the sides. Worth every pennny!!!!
Classy, refined, exclusive and delicious. I almost don't want to let the cat out of the bag, but I also cant in good faith gatekeep such a great steakhouse. You can tell, a ton of care and attention went into developing a relaxing, enjoyable speakeasy environment. The steaks, sides and drinks were all excellent. They didn't miss a thing at this place. The host even chased us out the front door to thank us and invite us back when he missed us walking out. Wow. If you're in town, reserve a table. Just be careful who you tell!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lump Crab Cakes, Bone Marrow Butter, Creamed Spinach
We just left Easter Chef’s Tasting Brunch and it was such an enjoyable experience. JP is an exceptional FOH manager. Give the man a raise immediately, hard workers, dedicated like him are hard to come by (now, more than ever). We were so delighted by the menu, I don’t want to share details of it to not ruin it for anyone else, but the cutlery between courses almost served as a clue for the course to come. I cannot wait to come in for dinner, this is without a doubt a memorable dining experience in Patchogue. Cocktails were phenomenal.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lobster Bisque, Oysters Rockefeller
I think they have a contender for best restaurant in Long Island with this one. Clean, ultra friendly atmosphere, perfectly dimmed lighting, the wait staff had big smiles and PERFRCT timing, the lobster mac and cheese had an overwhelming amount of lobster and the portion was large. Everything my fork went down it came up with some amount of lobster. I had to laugh out loud. Best I've eaten hands down. The OYSTER ROCKEFELLER is heavenly. I can't say enough about the crew and the ambiance. Moments after finishing a drink you'll be offered another, the timing is spot on. They don't miss! Every dish tasted nothing like the next, but all extremely fresh. The wait staff discreetly and quickly cleaned the table as we progressed through a dinning experience. This was nothing short of a culinary performance. They impressed me and my date on another level. Everyone seemed to enjoy their job so they must treat the crew well. And no need to awkwardly ask for a to-go container, they offer to wrap everything up for you. I'll stop now, but I've got more to say!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great good and service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I must tell you that this restaurant is exquisite! Marvin the Spartan behind the bar is a mixologist who is second to none! Danny, Jack, Casey and Mel have catered to our every need. JP is such an accommodating host that you'd never know he owns the place! There is no bad choices here! Be sure to attend their private events! We will never miss one!
Recommended dishes: Oysters Rockefeller, Apple Cobbler, Bone Marrow Butter, Creamed Spinach, Italian Cheesecake
Awesome place, great atmosphere, great drinks and delicious food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wonderful top notch steakhouse in Patchogue!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Baby Lamb Chops, Whipped Potatoes, Oysters Rockefeller, Bone Marrow Butter, Shrimp Cocktail
Hands down best food I have ever had. Lamb chops melt in your mouth. Drinks outstanding and bar tenders were crafting drinks to perfection and mash potatoes are smooth buttery and velvety! The tomahawk for two was cooked to perfectionI’ve had tellers, insignia and this place BLOWS them out of the water ! ALL of the staff and service was personalized and top notch! We were greeted and seated right away and they made us feel very welcomed! Can’t wait to go back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We went for my birthday celebration and enjoyed it immensely. The seating was a little tight but convivial. It filled in as we ate and got louder but with a good vibe. Interesting drinks, superb Oysters Rockefeller and great filet mignon. Thanks
Best steakhouse on Long Island. Everything on the menu is incredible. This time i had 4 shrimp cocktail-huge and tender, very tasty. Oysters Rockefeller- served piping hot, awesome flavor. Split the porterhouse for 2 with my wife and we both loved it! Medium rare of course, accompanied by creamed spinach and lobster mac-n- cheese. All were insanely delicious!! No room for desert but would have ordered the NY Cheese cake. Next time. Gonna try to go back again once/month. :-)
Restaurantji Recommends
Honestly wanted a really good steak and we ordered a tomahawk. Food was exceptional for appetizer and sides however the steak itself was not good at all. Actually all i tasted was the char on the outside which was just burnt pieces of steak
Chops was excellent our server Haley was very attentive and made our anniversary special . Food was excellent the veal chop was amazing and the Wagyu ribeye . We loved the smoked old fashioned and they had an excellent wine selection . Top notch
Great experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good steak but it was not a 20oz cut and definitely not seasoned properly zero salt. . Oysters were amazing. The tiny bernaise steak sauce was not seasoned properly either. Broccoli was horrible. Good drinks and Service was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Sat at the bar as there were no open tables. Loved it. Bartenders were both super friendly and attentive. Food is outstanding. Apps, steaks and even the sides. Worth every pennny!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5