32 Best American Restaurants near Slate Hill

“We've catered Christmas Eve Eve dinner now two years in a row and everything was outstanding both times. It makes the holidays so much easier to heat and eat and everything was delicious. They also did the chicken francese gluten free for us with no problem. The potato croquettes are soooooo worth it. Appeciate you all and Merry Christmas.“

“Was looking forward to trying the hot dogs.they were everything thing I hoped they would beThe owner “Cook “ was awesome the dogs were fantastic .I can’t say enough about them.he even gave us a free slider to taste .that I will definitely get next time I go!!!“

“Very neat place with awesome atmosphere. Solid craft beer list (unfortunately missed my tastes but still a good list). Bartender was super friendly and fun.We unfortunately only got wings here and they were not good. They were dry, small, and the dry rub only hit one side. So that side was overpoweringly flavored and the other was just dry chicken.Their menu looks awesome and some of the other food we saw coming out looked really good. But the wings were decidedly not good.Hope to come back another day and try some other food and switch to 5 stars.“

“This spot is hidden , passed this location many times not knowing that a marvelous restaurant was there.Nicely spaced tables, attentive service, and full kitchen staff.Wish the chicken wasn’t Cajun style since I’m a punk when it comes to spicy food. Knowing the chicken our other entrees were delicious.The French sticks, forget about it ! Delicious“

“Super friendly service, owner is very nice, friendly. Food quality is high, fresh, home made. Price is reasonable but the serving is not huge.Parking: Municipal lot behind the restaurant, have to go around the corner, the exit to the lot is one way and right next to the restaurant.“

“Recently started going there. Seems like a pretty nice place. Didn't sense any attitudes there. Owner and staff very nice! Haven't eaten there yet, but I've seen the great deals, and the food smells great. $5 pitchers of Coors! (12 year's later UPDATE.....Just started coming back here after at least 5 year's. Still a nice place. Haven't witnessed any violence. Owner and staff still very nice! It's been a while since I've eaten their food, but I hear it's just as good as it was before. $3.50 pints of Bud. No more $5 pitchers. Karaoke and DJ Thursday nights. If you hang with fun people, you'll have fun here.)“

“We moved to Florida and we wish we could bring Cuginos with us. Well actually, don't judge... but we have packed up food to fly home with us a few times! We CRAVE the food and we look forward to dining here every time we visit NY. We love everything we have tried but a few of our favorites are the Pizza, Garlic Knots with Cheese, Thai Chili Wings well done, hot honey espresso slice with pepperoni, Eggplant Parm, Chicken Parm and Penne Ala Vodka. We have ordered trays of the Penne Ala Vodka and Eggplant Parm in the past as well, and it's a guaranteed hit at parties! My husband has always said you can put their Vodka sauce on a shoe and it will taste good. It's a family owned and operated restaurant. The owner Maria is an absolute gem and the staff is friendly and attentive. The restaurant is always clean and nicely decorated. This place remains at the top of my list and the quality of food is highly deserving of the best rating!“

“We’ve been here a couple of times now and not only is the service great but we love the creative menu. There’s not a lot of fun, creative menus in the area and this is one we love to try.They regularly change things up to keep the menu fresh and the food is outrageous“

“We truly enjoy this place. It’s a definite GEM. The owner is great, and the place is so full of nostalgia. We literally have never been disappointed. Their menu is great and the weekend specials always leave us happy. Their waitress is amazing too. 5 stars and more!!“

“I had a surprise party for my boyfriend’s 40th here and it was great! Ed was a great help, super informative and responsive to all my questions. The space was great, nice and spacious. The food was great, and the service too! It was affordable as well! Michaela was a great bartender, super attentive and so nice! I highly recommend Tapped for your next event!“

“We always enjoyed coming here when it was "Something Sweet". Anna made the best apple crisp ever! Now that it's Piccolo, we love it even more! The soups are ALWAYS amazing, and the new menu is 10/10. The Italian Chicken Stew is out of this world, as well as the Butternut Squash Ravioli. Anna, you are not only an incredible baker, but an amazing cook!!! This is on our regular rotation - highly recommend.“

“The farm was the first venue we visited, and it was also the last. We fell in love that day and never looked back. Food is really important to us, and the farm was perfect. It was as close at it gets to a true "farm to table" experience, right on the property. All of their ingredients are either sourced from the farm itself, or other local ingredients. Steve, the chef, works with you directly to figure out the menu, and that process was really fun! The barn itself is the perfect setting for the "rustic chic" vibe that we were going for. It's gorgeous on its own and didn't require much for decoration, although working with Candice on the decor was easy and fun. We also stayed on the property that weekend (with our wedding party) and the accommodations were both luxurious and cozy/intimate. Working with Steve & Candice was a true pleasure, and we can't wait to go back for a farm dinner (they do those too!) soon. They also have an open farm market on weekends from 11-4 --- we highly recommend stopping by for farm raised meats, eggs, vegetables, honey, and so much more. <3“

