24 Best Ice Cream Shops near Reynoldsburg

Crumbl - Reynoldsburg Dessert • $
2863 Taylor Rd Ext, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

Crumbl Cookies
Chocolate Chip
Lemon Tart

“My kids and I ; this is our second time trying Crumbl. First time in the store. We loved this weeks cookies. Our least favorite was s’mores. The Golden Oreo cookie was a house favorite. Please keep in mind these cookies are huge and very sweet. I cut each cookie into 4 so we all have a decent size piece to try. I ordered online and picked up in store. I was not greeted upon entry but after I checked in on the app I was greeted and watched my order get packed up.“

4.3 Superb102 Reviews
Culver’s American • $
1912 OH-256, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Cheesecake Sundae
Single Butterburger Cheese
Pretzel Burger and Fries
Wisconsin Cheese Curds
Cheeseburger Combo
Root Beer Float
Crispy Chicken
Fish and Chips
Frozen Custard
Fish Sandwich

“I’m not a Midwesterner but I love Culver’s!! Stop by every time I’m in the area. The cheese curds, fries, and burgers are delicious but the CUSTARD is to die for. The concretes are so yummy (but also really filling). I’d rank it way above most fast food but on par with Shake Shack.“

3.9 Good138 Reviews
Dairy Queen Grill & Chill Fast Food • $
6545 E Main St, Reynoldsburg

Customers` Favorites

Chili Cheese Dog with Onion Rings
3-PC Chicken Strips with Fries
Chicken Strip Basket
Strawberry Sundae
Burger and Fries
Ice Cream Cake
Banana Split

“Got in and out quickly with no problems.. even a special order was correct. They have it together they get you through the drive through really quickly. Seem to have a full staff.Kid-friendliness: Kid meals and kiddie cones are ideal for 5 and under.“

3.7 Good44 Reviews
Smallcakes Cupcakery and Creamery Bakery • $
1249 N Hamilton Rd, Gahanna - 7.23 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Caramel Drum Cupcake
Peanut Butter Cup Cupcake
Peanut Butter Cupcake
Strawberry Shortcake
Lemon Drop Cupcake
Boston Cream Pie
Chocolate Cream
Dozen Cupcakes
Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake

“I stopped in randomly on Friday. I picked up 3 red Velvet cupcakes and a peanut butter cupcake to take to my parents. They said they were the best cupcakes they had ever had. My Mom said the red velvet was absolutely delicious! I can’t wait to recommend them to brides. I will definitely be back to get more.“

4.8 Superb67 Reviews
Johnson's Real Ice Cream Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
2728 E Main St, Columbus - 6.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Butter Pecan Ice Cream
Bubble Gum Ice Cream
Iced Sugar Cookies
Chicken Salad
Banana Fudge
Pint

“Really nice "old school" ice cream shop. Walk-up windows up front with places to sit outside when it is nicer. Quite a bit of seating inside. Ice cream, shakes, floats with a variety of toppings to enjoy. There is also the option of getting sandwiches, hot dogs, and soups if you want something more like a lunch/meal.“

4.6 Superb66 Reviews
Arabella Restaurant & Ice Cream Halal • $
1475 Sunbury Rd, Columbus - 7.43 miles

Customers` Favorites

Feta Salad Greek Salad
Cheeseburger
Wings
Fish
Fries

“Food - 4/5Service - 5/5Ambiance - 4/5 (Only Outdoor seating available)Price - Mid RangeOrdered a takeout for 6 piece wings, and a chicken teriyaki sub. The wings were awesome, but the bread for the sub wasn't great. It felt very dry. The flavor was good though.Overall, it's worth a visit if you're around.“

4.7 Superb38 Reviews
Crumbl - New Albany Bakery • $
6326 E Dublin Granville Rd, Westerville - 8.82 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cotton Candy Sugar Cookie
Oatmeal- Iced and Warm
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Milk Chocolate Chip
6 Pack of Cookies
Cornbread Cookie
Churro Cookie
Oreo Cookie

“I've loved crumbl since I came across them on tik tok a couple years ago! I would drive 20min to the Dublin location before the New Albany location opened. Do I think the cookies are a little overpriced? Yes...but they're so freaking good. And service is always super quick!!“

4.3 Superb90 Reviews
Dulce Vida Ice Cream Factory Ice Cream Shop • $$
6146 Cleveland Ave, Columbus - 12.32 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ferrero Rocher in Hand-Dipped Cone
Paletas

