50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Putnam Valley

“We had a last minute party on Sunday. We called Nonna's around 10:30 and they were able to prepare and deliver 4 trays of food by 1pm. The food was delicious and we are very grateful that they were able to accommodate us on such short notice!“

“Rock's Kitchen is phenomenal. Recently found they deliver through Uber. As a physical therapist constantly moving around, I enjoy healthy and filling options. The Greek chicken power bowl is a mid day pick me up, especially with the sauce. Great portions and solid flavor. Juices are fresh. Customer service is great too. Placed an uber order, called the kitchen last min after order was made on a request and it was handled immediately. Highly recommend if you're in the area.“

“They're legit good. I'm old school Bronx n I keep it simple- cheese. Their Baskin Robbins 31 flavors all looked good but a plain slice tells you the truth about a place n truth is it's good. Balance of cheese to sauce is right, that light crunch when you bite into it, light char on the bottom. Sauce is maybe a lil garlicky but that's fine by me. So all in all, a solid slice.“

“GREAT PEOPLE , FANTASTIC FOOD AND GREAT PRICES“

“There was some construction right outside today (not the restaurant's fault obviously) but the staff was very nice and made sure we sat in a place that was further away from the noise :) The food was really good! And the wait time on the food was not that bad. Would definitely recommend and come back again!“

“Excellent slices of pizza. Great sauce and thin crust was really great.“

“We just got dinners from Gerard’s for the first time. Definitely will be going back! The food was excellent, large portions and reasonably priced. Very, very good!“

“ive been coming here since 1964 when it was kim lis, a chinese restaurant owned by a classmate linda wongs parents. then frankie had 2 brothers, a great italian restaurant. now matt has the best italian restaurant and the best rib eye steak !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!“

“Love the pizza phenomenal sauce and crispy crust. Top notch topping.“

“Had great experience! The staff is top notch! Thank you Ryan! The food was excellent. Thank you!!“

“Arriving in Peekskill on Easter Sunday from out of state, we found several restaurants closed for the evening. Amici's was open and welcoming. We were thrilled to find that beyond their thriving pizza counter, Amici's has an elegant dining room with delicious appetizers, entrees and desserts. A hidden gem.Vegetarian options: Didn't see anything vegan; the meat-free eggplant parmesan was tasty, with eggplant, cheese, and sauce on my choice of pasta (I chose fettuccine). Came with a nice salad.Wheelchair accessibility: From the car in the parking lot to being seated at the table, a rolling walker had no difficulty, and was nicely tucked aside as we ate. Smooth ramps and wide enough walkways.“

“I loved my chicken cutlet sandwich. It was made well and yummy!!“

“Great Local Pizza restaurant. We order here every Friday for dinner and get there special which is an extra large pie and wings with a soda. This is our go to pizza place on peekskill. Come get a slice, garlic knots, and don't forget the zeppollis for dessert“

“I’m a pizza aficionado and this is by far the best slice in Northern Westchester. I’ve tried them all and nothing compares. I’ve been there everyday for the last week. Great undercarriage, good sauce to cheese ratio, great crispy crust and a delicious tangy sauce. Highly recommend this place.“

“I have nothing but fabulous things to say about Mobile Pie Truck. The food is absolutely wonderful. Authentic wood-fired pizza that rivals NY and CT pies, which are already some of the best. All of our guests couldn't stop talking about how delicious it was. Frank and all of the staff were so warm, friendly, and helpful. Looking for a good excuse to book them again!“

“Love this place. Great online ordering system and you can include the tip too. I had the salmon tonight and it was absolutely delicious. I highly recommend Carlos in Cold Spring.“

“Love Maria's Pizza when we moved up here to Yorktown a few years ago Maria was the first pizza shop we ordered from and they never disappoint. The service and delivery is great and everybody's always very nice when they answer and take our orders. Definitely recommend Maria's pizza and we're definitely going to try there. The drunken chicken is my favorite chicken Parm pizzas excellent. Tried the new cannoli chips and dip loved we're gonna soon try Maria's famous 3 foot pizza cause we'll be having a gathering so we're gonna try that when ordering it arrives early and hot so if you're in the Yorktown area, try Maria's Pizza. You won't regret it.“

“Always a good time & good food with one of our chamber members!“

“If you haven't got food from here yet, do yourself a favor and stop. The food is outstanding, the prices are fair and the portions are large. I have tried a few different pizzas and they are all worth eating again. I have also tried the sausage with peppers and chicken Stromboli. Both are great. The service is as good as the food!“

