I ordered pasta with broccoli oil and garlic. I don't know what happened to this place. It used to be consistent and the food was always good to great. I cook a lot of Italian food and I know that this pasta was likely put in the to go container, stuck together and unseasoned (no salt in the water I'm guessing) and not sauteed with the broccoli and garlic. The broccoli was over cooked and there wasn't enough garlic but the garlic was so under cooked that the broccoli had no flavor. I couldn't put enough Parmesan on it to make it any better and had to throw it away without even eating half. My wife had penne with broccoli and Alfredo sauce. Her food was bland and the pasta was overcooked and falling apart. The broccoli, again, over cooked and dumped on top. She too couldn't finish even half. We had to eat the terrible bread that came with the order to get the taste of the pasta dishes out.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Gloria Carretta
I had penne and broccoli with Alfredo sauce and everything was completely over cooked and tasted so bland. The amount of Parmesan and black pepper I put on didn't even make the food taste good. Not worth almost $50 for two
Food: 1
Gerri
We've ordered before and we pick-up! The Sicilian pizza is amazing. It's the best we've had in this area. Next time we'll try their other items on the menu. I would recommend for sure.Parking: Parking is a bit rough but you can always find a spot even if you have to walk a bit.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Slice
*Yvonne*
I just wish it was a bigger spot!!!Vegetarian options: You can order items w/o meat or cheese + that have great salad selections.Parking: The pizza shop is located next to several stores. You'll get parking but it might not be right in front of the place.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Greek Salad, New York Pizza by the Slice, Buffalo Wings Bone In, Rolls
Neo Abner
I ordered a margherita pizza, this is what they gave me. They need to go back to italy to learn how to make it. They threw tomatoes on top and called it margherita. Disappointed.
Jose Dilone
My fav pizza place right
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: New York Pizza by the Slice
Heriberto R.
TERRIBLE & I MEAN TERRIBLE RESTAURANT ordering from DoorDash they will not give the driver your order they will make some shitty excuse like they don't have that on they're menu very unprofessional & I hope no one has to deal with these idiots they way I had to
J P
We were in the area and happened to stop in for a couple of slices and a salad. What a pleasure to see a familiar face from the old neighborhood of 241st and White Plains Rd! The food, service, and atmosphere were as good, if not better, than I remembered. You have to try Grandma slice! Definitely will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bill O.
Have tried this business on several occasions. Pizza is bland and tastes like it's made with low quality ingredients. Not very tasty and even though it's "heated up" still comes cold. Sauce is ok but cheese is tasteless and probably not the best quality to save money. Other better pizza places in area to try ... sorry but this one is a miss and should not be called "famous" for any reason
First time ordering from this place, the food was excellent. I ordered pizza, chicken parm and penne vodka Thank you
The Age of The Awakening
Best old school NY pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chris L
Didn’t like the pizza just Zeppoli‘
Food: 3
Marilyn Cepeda
Best Pizza and Sevice in North East Yonkers
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Geraldine Kelly
Ordered a Sicilian pie and mozzarella sticks for pickup. The guy told me "ten" minutes! It was fast. I have to say the Sicilian did not disappoint! My mom even enjoyed it and she's a tough critic. Definitely going to order from there again.
Fast courteous and delicious.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
I ordered pasta with broccoli oil and garlic. I don't know what happened to this place. It used to be consistent and the food was always good to great. I cook a lot of Italian food and I know that this pasta was likely put in the to go container, stuck together and unseasoned (no salt in the water I'm guessing) and not sauteed with the broccoli and garlic. The broccoli was over cooked and there wasn't enough garlic but the garlic was so under cooked that the broccoli had no flavor. I couldn't put enough Parmesan on it to make it any better and had to throw it away without even eating half. My wife had penne with broccoli and Alfredo sauce. Her food was bland and the pasta was overcooked and falling apart. The broccoli, again, over cooked and dumped on top. She too couldn't finish even half. We had to eat the terrible bread that came with the order to get the taste of the pasta dishes out.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
I had penne and broccoli with Alfredo sauce and everything was completely over cooked and tasted so bland. The amount of Parmesan and black pepper I put on didn't even make the food taste good. Not worth almost $50 for two
Food: 1
We've ordered before and we pick-up! The Sicilian pizza is amazing. It's the best we've had in this area. Next time we'll try their other items on the menu. I would recommend for sure.Parking: Parking is a bit rough but you can always find a spot even if you have to walk a bit.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Slice
I just wish it was a bigger spot!!!Vegetarian options: You can order items w/o meat or cheese + that have great salad selections.Parking: The pizza shop is located next to several stores. You'll get parking but it might not be right in front of the place.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Greek Salad, New York Pizza by the Slice, Buffalo Wings Bone In, Rolls
I ordered a margherita pizza, this is what they gave me. They need to go back to italy to learn how to make it. They threw tomatoes on top and called it margherita. Disappointed.
My fav pizza place right
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: New York Pizza by the Slice
TERRIBLE & I MEAN TERRIBLE RESTAURANT ordering from DoorDash they will not give the driver your order they will make some shitty excuse like they don't have that on they're menu very unprofessional & I hope no one has to deal with these idiots they way I had to
We were in the area and happened to stop in for a couple of slices and a salad. What a pleasure to see a familiar face from the old neighborhood of 241st and White Plains Rd! The food, service, and atmosphere were as good, if not better, than I remembered. You have to try Grandma slice! Definitely will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Have tried this business on several occasions. Pizza is bland and tastes like it's made with low quality ingredients. Not very tasty and even though it's "heated up" still comes cold. Sauce is ok but cheese is tasteless and probably not the best quality to save money. Other better pizza places in area to try ... sorry but this one is a miss and should not be called "famous" for any reason
Restaurantji Recommends
First time ordering from this place, the food was excellent. I ordered pizza, chicken parm and penne vodka Thank you
Best old school NY pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Didn’t like the pizza just Zeppoli‘
Food: 3
Best Pizza and Sevice in North East Yonkers
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a Sicilian pie and mozzarella sticks for pickup. The guy told me "ten" minutes! It was fast. I have to say the Sicilian did not disappoint! My mom even enjoyed it and she's a tough critic. Definitely going to order from there again.