La Piazza Pizzeria & Italian Kitchen

1137 Old Country Rd, Plainview
(516) 938-0800

Recent Reviews

tomjam pap

The chef specials offered Thur - Sun are delicious....more than a pizzeria......

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

timothy coen

Good pizza, but over priced.

Food: 4

Service: 5

Jennifer Schroeder

Fantastic margherita pizza!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Heidi Burmann

Great food, impeccable service. The music was a bit loud for lunch conversation.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Eggplant Rollatine, Alfredo

Roy Pick

A marguerita pizza eating in the dining room $37I thought it was truly a rip offI should have checked the price firstI know “customer beware”However I do believe the price is beyond a fair priceApril 2024

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Bill Paz

First time going there, was very impressed

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Donna Bee

Update: ate a late lunch in the restaurant area with a friend and the food was hot, cooked well and delicious. I love the warm bread like garlic knots and the chicken Marsala platter was delicious. Got it with penne in an Alfredo sauce. Had some pizza as well that was great. Salad was good. Had the mini cannolis for dessert.I ordered a chicken parmigiana hero and a few slices of pizza for pick up today. They were Delicious and cooked to perfection. I try not to go when it’s very busy. I lucked out today.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Chicken Marsala, Chicken Parm

Nolan Han

The food is so good, and authentic.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Grandma

Cin Vine

I am SO bummed to leave this review. But god forbid you have an allergy, vegan or any special diet… I was informed their menu does NOT reflect the truth of what’s prepared at all. I haven’t eaten meat since a teenager (MANY moons ago)… on menu it says clear tomato based vegetable broth. When I came last week I asked waitress who confirmed yes this is a vegan soup. Ate the soup.Came back a few days later for the soup and salad. I ordered over the phone and again confirmed this is a VEGETABLE BASED soup.Tonight as I’m eating the SAME soup again… I questioned to the waiter bc this broth just tastes TOO GOOD. He comes back to tell me… it’s CHICKEN BROTH.What followed is what I’m most angry about. The manager claims a patron needs to TELL the waiter and check what’s in the food bc the menu doesn’t have to actually be accurate. And this was essentially my fault bc I didn’t check (btw I DID the first time).After he insisted there was nothing really wrong with this situation and brushed it off… he then changed his attitude and direction coming back over to apologize and offer a beer or wine. But actually charged us FULL PRICE for this meal. I just wished the response to this disaster was handled better and left feeling like they actually understand how serious this is.The servers in this place are fantastic. The food I ate, less the soup, is good. But you can’t trust the owner to put a menu out that keeps his customers safe in regard to diets and allergies… what a shame. Im sad.. and upset I offered this to other vegan friends. I really TRULY hope they change their menu ASAP or change the recipe immediately.

Dennis L

Service was very good and they accommodated our large party when we got there since they don't take reservations. Salad and desserts were great but the chef may had an off day. The soup, calzone and some entrées were just meh.Delsy was a great server and so patient with us, especially with our kids.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Cindy Val

I’ll be honest… I’mSHOCKED this place doesn’t have close to 5 star reviews!! The food was RIDICULOUS good!!! The service was great. The workers who bus the tables and take care of things like that were so unbelievably attentive, and nice. I could not be more impressed. I think because it’s a pizza place in the front it’s deceiving. You might not realize there’s a whole restaurant in the back. We will definitely make this our go to for dinner.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jon Paul

$3 delivery fee goes to the owner..Delivery fee, plus tax, plus tip..No thanks

Denis Egas

Never deliver utensils for food !!!

Food: 3

Service: 1

Tina R.

Horrible! The woman working the back counter was so rude to me and had the biggest attitude. They forgot something in my order and refused to give me a complementary dish that was missing after being told over the phone they would give me the missing item free of charge. I'm never buying from here again!

Ilizabeth L.

Always a great experience! Salads, pizza, and any entrees have never disappointed. Their house salad dressing is an all time favorite of mine. The fountain soda is great and you can't beat the bread basket. All the staff are always very friendly and in a good mood. Toni is a gem and makes sure his customers are happy. I order in from la p and go here all the time! I'd recommend going here to anyone in the area or for someone in the mood for some NY style Italian food or pizza!! 1000/10

Load More

La Piazza Pizzeria & Italian Kitchen

1137 Old Country Rd, Plainview, NY 11803
(516) 938-0800