“The food was great. I ordered the pork chop with spinach and roasted potatoes. The food came out hot just the way I like it. My friend ordered the chicken Mona Lisa. I tried my Friends entree and I will say what I tried was fabulous. I love Norca the bartender and she gives wonderful service. Norca makes you feel like you don't want to leave, she is very welcoming and warm. I like to visit this restaurant when Norca is working. When Norca doesn't work I don't show up and neither does my friends. Very nice decor comfortable atmosphere great vibes all the way around. The pizza is also great too. If you're in the mountains kisco area. Happy eating and Happy dining“

“After eating here a few times for dinner and or lunch we decided it was a great place to do our office holiday party. I had noticed they have a private room with large glass doors and inquired about booking it. They got back to me really quick with a better deal than anything else local we could find, meal options, etc. But honestly we would have paid more. They printed us out menus for our event. They lined up two tables for dining and have the extra tables for a white elephant gift exchange. We chose to have appetizers served family style (nanas bread with cheese sauce and marinara, crispy meatballs ( these were so good!) tomato and mozz salad and calamari) there were a few plates of each dish placed and timed so we weren’t overwhelmed . Then we had four options- chicken piccata, halibut, pasta ragu and a vegetarian option. After this came out we did our gift swap and then had coffee accompanied by tiramisu and a lemon crostata dessert. This didn’t feel like a under thought buffet style party. It came out in courses- we had plenty of time to enjoy each other outside of our office. We didn’t feel rushed. The wait staff was so on top of everything. No one had to ask for refills etc. Multiple managers came in to check on us periodically ( and the owners brother) and they packed up whatever we didn’t eat. We actually took all the desserts back to the office. All in all I would 10000 percent suggest this for anyone looking for a party location. While we enjoyed it for a large office plus spouses Christmas party, it was spacious enough that I could see rehearsal dinners, retirement parties graduations etc. Everyone left happy! We’ll be booking it again in the future.“

“I was just at the Muscoot Tavern lastnight and the food was sooooo good. The Service was great. I highly recommend the Muscoot Tavern!!!“

“Hubby and I came here to meet our friend for brunch. It's a spacious, cozy, pleasant cafe with enough room for small and big groups. Alexa was our server. She's fast and attentive. Good! We'll eat slowly. We ordered mussels for appetizer. Then I had a wild fish taco, Hubby had a Village burger, and our friend had a duck quesadilla; I am not kidding; it's a duck quesadilla! Of course, I had my hot green tea! I love my hot tea during brunch or lunch. The mussel was phenomenal! The food was exceptional! We loved everything that we ordered. The homemade creamy sauce that they used on top of my taco was fantastic. I don't usually like creamy sauce or anything with my food, but I definitely enjoyed this one. We want to come back and check out more dishes. Everything's excellent! Thanks!“

“A cozy Italian-American in Mahopac on Route 6, that is worth a trip from anywhere! The review, may sound like hyperbole, but it's not! A friend mentioned it had good food, great prices, and table service and he was going down there, so we all stopped in for lunch. Great decision. The prices are very reasonable! One of the best Italian-American restaurant/pizzerias I've found in years; and I've eaten more than my share of pizza in many countries. Only top quality ingredients are used! We each ordered a different 12" pizza, one for each of us. In hindsight, we could've ordered one pizza that the three of could have shared and would we have been satiated! My significant other ordered a prosciutto and arugula pizza. She had one at Cancino's in Mexico City November 2019 and LOVED it. We've never seen it on another menu here. So, when she saw it on their menu, she ordered it right away! It was perfect! There was about 4 ounces of arugula and the $20 something a pound prosciutto on it. See the photo. No crispy cremated prosciutto chips nor wilted arugula arrived to the table. My friend had the red meat pizza. It looks like about a pound of sausage meat and a whole pepperoni was sliced and put on his pizza. He kept picking pepperoni off his pizza and putting it on ours. What we had looked like a normal pepperoni pizza; there was that much on his! There was a small group who ordered pasta dishes. They looked great also. Yelpers get a 10% discount.“

“I want to share that Romano's catering was perfect for my twin's third birthday celebration. The food was exceptional, and everyone was delighted with it. Plus, the leftovers were so good that guests were happy to take them home. I highly recommend Romano's catering services to anyone who wants to impress their guests with quality food and excellent service.“

