Premier Pastry

433 South Ave, Rochester
(585) 546-1420

Recent Reviews

Natalia Wojdak

We ordered our wedding cake here a few years ago. I've been thinking of that cake ever since and need to order another for our anniversary. Was honestly the best cake we ever had and communication was great. Love them!

Marcia B.

Christmas cookies. So absolutely delicious. The cookies are better than homemade and so perfectly decorated.

Lisa Killingsworth

I ordered a cake and cookies for a surprise 40th birthday party that had an 80s theme, about three weeks before the event. It was super easy to work with Philip on choosing a design and flavors, size, and fillings. I chose one tier with chocolate cake and another with funfetti. The cake and cookies were delicious.I did some shopping around and Premier had the best price and design options.Our guests (and guest of honor) were blown away and everything turned out perfectly. I couldn't recommend them more for your event.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Russell Gates

My wife called on a Wednesday to have a cake made in time for a birthday on Saturday.This was over the phone, and got immediately dismissed, because they claimed they required a week in advance for any cake orders.Who can’t do a simple 4-in round cake in 3 days?Called the competition shortly after, and was told they could easily do that same cake, and it’d be ready on that Saturday. Take your business elsewhere.

Anne Gleason

Our daughter used them for her wedding “cake and dessert “. The cake was intentionally small for cutting only. It was very good nonetheless. The pastries and cookies were outstanding. I would highly recommend this business for quality, communication and execution.

Emily Wegman

We were married yesterday, and premier pastry made all of our pastries! Everyone at the wedding raved about them, and they were beautiful. Premier worked with my wedding planner for drop off, and I didn't have to worry one bit. Thank you!

David H.

They made exactly what I wanted. The end result was amazing and the taste was on point.

Toni Giannavola

Our wedding cake was more than I could have ever imagined. We mentioned a few details and premiere did them and more! The cake was delicious, beautiful, everything we wanted and more! Thank you so much Paula and Phillip for your talent! Our guests loved the cake and we still get compliments after months later!

Janet Santiago

It's been 3 years and we still talk about this cake. My wife and I couldn't thank this team enough. The cake was beautiful and the taste was out of this world. 10 out of 10 recommend!

Macy DiPasquale

Awful experience.I ordered a cake over the phone for my sons third birthday. They told me to email the details to their email. I call a day before my sons birthday to confirm and they yelled at me saying they never received the email and neglected to call and let me know they never received it.Horrible disservice.

Macy T.

Awful experience.I ordered a cake over the phone for my sons third birthday. They told me to email the details to their email. I call a day before my sons birthday to confirm and they yelled at me saying they never received the email and neglected to call and let me know they never received it.Horrible disservice and completely unprofessional!

Joane B.

First class operation. We were delighted with the planning and execution of our wedding cake. The cake was beautiful and we had so many compliments on the cake. Thank you very much!!!

John Perry

I had two cakes made for a milestone birthday for my wife. I called Premier two weeks ahead and asked for a German chocolate cake and apricot and almond flavored cake. I asked for Gerbera daisies on one and cherry blossoms on the other. They were outstanding. The decoration was great and each cake had great flavor and texture. The ratio of frosting, filling and cake was in good balance. The sponge was moist. The caramel layer in the German chocolate was particularly good. Highly recommend this baker.

Asma Ali

They made my wedding cake and it was beautiful.

Racheal Henry

Premier Pastry created our wedding cake. They did a great job for us, we had many compliments on the tasty cake. We put two weddings together in 4 months so I didn't have a lot of time to put it together. I had to order our cake last minute as a result. However, they got our order in and gave us a wonderful experience and delicious and beautiful cake.

Load More