I really like their pizza. It's Ohio Valley style so it's different than your regular midwest pizza. The crust is crunchy but not too thin. The sauce is hearty and robust without being sweet and the cheese goes on at the end. Like I said I really like their pizza and you should give it a try
Sp33dD3mon
Had DiCarlo's Pizza for the 1st time last week. It was a different type of pizza, but really really good! Took my son with me today...the crust is nice and crispy! The sauce has amazing flavor! The way it's baked and then after topped with fresh cheese....amazing!! Looks different, but once you try it..you'll be hooked! New favorite pizza!!Yes...a picture of the box. We finished it!
A K
What a amazing family own pizza spot...their pizza is delicious...the environment is such a vibe... shot out to the employees they were such a kind and friendly with a positive vibe ?...
Lawrence
BE AWARE: USE ONLY DEBIT OR CREDIT CARD...ON 4/22/2023 while visiting from out of town I decided to stop and try this establishment as I was in the mood for some pizza. I brought cash and the staff did NOT have enough cash in the till to make the correct change and simply told me that they did not have enough...so to have my order completed and receive my order I had to make the decision to leave the rest of my change behind as there was no other option...I was never told that this was a cashless establishment by the staff even though it has been reported that there is a sign on the door (of which I obviously did not see), nor was I asked if I could use a debit/credit card instead of cash but rather simple told that they could not provide me the correct change and there was no other option...not even an option to be paid back in coins. After this negative and frustrating experience I contacted DiCarlo's and the franchisee asked me to reach out and when I did he only blamed this on me, citing that I did not see the "Cashless sign" and that they only take cash as a "courtesy" and took no responsibility for not having enough money in his till to make the appropriate change and again making it known that this was my responsibility and not his as the operator...only after I reached out to DiCarlo's again did he offer to make it right but again felt the need to let them know that I am one of the few that complain out of the hundreds of customers that he serves weekly...just be aware that this is not somewhere you want to use cash or even frequent after this story...if you decide to discontinue your business with this establishment after reading this review, I would completely understand and again encourage you to approach this establishment with caution!
Brian Hargis
Great little pizza shop that began in Ohio back in 1929. Many immitations in the last century, but DiCarlos Famous Pizza is the OG.Very unique in taste, and a 'must try' for anyone passing through the area.Hit the HELPFUL button if this was beneficial for you.Brian HargisExpert Google Guide
mark piko
Pizza has changed, flimsy crust, not hot. They said it just came out of the oven, but after a 5 minute drive home it was completely cold. Still love the pizza, but quality needs to
Sawyer Schmidt
I’ve been doing here for a pretty long time, made good conversation with the owner several times and every time me and my family come here it is always a good experience, until tonight. I ordered ahead and got to the store to see the entire store being ran by what seemed like girl high school students at least that was who was at the store front. After not being able to find my name in their machine due ti whatever tech issues they seem to always be having, these girls informed me despite me ordering online for ahead pickup, it would be another 5-8 minutes because on “their” screen the time was double what it was on mine. Upon waiting I was given my pizza and got into the car only to discover it was the incorrect pizza. Per direct order, the ordering merchant they use, the pizza is cheese unless a pepperoni box it check marked. I did not check that box but can you guess what I got? When my family member went in ti correct this (due to me not having the energy being post surgery.) instead of a cheerful acceptance of their mistake and willingness to fix it, they were met with a “it didn’t say that.” and monumental attitude. Which is very uncommon for the type of people they usually hire. They did finally fix the issue after denying accountability for their mistake which is fine but this is enough for me to find a new local pizza place to shop at. While sitting waiting for them to fix their mistake several other people had to leave and come back because they also messed up their orders so I know it was not just me! Monumental inconvenience or minor inconvenience is irrelevant when it is my time and money being played with here. I expect so much better from these people, if this is the future of this store due to short staffing or whatever the case may be, I hate to say I see many people taking their business elsewhere.