“I'm still in the restaurant writing this review. It's that good! Simple; unassuming from the exterior but enter and experience excellent service, large very tasty portions of food at really great prices, and a simple but cute dining area. Elda and Joseph did a really nice job! Go see them.“

“Always had very good food here and Excellent service …“

“My wife and I found Mario's on a trip to Mt Kisco to get my phone fixed. I can not tell you how good the food here is. If you want absolutely the finest Italian food and pizza, you need to get here. It's my new favorite spot, hands down. MARIO, you're the man! This is not only food, it's art, a masterpiece.“

“Hands down the best pizzeria in westchester, their food in the kitchen is absolutely award winning worthy, I have dined in some of westchester’s top Italian restaurants and let me tell you Grandma’s kitchen food is on the same level of not better. The staff that works there is so welcoming. The restaurant is clean and always tidy. If going there I highly reccomend the chicken franchese over pasta ! 11/10. Pizza is just as great, very nice and thin and crispy and I have seen some really awesome house pies on display when going there as well. Overall for me personally this place is a 10/10.“

“Family owned pizzeria and Italian restaurant. The staff is always welcoming, and the food always comes out when they tell you. In addition to the the traditional dishes you can order for lunch or dinner, they can also provide catering dishes for hosting events.“

“The best meatball parm ever.meatballs are soft and flavourful as well as the sauce. The bread is a little soft but I just throw it in the air fryer for 3 min and it doesn't ruin the integrity of the moist flavourful meatballs.Parking: Plenty“

“We love Slice! The food is delicious, the staff is so kind and friendly. Their dedication to caring for children with allergies is so deeply appreciated. If I order the burrata panini (do it! Yum!) and mention the peanut allergy we have and forget to write that pine nuts are okay, they call my separately to confirm the ingredients are safe. I just love their care and effort toward keeping people safe, and the fact that their food is so great is even better!Dietary restrictions: The staff at slice was great about monitoring for allergy safety.“

“Great tasting and consistent pizza for people who like a softer slices. I like most styles of pizza, and this is the best place for a soft and cheesy! Pretty good ingredients; I've never felt something wasn't fresh or stale. As for their other foods, their portions are a little smaller than other places in the area, still great food nonetheless but I mainly go just for the pizza. Great service and overall great place!“

“Here is the easiest way to describe this place. STRAIGHT UP HOMEMADE ITALIAN FOOD! This is 5-STAR Italian deliciousness! I was last here about 20 years ago but to be honest, like most, I have zero reason to ever be in Verplanck. This evening I was down there and made the immediate decision to dine-in the second I saw their big sign on Broadway. The place looks basically the same as I remember, very neat, clean and of course with a stellar menu. I observed Carmine (at the bar) preparing some amazing looking cocktails! Great service, well priced, friendly staff and great dishes! One thing I want to point out is how the first forkful of my cold antipasto salad appetizer immediately tasted soooo different. I wasn't expecting fresh, 'sharp' provolone -- no sliced ham here kids. Tonight was an unexpected treat! I will again grab my passport and cross the border into Westchester to spend more time here! Mangia!“

“This joint is all about no-frills dining; they even charge extra for napkins and mark up one-dollar Arizona drinks to two bucks. The evening shift operator oozes an arrogant kind of charm, but one thing remains consistently good—the pizza. It's always deliciously greasy, folded up neatly into a paper bag. They don't skimp on quality, using top-notch ingredients and embodying that classic Italian flair blended with New York charm. These two brothers have been making pizza here day and night for close to 50 years. If you grew up in Northern Westchester, you know Napolis pizza, and you know these two legends.“

“Brothers Pizza is a true hidden gem that exceeds expectations on every level. Tucked away in a cozy corner of the Village, this unassuming pizzeria delivers an exceptional dining experience that leaves a lasting impression.Upon entering Brothers Pizza, you are immediately struck by the inviting aroma of freshly baked pizza and the friendly, welcoming atmosphere. The interior is unpretentious yet charming, with a distinct focus on creating a comfortable space for guests to enjoy their meal.Now, let's talk about the star of the show – the pizza. Brothers Pizza takes the art of pizza-making to new heights. Each pie is crafted with care and precision, using only the finest, freshest ingredients. The result? A perfect marriage of flavors, with a thin, crispy crust that provides the ideal base for an array of delectable toppings. Whether you're a fan of classic combinations or more adventurous flavor profiles, the menu offers something for every palate.Aside from the outstanding pizza, the menu also features a variety of other mouthwatering options, including savory appetizers, fresh salads, and indulgent desserts. The attention to detail and quality extends to every dish, ensuring a truly satisfying dining experience.Brothers Pizza is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts and food lovers alike. With its dedication to quality, inviting ambiance, and top-notch service, this establishment has undoubtedly earned its reputation as a go-to destination for exceptional pizza. Whether you're dining in or grabbing a slice to go, Brothers Gourmet Pizza is sure to leave a lasting, delicious impression.“

