7 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sayville

Cherry Grove Pizza Pizza • $$
179 Ocean Walk, Cherry Grove

Customers` Favorites

Siciliano Cheese Pizza Slice
Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza
Garlic Knot Slices
Meatball
Lasagna

“If you're visiting Cherry Grove / The Pines, make your way to Cherry Grove Pizza. I've visited several times over the years, and have never been disappointed. I recommend the delicious pork chop Milanese, the truffle fries, and the chicken Sorrentino as well. Generous servings in a laid-back atmosphere.“

4.6 Superb26 Reviews
Umberto's of Sayville Pizza • $
37 N Main St, Sayville

Customers` Favorites

Pasta with Marinara Sauce
Chicken Parm Slice
Vegan Sicilian
Vegan Eggplant
Cheese Pizza
Regular Pizza
Vegan Pizza
Grandma Pie
Garlic Knot

“love the staff here. So friendly and their vegan pizza is so good!!! They even keep vegan pizza for you to order by the sliceI normally get a Sicilian with half roasted red peppers with onions and the other half eggplant with garlic. It's so good and my non-vegan friends like it too.“

4.2 Good72 Reviews
Metros on Main American • $$
60 Main St, Sayville

Customers` Favorites

Baby Clam Bar Pie
Baked Clams 12
Baby Clam Pie

“Phenomenal quick lunch late afternoon snack Open airy friendly clean accessible withampleparking Always beautifully decorated for all holidays. A must try Food is cooked fresh, pizza is piping hot and several options Vegetarians , GF, and traditional freshmade to order or a slice of pre-made if you prefer! Restaurant is nicely situated Bartender is friendly and welcoming too. Whether pizza or a hero or dinner everyone sits in same area!“

4.7 Superb18 Reviews
Sal's Pizzeria and Catering Pizza • $
183 Montauk Hwy, Sayville

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chicken Cutlet Hero
Large Cheese Pizza
Grandma Pizza
Garlic Knots
Sal

“I was in the shopping center and wanted to grab some lunch. I went here a few years ago and wasn't impressed. The experience was average. I decided to give Sal's another try. I had the meat lover's slice and chicken caesar slice. Both were great. The meat lover's slice had plenty of meatball, sausage, and pepperoni on top. It was my favorite of the two. The chicken caesar slice had a homemade dressing and fried chicken cutlet on top. I really liked it. There was plenty of chicken on top. The staff at the counter was awesome. Prices were very reasonable. I'll definitely return.“

4.2 Good49 Reviews
Station Pub Bar • $
3 Lakeland Ave, Sayville

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Wings
Hot Pretzel

“Visit this place right next to train station!! Waiting on a train in a city I'm not familiar with, going to meet family and find this gem to kill some time - 4 hours actually. After stressful airports and travel, I uber to this spot and I'm so in love ❤️ FRESH CLAM STRIPS AND A BLOODY MARY (fries were killer too!), GREETED AND HANGING WITH THE AMAZING MAN THAT RUNS IT! Got to hang for hours as other nice regulars poured in, didn't even want to leave to get on the train to Montauk!! Wanted to go for Sunday jam days too! Visit this place if you get any chance and you're a regular for life!“

4.4 Superb8 Reviews
Butera's Italian • $$$
100 S Main St, Sayville

Customers` Favorites

Rigatoni Alla Vodka Lunch
Mozzarella Caprese
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Parmesan
Calamari Fritti
Rigatoni Butera
Chicken Marsala
Birthday Cake
Bread Basket
Broccoli Rabe

“We celebrated my husband's birthday at Butera's, as it is one of his favorite places to eat. We were seated in a side room off the bar, which initially concerned us, since we thought it might affect our service. I'm happy to report that service was wonderful! Our waitress, Zoe, was friendly and efficient, and she bent over backwards to make sure Dennis' birthday dinner was perfect. We use our Foodie card to get a discount, and we have the Butera's "frequent diner" card, which accumulated points based on the amount of our dinner. I also purchase gift cards at a slight discount at Costco, so all in all, it's an excellent value. Oh, and the food is amazing!!!“

3.8 Good177 Reviews
Sayville Pizza & Italian Restaurant Pizza • $
60 Main St, Sayville

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Slice
Chicken Parm Slice
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Spinach Pinwheel
Chicken Caprese
Slice of Pizza
Grandma Slice
Garlic Knots
Cheese Pizza
2 Liter

“Went to Metros on Main for my fifth wedding anniversary last week 5/11/23. The service was outstanding Thank you Evan and the food and staff were awesome great cocktails thanks Nicole The live music was the perfect touch, Danny and Dominick treated us like family and I couldn't have been happier Dominick even replaced my cheap plastic bouquet with Roses for my wife Best anniversary ever I recommend dinner there anytime and tell Danny & Dominick EJ & Jo sent ya We had an awesome time and will definitely be having dinner and cocktails again soon.“

3.7 Good30 Reviews
Loading...
map Map