Custom Cakes near Dublin, OH

Our CupCakery Bakery • $$
54 S High St, Dublin

Customers` Favorites

Wedding Cake
Cupcake

“Laura and team were so amazing!! When the cake shop I had scheduled for my wedding closed it's doors, I reached out to Our Cupcakery. They were able to accommodate us quickly and the cake was even better than the previous shop we utilized! The cake was delivered in perfect condition and was absolutely breathtaking. They truly helped make our big day a success!“

4.5 Superb33 Reviews
Bakle the Baker Bakery •
5516 Stockton Way, Dublin

“We came across Bakle the Baker at the farmers market. My kid absolutely loves well designed frosted cookies in fun shapes, and Bakle the Baker has become a favorite. We're always excited to see what kind of fun new designs she has on hand. We've gotten dinosaurs, cookies shaped like slices of pumpkin pie, Christmas lights, and more. Just browsing the pictures in her gallery on her website is amazing too. We were also excited to find out recently that Winan's carried some of her cookies, so we've been getting some there during the market off-season. The cookies are tasty in addition to looking good, and we were told that they will stay fresh 2-3 weeks in their packaging and can be frozen. Ours haven't lasted long enough to make it to the freezer though! The baker is very friendly and kind too.“

3.7 Good3 Reviews
Menchie's Frozen Yogurt Ice Cream & Frozen Desserts • $
7545 Sawmill Rd, Dublin

Customers` Favorites

Frozen Yogurt

“The place is neat and colorful. The yogurt selection ranges from a variety of natural flavors, like coconut, tart, and pomegranate, to more eclectic choices, like wedding cake and peanut butter.They also have a candy bar where you can top your yogurt with a vast selection of candy, choices like candy worms, chocolate chips, and even marshmallows, to fresh choices like cherries, strawberries, and brownies.We love this place but it frequently happens that they don't have the popular flavors. Maybe it's the time of day we go but it seems they run out of some flavors whenever we are there.“

3.6 Good31 Reviews
Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $
7038 Hospital Dr, Dublin

Customers` Favorites

Caramel Apple Favorites
Chocolate Chip

“I ordered a custom cake for my daughter’s first birthday. When we cut into the cake, we realized that none of the mix-ins I ordered were actually inside the cake. I filled out a form online to let them know about the mistake. Very shortly after, I received a very apologetic voicemail from the store manager and received a full refund instantly. I appreciate the great customer service. The cake still tasted good - it was just plain ice cream inside though.“

3.1 Average23 Reviews
Three Bites Bakery Bakery • $
999 Mt Vernon Ave, Columbus

Customers` Favorites

Brown Butter Sage Sweet Potato Galette
Slice of Italian Lemon & Almond Cake
Mushroom Artichoke & Leek Croissant
Mushroom Artichoke Hot Oil Pizzette
Mexican Hot Chocolate Cookies
Ube Pandesal with Cheese
Polenta Mushroom Sandwich
Italian Anise Cookies
Chinese Pineapple Bun
Slice of Coffee Cake

“We’ve been going to Isa for a while, so when we started planning our wedding, she was honestly our first and only choice. Yes, her pastries are out of this world and I could wax poetic on them - specifically the sweet potato one, look if you know you know - but this review is for the absolute masterpiece of a wedding cake that she put together for us. Because we’re long standing customers, we actually ended up doing both the spring/summer and the fall/winter tasting boxes. There is no wrong answer here, every single cake she makes is delicious, but we ended up going with the pretty traditional almond raspberry with the raspberry jam. It’s sweet, it’s decadent, and it was a huge hit with our guests. And god, just look at it! So beautiful! 100% worth it, choose Isa and Three Bites for all your pastry and cake needs!“

5 Superb58 Reviews
Biscotti Cookies and Cakes Bakery • $$
14 Dillmont Dr, Columbus

“I love her cookies! Makes special order cookies and has her staples. Best almond sugar cookie ever, awesome peanut butter, and oatmeal raisins. Lots of biscotti flavors. Haven't tried a cake yet but a couple of birthdays are coming up. A regular stop when I get my comics just down the sidewalk.“

5 Superb23 Reviews
Mrs. Goodman's Baking Co. Bakery • $$
901 High St, Worthington

Customers` Favorites

Wedding Cake

“My wedding cake was made here!! The comments I got from my wedding guest were "The frosting is perfect" , "The cake is so moist" and so many more. Such a delicious and amazing way to end one of the best days of my life. Special thank you to Donna. Much love!!“

4.9 Superb44 Reviews
Alice's Piece of Cake, LLC Custom Cakes • $$
2433 Home Rd, Powell

Customers` Favorites

Wedding Cake

“We loved our wedding cake from Alice’s Piece of Cake. It came out exactly as we had envisioned it, and it was delicious to eat as well. On more than one occasion our guests commented on how much they enjoyed the cake. We can’t wait to dig into our top tier on our first anniversary!“

5 Superb17 Reviews
Kuro Neko Cake Studio Custom Cakes • $$$
1660 Northwest Blvd, Columbus

“Deborah Li is not only an artist but an actual wizard, and Kuro Neko Cake Studio is her tower of magic. My wife and I were lucky enough to commission a cake from Kuro Neko for our wedding, and it turned out that one of the best parts of the whole reception was telling people that, yes, it really is cake! (I'm still not sure that my wife's grandma believes us.) When we asked for a book cake, we knew it would be beautiful, but upon seeing it the morning of, we were absolutely blown away. The colors, the sculpting, and how it all fit together as a piece of art left us without words. And, somehow, it tasted as good as it looked. As for the process, Deborah was wonderful to work with: attentive, keen to get the personal details just right, and fantastically friendly and supportive. Thanks in no small part to her artistry and amazing work, our wedding day was completely magical!“

5 Superb10 Reviews
Bumbles Bake Shop Bakery • $
9220 Dublin Rd, Powell

Customers` Favorites

Custom Cakes

“I stopped after seeing their sign as I can rarely pass up a bakery! Staff was friendly and helpful. Store is adorable and very clean. Products are nicely displayed in case. I chose the cutout with buttercream and chocolate chip caramel sea salt cookies. Cutout was thick, soft and delicious! The icing was sweet and smooth and really quite perfect. Loved the simple and pretty decor of the flower. Chocolate chip cookie was just as wonderful in its own way. Slightly crunchy around the edges yet soft and chewy in the center. Nice balance of chocolate, caramel and cookie batter topped off with salt. Would highly recommend checking this place out!“

4.8 Superb29 Reviews