Nichole Armstrong
It was an interesting concept of how to make and bake the pizza. It turned out delicious and I would definitely get another slice. We didn't understand how much you get per order, so make sure you clarify that.Our food was made promptly, but the gentleman working seemed to be in a bad mood. Not sure if he was having a bad day or what happened but it was very off putting. There is also not a ton of space to eat if you are bar hopping around downtown Hilliard. Would still come back.
Charles Hickman
Pizza was very disappointing. I grew up in Steubenville, Ohio and this is no way the pizza I grew up on. To serve the pizza that I had is terrible. I recommend to take a trip to Steubenville and learn how to properly make this pizza.Thanks for the reply. I would like a refund, please. I tried to call your Hilliard and Weaterville location, but neither Sara or Mike were available. So, how do I get my money back?
Alex White
Shockingly good pizza, really wasn't expecting to like it so much. Love the cold cheese on top. Also appreciate how simple the menu is.
I received an excellent follow up call from the owner. Mo did an excellent job making it right. This pizza is a uniquely delicious cold cheese style from the Ohio valley area. ENJOY!
412jakeg
Wow. Terrible first impression. Delivery was left on the porch with no door bell, knock or notification. We found it about 20 mins later - cold. Some of the pizza was not fully cooked, others burnt on bottom. I grew up with valley pizza, this is not it. So for $60 we got cold, chewy pizza that we had to reheat. Thanks.
adrien braun
Love Dicarlos!!! But please stop making the crust to thin! Last 2 times I’ve ordered, the crust is being made waaaaaay to thin and hardly any of your delicious sauce :( Please stay true to your original way of making this normally perfect pizza. I would’ve given a 5.0, but this location is under new ownership and seems like they are doing things differently. All the ingredients are the same by taste, but this pizza is being made completely different. Stop skimping, and charging almost twice as much. Sincerely a loyal customer of 10 years.
Michael C.
I love the pizza at the DiCarlos. I'm so glad they reopened! Also, a personal favorite of mine are the pepperoni rolls with banana peppers.
Rick
Pizza sauce on this pie is amazing!!! Crust is magical. Staff is super super friendly.
I really like their pizza. It's Ohio Valley style so it's different than your regular midwest pizza. The crust is crunchy but not too thin. The sauce is hearty and robust without being sweet and the cheese goes on at the end. Like I said I really like their pizza and you should give it a try
Had DiCarlo's Pizza for the 1st time last week. It was a different type of pizza, but really really good! Took my son with me today...the crust is nice and crispy! The sauce has amazing flavor! The way it's baked and then after topped with fresh cheese....amazing!! Looks different, but once you try it..you'll be hooked! New favorite pizza!!Yes...a picture of the box. We finished it!
What a amazing family own pizza spot...their pizza is delicious...the environment is such a vibe... shot out to the employees they were such a kind and friendly with a positive vibe ?...
BE AWARE: USE ONLY DEBIT OR CREDIT CARD...ON 4/22/2023 while visiting from out of town I decided to stop and try this establishment as I was in the mood for some pizza. I brought cash and the staff did NOT have enough cash in the till to make the correct change and simply told me that they did not have enough...so to have my order completed and receive my order I had to make the decision to leave the rest of my change behind as there was no other option...I was never told that this was a cashless establishment by the staff even though it has been reported that there is a sign on the door (of which I obviously did not see), nor was I asked if I could use a debit/credit card instead of cash but rather simple told that they could not provide me the correct change and there was no other option...not even an option to be paid back in coins. After this negative and frustrating experience I contacted DiCarlo's and the franchisee asked me to reach out and when I did he only blamed this on me, citing that I did not see the "Cashless sign" and that they only take cash as a "courtesy" and took no responsibility for not having enough money in his till to make the appropriate change and again making it known that this was my responsibility and not his as the operator...only after I reached out to DiCarlo's again did he offer to make it right but again felt the need to let them know that I am one of the few that complain out of the hundreds of customers that he serves weekly...just be aware that this is not somewhere you want to use cash or even frequent after this story...if you decide to discontinue your business with this establishment after reading this review, I would completely understand and again encourage you to approach this establishment with caution!