“Quaint little place off the Main Street in downtown Warwick. Highly recommend making reservations because it is a small space with not that many tables. Everything is homemade, so it takes a little longer to get your order, but is well worth the wait. Coffee was amazing! I got Fannie’s signature latte which was full of interesting flavors. Went there for breakfast and everything tasted great. The one thing I will tell you is to ask for the price of the specials before you order. I ordered a special that included pork loin (which was the previous night’s dinner special) eggs, hash browns and an apple salad and it was $33. It was good, but not $33 good. My fault for not checking the price, but I never imagined a breakfast dish costing that much. I will still go back next time I’m in Warwick, but I’ll be sure to ask for the prices before I order a special again.“

“Food was excellent, really cute little place, drinks were also great! It's a hidden gem that more people should know about. I got beef Wellington which was excellent, brussel sprout appetizer and the chocolate platter, and not pictured was the poached pear dessert also super good and French onion soup was excellent as well! Would definitely recommend and go again! Little pricy though“

“Ambiance and service were excellent, harbingers to the simply delicious entrees which followed our very unique and tasty appetizer- petite potato pancakes and deviled eggs. Main course was lamb shank Wellington (outstanding) and crab cakes (delicious), both presented with a gourmet flair, by friendly and attentive waitstaff. A truly wonderful dining experience, in this bistro-like gem of a restaurant, situated in a rural country area. Highly recommend this great place.“

“A group of us from Long Island visited Warwick & had lunch at Yesterdays this week. We loved the atmosphere of the new space, and enjoyed looking at all of the fun retro decor. Very clever use of beer kegs inside and outside the new building. The food was fresh and delicious, we had mozzarella sticks, Irish nachos, fried chicken and salads, the dressing on my grilled chicken Caesar salad was probably the best I’ve ever had. Overall an excellent experience. Thank you Peggy & John!Kid-friendliness: Family friendly!Wheelchair accessibility: There is a ramp to get into the restaurant from the parking lot“

“Indulging in the mac 'n' cheese at this establishment is nothing short of a gastronomic delight. From the moment you enter, the inviting aroma of cheesy goodness sets the stage for an exceptional experience. The diverse menu offers a myriad of creative twists on this classic comfort dish, leaving you spoiled for choice. The macaroni is perfectly cooked, providing the ideal canvas for the rich, velvety cheese sauce that coats each pasta strand with perfection. The incorporation of premium cheeses lends an exquisite depth of flavor that lingers on the palate. Portion sizes are generous, ensuring you savor every delicious moment of your meal. The ambiance complements the culinary journey, striking a balance between cozy and contemporary. Attentive and knowledgeable staff members add a touch of warmth to the overall dining experience, making you feel right at home. Whether you're a seasoned mac 'n' cheese aficionado or a first-timer, this place is guaranteed to exceed your expectations. In conclusion, this mac 'n' cheese haven deserves every bit of its five-star rating. The dedication to quality ingredients, culinary creativity, and exceptional service make it a standout destination for those seeking the epitome of mac 'n' cheese perfection!“

“Great food well prepared. Basically a breakfast and lunch menu but good choices. Service was pleasant and fairly quick but due to the care taken the food can take a while to get to you. A smallish storefront place right in downtown Warwick. RecommendParking: As is usual in Warwick, parking can be hard to find in a convenient place as it is often busy, especially at weekends“

“Living close to the NY/PA/NJ border definitely has its perks.Decided to head over to Sussex County NJ to try something new for lunch. First of all, the beer flights are only $7, the downside is all beer is served in plastic cups, but the pours are nice size. They do have wine but nothing that this wine snob wanted, lol. The kitchen offers something for everyone. I had the hot Italian panini, my husband the pepperoni pizza, zero complaints. Big bonus there's was music on Sunday! Nice gentleman singing not your ordinary songs, like Eleanor Ribgy! Very cool.2nd Bonus.There's specific parking spots for motorcycles. So we will definitely be back on our scoot with some friends, scenic route from home is no highway. Nice outdoor seating and ice cream for kids, bring the whole fam, no dogs tho.“

“Their menu isn't particularly large, but their offerings vary from wings and a top tier burger to fancier options like Coq au vin, as well as some daily specials. And they certainput their all into them. The dessert menu is pretty fancy, and everyone was thrilled with what they ordered.The place itself is definitely a piece of history. The ceiling of our dining area was made of old doors. It was a neat conversation point for us. The wait staff was really professional and pleasant as well. It was a nice experience. I'd go back again.“

“Visiting from out of town for the Spartan race on Mt. Vernon and stopped in. Had the Scallop and Tagliatelle Prima Vera and my buddy had the Chicken Parm, both dishes were excellent and portions were great. Would definitely come back if in the area again.“

“I have lived in the area for 25+ years and have driven by the little sign on Route 1 pointing the way to this little gem thousands of times.Thanks to a New Years resolution to eat at every place I have never been to , I made reservations for the Crystal Inn.Its been there for @60 years and is kind of a local institution.First of all the prices are very affordable when compared to the Warwick restaurants that act like they are in NYC with their crazy prices!Five of us went out for $180 which included drinks and tip. Amazing!The French onion soup was very good and my steak sandwich was great.Stop in next time you are in Warwick.“

