Custom Cakes near Powell, OH

“We loved our wedding cake from Alice’s Piece of Cake. It came out exactly as we had envisioned it, and it was delicious to eat as well. On more than one occasion our guests commented on how much they enjoyed the cake. We can’t wait to dig into our top tier on our first anniversary!“

“We were flipping though our wedding album on our recent anniversary, looking back at our photos from that special day and I was reminded of the beautiful and delicious cake that Katie made for our wedding. I never left a review back then, (13 years!) but people who went to our wedding still talk about that cake, so thought it deserved a belated review. Thanks for being so great to work with and making our special day perfect!“

“I stopped after seeing their sign as I can rarely pass up a bakery! Staff was friendly and helpful. Store is adorable and very clean. Products are nicely displayed in case. I chose the cutout with buttercream and chocolate chip caramel sea salt cookies. Cutout was thick, soft and delicious! The icing was sweet and smooth and really quite perfect. Loved the simple and pretty decor of the flower. Chocolate chip cookie was just as wonderful in its own way. Slightly crunchy around the edges yet soft and chewy in the center. Nice balance of chocolate, caramel and cookie batter topped off with salt. Would highly recommend checking this place out!“

“My wedding cake was made here!! The comments I got from my wedding guest were "The frosting is perfect" , "The cake is so moist" and so many more. Such a delicious and amazing way to end one of the best days of my life. Special thank you to Donna. Much love!!“

“A Japanese French bakery in CBUS? Pinch me! If it were only closer to home. Maybe it's a blessing though, because everything is sooo good. Try the made-to-order crèpes, they're very good, I love their almond croissants & mango mousse cake, their sandwiches, breads, everything I tried was done well and with great intention to detail. What a gem!!“

“So glad I discovered this place.! I needed a cake and waited last minute to order it as some of us do..and found this place. They took my order over the phone with a 24 turn around time which I appreciated immensely. The cake was delicious and not overly sweet and affordable. Instead of ordering from a big store, order from here. You won't regret it.“

“I love her cookies! Makes special order cookies and has her staples. Best almond sugar cookie ever, awesome peanut butter, and oatmeal raisins. Lots of biscotti flavors. Haven't tried a cake yet but a couple of birthdays are coming up. A regular stop when I get my comics just down the sidewalk.“

“Sometimes I don't think about recommending some thing that's been around so long. My 50 year old niece used to love to go to this place when she was a kid. I've been taken nephews and cousins and my own children here forever. Their chocolate ice cream is my chocolate Favorite, the kids love the chocolate cones! And I must say the service there is good because it seems to be like we spent about 1000 years in there to spend five dollars per kid lol and nobody else got impatient except me. There's not a lot of room in there but it's just a fun experience for kids and grandmas too“

“So thrilled with my son's birthday cake!! I was a little daunted at first because it's obvious English is a second language for many of the staff here- I was worried something would get lost in translation. But I was worried for no reason. Communication was great! The cake is exactly what I asked for, and my kiddo's going to love it. ?❤️?“

“I kept seeing this business pop up in conversations about the best cake in Columbus, although I admit that living near Belle's Bread means that I wasn't particularly looking for more cake options. But today, I had a long wait for takeout food in the same strip mall, and decided to walk over. And now I am obsessed with their white chocolate mousse cake, even though I'm not usually a huge fan of chocolate mousse cake. So yeah, good job, random bakery in a strip mall. I will now have to come back for the apparently citywidely famous strawberry cake.“

“Laura and team were so amazing!! When the cake shop I had scheduled for my wedding closed it's doors, I reached out to Our Cupcakery. They were able to accommodate us quickly and the cake was even better than the previous shop we utilized! The cake was delivered in perfect condition and was absolutely breathtaking. They truly helped make our big day a success!“