Great little pizza shop that began in Ohio back in 1929. Many immitations in the last century, but DiCarlos Famous Pizza is the OG.Very unique in taste, and a 'must try' for anyone passing through the area.Hit the HELPFUL button if this was beneficial for you.Brian HargisExpert Google Guide
Pizza has changed, flimsy crust, not hot. They said it just came out of the oven, but after a 5 minute drive home it was completely cold. Still love the pizza, but quality needs to
I’ve been doing here for a pretty long time, made good conversation with the owner several times and every time me and my family come here it is always a good experience, until tonight. I ordered ahead and got to the store to see the entire store being ran by what seemed like girl high school students at least that was who was at the store front. After not being able to find my name in their machine due ti whatever tech issues they seem to always be having, these girls informed me despite me ordering online for ahead pickup, it would be another 5-8 minutes because on “their” screen the time was double what it was on mine. Upon waiting I was given my pizza and got into the car only to discover it was the incorrect pizza. Per direct order, the ordering merchant they use, the pizza is cheese unless a pepperoni box it check marked. I did not check that box but can you guess what I got? When my family member went in ti correct this (due to me not having the energy being post surgery.) instead of a cheerful acceptance of their mistake and willingness to fix it, they were met with a “it didn’t say that.” and monumental attitude. Which is very uncommon for the type of people they usually hire. They did finally fix the issue after denying accountability for their mistake which is fine but this is enough for me to find a new local pizza place to shop at. While sitting waiting for them to fix their mistake several other people had to leave and come back because they also messed up their orders so I know it was not just me! Monumental inconvenience or minor inconvenience is irrelevant when it is my time and money being played with here. I expect so much better from these people, if this is the future of this store due to short staffing or whatever the case may be, I hate to say I see many people taking their business elsewhere.
It was an interesting concept of how to make and bake the pizza. It turned out delicious and I would definitely get another slice. We didn't understand how much you get per order, so make sure you clarify that.Our food was made promptly, but the gentleman working seemed to be in a bad mood. Not sure if he was having a bad day or what happened but it was very off putting. There is also not a ton of space to eat if you are bar hopping around downtown Hilliard. Would still come back.
Pizza was very disappointing. I grew up in Steubenville, Ohio and this is no way the pizza I grew up on. To serve the pizza that I had is terrible. I recommend to take a trip to Steubenville and learn how to properly make this pizza.Thanks for the reply. I would like a refund, please. I tried to call your Hilliard and Weaterville location, but neither Sara or Mike were available. So, how do I get my money back?
Shockingly good pizza, really wasn't expecting to like it so much. Love the cold cheese on top. Also appreciate how simple the menu is.
Restaurantji Recommends
I received an excellent follow up call from the owner. Mo did an excellent job making it right. This pizza is a uniquely delicious cold cheese style from the Ohio valley area. ENJOY!
Wow. Terrible first impression. Delivery was left on the porch with no door bell, knock or notification. We found it about 20 mins later - cold. Some of the pizza was not fully cooked, others burnt on bottom. I grew up with valley pizza, this is not it. So for $60 we got cold, chewy pizza that we had to reheat. Thanks.
Love Dicarlos!!! But please stop making the crust to thin! Last 2 times I’ve ordered, the crust is being made waaaaaay to thin and hardly any of your delicious sauce :( Please stay true to your original way of making this normally perfect pizza. I would’ve given a 5.0, but this location is under new ownership and seems like they are doing things differently. All the ingredients are the same by taste, but this pizza is being made completely different. Stop skimping, and charging almost twice as much. Sincerely a loyal customer of 10 years.
I love the pizza at the DiCarlos. I'm so glad they reopened! Also, a personal favorite of mine are the pepperoni rolls with banana peppers.
Pizza sauce on this pie is amazing!!! Crust is magical. Staff is super super friendly.