“Very great pizza and very friendly place to eat with your family!!!!!!“

“I LOVE Route 9 Pizza. Every time I stay at the Countryside Motel, across the road, I always order from this place at least once. The food is great, the prices are reasonable and the customer service is excellent. I look forward to dining in soon.“

“Absolutely great place to go! Tried the Pizza and Deserts and it was great. All the staff is super friendly if you live in the area and don't go to Cacciatori you're doing yourself a major disservice. I will always stop by for great food when I'm in the area!“

“I go here for breakfast bacon egg cheese sandwiches. They are very good. They charge a little more than their closest competitor but it seems that they use more ingredients in the sandwich which makes the sandwich a better deal in the long run. Got to try their other stuff“

“Longtime customer! Best Pizza in North Rockland!!!!Parking: In a strip mall with a pretty great deli, a so-so Greek Place, An old school family type pharmacy with overpriced toys , a print shop and various pot holes in the parking lot. But the parking is plentiful and even goes around the side of the strip mall where the deli is.“

“We were a large party. Service was very attentive. Food was flavorful. I would recommend it to anyone who wants a good meal.“

“First time ordering take out from here since it’s been under new management. We ordered the Brooklyn pizza (thin square pie) and a large pie (half regular/ half pepperoni). The round pie was very good. Sauce had a nice tang, was thing and had a nice crunch. The show stopper was the Brooklyn Pie. My goodness, was it absolutely delicious. The sauce was more robust, had a bite to it and the pie was thin and crunchy. Absolutely amazing. My wife and I nearly ate the entire pie between the two of us. We will definitely be going back!“

“Their chicken parm & meatball wedges are FANTASTIC! A must to try!!!!!!“

“SO happy your are here! You were always my fave back in Yonkers and tonight's first pie from your new digs was EXCELLENT! even my grouchy hate everyone's pizza hubby loved it! THANK YOU FOR COMING NORTH! See you soon for that Pesto Bianco!“

“Delicious. While I was waiting for my order, I noticed a couple at a table enjoying soup. She looked delicious. Ask, What are they eating? . They informed me that "Seafood soup." I wanted to try it and requested an order. Ummmmm what a delight, great flavor, little fat, good protein, shrimp, oysters, clams. I enjoyed it. My wife ordered another order and she loved it. I recommend this dish If you want to eat something nutritious, light and delicious. For less than 10. there is parking and the restaurant is central. They also sell pizza of various flavors and I notice that they make delivery. The place has table service, they are diligent, warm and attentive. I should clarify that I ordered a small soup, but I should have ordered the large soup.“

“We finally found it! After living in the area for just over a year and trying most pizzerias around we finally found the best of the best. Fantastic tasty coal fired pizza that the whole family loved. The margarita was thin, crispy with quality produce. The same with the Calabrase. We will definitely be back.“

“Went here for a slice of pizza on Monday November 6th, before heading to a funeral that was nearby. Went with my parents. They had quite a few pizzas and rolls available. I had a slice of BBQ Chicken pizza, my mom had white pizza with a spinach roll, and i forget what my dad had. i enjoyed my pizza, and liked the slice. Was also greeted right away, and everyone seemed very nice. Reasonable price too.“

“It's a pizzeria, nothing fancy, but the food, especially the pizza is beyond fabulous. If you like tender calamari, you must order it here. You will not find better anywhere. If you are lucky enough to come when Mario make his homemade bread, you are not going to want to share it.“

“SO happy I eventually (re)tried this place! Stella's had changed hands so many times I eventually gave up on it. The new person(s) know what they're doing! Finally! Very FRIENDLY front-end people, LARGE proportions, GREAT food and very FAIRLY priced! With pizza places every 500 feet around here, Stella's just went to the top of my list. In addition to the usual smorgasbord of creative pizza selections at the counter, they also had two different kinds of sliders sandwiched between garlic knots--very creative and delicious. Chicken cutlet or fresh mozzarella with tomato! BOTH were excellent (and different)! I've never commented on salad before but BEST house salad I've ever had with a generous portion of dressing. Thank you!“