Ice Cream Shops near Pickerington

Graeter's Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
1500 Cross Creeks Blvd, Pickerington

“We can't come to Ohio without MULTIPLE trips to Graeter's! We think it's easily some of the best ice cream in the country! Any of their "chip" flavors are phenomenal. My favorite is salted caramel chip or sometimes I go for the Black Raspberry Chip. I tried the Toffee Chip this time, and it was also good. My husband tried the hot honey flavor and it was very unique and he really loved it. (Spicy ice cream anyone?!)“

4.1 Good29 Reviews
Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $$
1718 Hill Rd N Suite 107, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Apple Pie a La Cold Stone
Cake Batter Ice Cream

“I used to go to Cold Stone as a kid all the time (before I had any discerning tastebuds lol). Over a decade later, I found myself revisiting this place a couple of times. Their "creations" are what give them the edge over pretty much every other ice cream spot around town. You get smooth creamy textures, an abundance of toppings/flavors, so many good-looking options that you'll be standing around indecisive on every visit, and no creativity of your own is needed. They definitely stole part of my heart away from Graeter's, and I'm very glad I decided to re-live childhood memories at Cold Stone. Top-notch ice cream chain!“

3.8 Good22 Reviews
Orange Leaf Frozen Yogurt Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $$
10503 Blacklick-Eastern Rd NW, Pickerington

“Me an my daughter found this place on Google an we were both excited this being our first time. The place was nice an clean but the smell was not so pleasant. No one was at the counter to greet us in but they soon came from the back. They were nice an it was kinda easy to figure out what do. The flavors were exciting to choose from. My daughter loved it an so did I.“

3 Average21 Reviews
Dairy Queen Fast Food • $
541 Hill Rd N, Pickerington

Customers` Favorites

Royal New York Cheesecake Blizzard Treat
Fish Sandwich and Onion Rings
Butterfinger Blizzard Treat
Chicken Sandwich and Fries
Quart of DQ Soft Serve
Peanut Buster Parfait
Cheese Curds
Carmel Sundae
Royal Reese
Double

“I usually use the drive thru and have never had a problem. My order is always hot and accurate. I know people complain about the slow service but keep in mind this isn't a fast food place that makes batches of sandwiches and keeps them under a warmer. Your burger and fries are made to order. I think it's great they support the local youth not only by hiring them but also supporting their sports teams. Thanks for being a part of the community DQ!“

3.2 Average69 Reviews
Crumbl - Reynoldsburg Dessert • $
2863 Taylor Rd Ext, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

Crumbl Cookies
Chocolate Chip
Lemon Tart

“My kids and I ; this is our second time trying Crumbl. First time in the store. We loved this weeks cookies. Our least favorite was s’mores. The Golden Oreo cookie was a house favorite. Please keep in mind these cookies are huge and very sweet. I cut each cookie into 4 so we all have a decent size piece to try. I ordered online and picked up in store. I was not greeted upon entry but after I checked in on the app I was greeted and watched my order get packed up.“

4.3 Superb102 Reviews
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard Ice Cream Shop • $
200 Granville St, Gahanna

“It's our family's favorite treat station. They have super delicious Italian ice. a small is heavy and a good value. try a gelati which is Italian ice intermingled with custard. Their custard is extremely creamy and we all enjoy it more than ice cream. This place will remind you of a time gone by. Absolutely wonderful, they have some picnic tables for outside eating. The parking lot is small. There is a great pizza joint around the back also.“

4.4 Superb37 Reviews
Antojitos de mi tierra LLC Ice Cream Shop • $
5137 E Main St, Whitehall

Customers` Favorites

Tostilocos
Esquites

“The quick service Mexican Ice Cream shop has a lot of flavors to choose from. For regular ice cream flavors the pistachio was a smooth and creamy treat. The Oreo frappe was a fancier treat that wowed with the presentation. We were fortunate to get there at a good time as the small shop seems to have an u ending stream of visitors.“

4.7 Superb19 Reviews
Whit's Frozen Custard Ice Cream Shop • $$
564 E Broad St, Pataskala

Customers` Favorites

Ice Cream Cone
Whit's Pints

“I went there on the last day of the season. They will open back up in January 2024. I purchased several quarts of ice cream. My favorite is Candy Cane this time of year. I have enough for my family until they open back up. The ice cream is so smooth and good. We love it.“

4.9 Superb14 Reviews
Whit's Frozen Custard Ice Cream Shop • $
121 S Stygler Rd, Gahanna

Customers` Favorites

Caramel Apple

“I absolutely love soft serve. I have to admit, I find their prices a little expensive, but they are comparable to other ice cream shops in the area. The location is right off the side of the road, but has a cute little outdoor seating area and is dog friendly. During the summer, my dog and I would go hear to enjoy the sun and a yummy treat. The staff are always friendly and loved seeing my dog. He would sometimes get a free treat! A way to get a cheaper whitser is to order the flavor of the weak or day! The scoops are cheaper than if you make or order your own. I highly recommend this place. Also, I keep tabs on the best things I've tried throughout Columbus so far and their german chocolate flavor made the week. If they have this flavor you must try it if you enjoy chocolate, coconut and caramel together. IT'S ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!!!“

4.2 Good57 Reviews
Whit's Frozen Custard Ice Cream Shop • $
7520 Hill Rd, Canal Winchester

“This location is a walk-in shop. The staff is very nice! The frozen custard is great. My favorite thing to get here is the chocolate custard Sunday with fudge, caramel, and brownie bites. I think they have some of the best brownie bites in Columbus. I usually get a mini which is $4.75 and it is actually a decent size.“

4.2 Good21 Reviews
Loading...
map Map