“Halligans is my neighborhood place. AloneFor lunch, with a gang for the game, it is like dropping by a friends. The food is good. I like the beef tips salad, artichoke, great hamburgers..if you are hungry. GoKid-friendliness: Lots of families. Great place to take the kidsWheelchair accessibility: The whole place is one floor and there is a side access door.“

“It's a very nice little place in the middle of nowhere. It's between small towns. The food is good the service is very friendly the atmosphere is okay. I haven't tried dinner there but I've had breakfast and lunch. I was happy every time. It can get a little loud if it's crowded.“

“I had John as my server the last time I went. He is THE BEST server EVER! all of the food came in a fast and timely manner, and he brought bread and butter out nonstop. I left feeling like I went to an all you can eat buffet off of the rolls alone. I highly recommend that you request John as your server. I went on Saturday as soon as they opened so it wasn't very busy but boy we felt special.Kid-friendliness: Family friendly restaurant. Great for kids birthdays.Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible.“

“What a delightful surprise! During my visit to Otisville, I chose Grogan's Irish Pub as our meeting spot to catch up with a friend. Despite its unassuming exterior, this charming local watering hole exceeded my expectations. Once seated at the bar, we were warmly welcomed by Brittany, the attentive bartender. She made our experience truly enjoyable, ensuring our mugs were never empty and our beer remained refreshingly ice-cold. As the evening progressed, our appetites grew, prompting my friend to opt for the wings while I indulged in the special, Cajun kielbasa. The flavors were nothing short of extraordinary, leaving me thoroughly impressed with the culinary offerings at this establishment. I wholeheartedly recommend Grogan's, not only for its superb drinks but also for its delectable food!“

“This was our first experience at this diner. We were there very early. The staff was great! The food delicious and my kids made a special request of their dad to tip heavy. I have great kids who like to show their appreciation for a great experience.“

“My first time this week there, it was a Monday night and they had trivia ( fun try it !) went with another couple that recommended it we had a great time! Good drinks, good food, service was great?Ps I was there today as well! Twice in a week!“

“We’ve been coming pretty regularly for some time and have been very happy. Tonight we had a server, Donna, whom we’ve never had before. She was so awesome and patient with me. I was indecisive and she asked me my likes, my dislikes, what I usually have etc. I wasn’t too sure about the sauce I tried which was probably amazing, just not something I would prefer. She would not take no for an answer and got me a different sauce… even after the kitchen was closed.Another great experience and even better this time around knowing they cared enough to make sure you were happy. ❤️“

“In these times of economic vigilance, a visit to Galloway Grill in Warwick, NY, is akin to a well-considered market strategy. As a Wall Street banker, keenly aware of the volatile economic landscape, every dining choice is a reflection of careful fiscal planning.Galloway Grill is conveniently located and offers a bustling yet welcoming environment. The crowd is a mix of older patrons and families, reflecting a diverse demographic. However, a word of caution for fellow diners: be mindful of the speed traps in the village. The local law enforcement is vigilant, and going over 30 mph could lead to an unwanted financial setback – a scenario all too familiar in my line of work.Service at Galloway Grill is efficient and no-nonsense, much like a well-oiled financial machine. However, there's a slight hiccup when it comes to the children's harmless fascination with jelly packets. In an era where every small expense is scrutinized, this seems a trifle, yet it's emblematic of the broader economic prudence we must all exercise.The menu offerings, like stable financial instruments, are reliable and satisfying. The pancakes, French toast, and particularly the omelets, provide a comforting return on investment, both in terms of taste and fulfillment.The price point, around $70-80 for a family of four, is a significant consideration in these times of economic uncertainty. While the quality is undeniable, the cost is a reminder of the current need for careful budgeting and financial foresight.Galloway Grill occupies a unique position, slightly more upscale than a diner but not quite a high-end restaurant. Its place in the culinary market is somewhat analogous to a mid-cap stock – not without its risks, but offering a potentially rewarding experience.In conclusion, while I recommend Galloway Grill for its quality, do so with an eye on both your wallet and the speedometer. The current economic climate, much like the vigilant speed enforcement in the area, requires constant awareness and prudent decision-making. It's a solid 4-star experience, with the potential for 5, should the economic and local traffic conditions become more favorable.“

“My daughter and I went around lunch time, but we still wanted breakfast. I had french toast, bacon, sausage and eggs. My daughter had pancakes, bacon and grits with cheese. The food was very good, not one complaint. I will definitely be back to try different food choices.“

“The food was excellent, which was good considering we waited a long time to get served. Service as mention was not that great only because they took a long ti.e to take our order and to deliver the food. I think k it may have been that they forgot about us.Why because we were taken to the lower are of the restaurant. Upstairs was not that full when we arrived. But if more people came they may have taken care of them 1st since the kitchen is in the same level. But that is my assumption. All I know there was another family already seated and waiting and they got their good just about 30mins prior to us.Atmosphere seemed nice. Lower level had a dj booth which maybe is used either for special occasion or specific days.I would like to give this restaurant another try because as mentioned their food was great, staff were pleasant, only negative slow.Parking: Spacious and enough.Kid-friendliness: Yes“