$ • Pizza

4142 Main St, Hilliard
(614) 777-4992


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Recent Reviews

Growing up as a kid spending the summers with my late grandparents in Follansbee, West Virginia we ate this pizza all the time. Now in in Cincinnati and make the drive to Columbus to get a couple trays. Simple the best pizza I have ever tasted. Keep it up and hoping you open one up closer to me soon

I'm from the Ohio Valley and every time I go home to visit, DiCarlo's is always on our list of places to visit. I was so excited to find out there was a DiCarlo's that's about a half hour from where I live now! I bit into my first slice and it's like I was back home again! It was perfect! The crust was crispy, not too much sauce, and the bag of fresh cheese was perfect!Exactly what I was hoping for! Thank you for bringing a piece of the Ohio Valley to the Columbus area!

First thing trying them, we ordered the pepperoni rolls, and the pepperoni pizza. We will def check out Di Carlos pizza again. It's a great change from a traditional type of pizza, they add the toppings on after the pizzas cooked. The crust is good, as well as the sauce. The mozzarella cheese starts to melt ontop of the pizza after that pull it out of the oven to give it a fresh taste. The pepperoni tasted fresh and had a nice flavor and kick to just top it off. Would recommend...read full review

More Reviews(140)


Monday 4 - 8PM
Tuesday 4 - 8PM
Wednesday 4 - 8PM
Thursday 4 - 8PM
Friday 4 - 9PM
Saturday 1 - 9PM
Sunday 1 - 7PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.