“Love this company (there's another location on Sawmill)! Ice cream is rich and very fresh flavors. Kids like to get the ice cream and popsicle combo. The Popsicles are also excellent quality, packed with fruit and not overly sweet. I got the nachos supreme with marinated pork and covered in jalepeños. It's bright and vibrant inside, a perfect pick me up to the grey winter.“

4.4 Superb52 Reviews
Crumbl - Easton Bakery • $
4034 Morse Crossing, Columbus - 8.8 miles

Customers` Favorites

Blueberry Muffin Cookie Churro Cookie Chocolate Cookies and Cream Chocolate Chip
Strawberry Cheesecake Cookies
Peanut Butter Cookies
Classic Sugar Cookie
Birthday Cake
Lemon Crinkle
Tres Leches

“I love these cookies yall! ‼ They are highly addictive!! (I mean seriously what do they put in this cookies??!!)Their flavor/ variety changes/ the week. Their cookies are huge unless you are ordering catering you get the average size! Their customer service does need improvement. We walked in and absolutely no greeting. They have kiosks for you to place your order and pay however that does not excuse them from proper customer service and manners. They were quick about my order. Nothing fancy about the store. There is no sitting area, no art, no razzle dazzle but that okay you come for the cookie“

4.2 Good90 Reviews
Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams Ice Cream Shop • $$
3998 Gramercy St, Columbus - 8.65 miles

Customers` Favorites

Dark Chocolate Truffle
Brambleberry Crisp Pint
Gooey Butter Cake
Frozen Yogurt
Sorbet
Waffle

“BITCH THIS SHIT WAS BUSSSSSSIIINNNN. Best thing I've ever put in my mouth (and there's been a lot;) I want a truck load of those waffle cones, UGH I'm dreaming about them rn. The ooey gooey butter cake deserves a star on the Hollywood walk of fame itself. The special Nebula berry really was "out of this world". Perfectly sweet but not too much and the berry was "berry good". Go get this as soon as you get here!!!!!!!“

4.3 Superb57 Reviews
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard Ice Cream Shop • $
200 Granville St, Gahanna - 5.53 miles

“It's our family's favorite treat station. They have super delicious Italian ice. a small is heavy and a good value. try a gelati which is Italian ice intermingled with custard. Their custard is extremely creamy and we all enjoy it more than ice cream. This place will remind you of a time gone by. Absolutely wonderful, they have some picnic tables for outside eating. The parking lot is small. There is a great pizza joint around the back also.“

4.4 Superb37 Reviews
Johnson's Real Ice Cream, New Albany Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
160 W Main St, New Albany - 8.71 miles

Customers` Favorites

Death by Chocolate Sundae
Lemon Cha Cha

“SO GOOD! First time visiting and I loved it. The store itself is very cute with great parking but also good accessibility from the rest of New Albany if you wanted to have a long walk with your ice cream! The employees were super friendly and helpful and I was grateful to get to sample a couple flavors because their menu is packed with options! I opted for the Buckeye flavor this time and it was delicious - creamy and the perfect peanut butter/chocolate balance without being too rich. the sugar cone was good too- nice and crispy with a good vanilla taste and not just from the cheap box you can find at the grocery (though I don't dislike those). I was only supposed to get one scoop but I definitely got a little extra. Excited to go back and try other flavors!“

4.5 Superb27 Reviews
Antojitos de mi tierra LLC Ice Cream Shop • $
5137 E Main St, Whitehall - 2.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

Tostilocos
Esquites

“The quick service Mexican Ice Cream shop has a lot of flavors to choose from. For regular ice cream flavors the pistachio was a smooth and creamy treat. The Oreo frappe was a fancier treat that wowed with the presentation. We were fortunate to get there at a good time as the small shop seems to have an u ending stream of visitors.“

4.7 Superb19 Reviews
Whit's Frozen Custard Ice Cream Shop • $
121 S Stygler Rd, Gahanna - 6.01 miles

Customers` Favorites

Caramel Apple

“I absolutely love soft serve. I have to admit, I find their prices a little expensive, but they are comparable to other ice cream shops in the area. The location is right off the side of the road, but has a cute little outdoor seating area and is dog friendly. During the summer, my dog and I would go hear to enjoy the sun and a yummy treat. The staff are always friendly and loved seeing my dog. He would sometimes get a free treat! A way to get a cheaper whitser is to order the flavor of the weak or day! The scoops are cheaper than if you make or order your own. I highly recommend this place. Also, I keep tabs on the best things I've tried throughout Columbus so far and their german chocolate flavor made the week. If they have this flavor you must try it if you enjoy chocolate, coconut and caramel together. IT'S ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!!!“

4.2 Good57 Reviews
Graeter's Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
425 Beecher Rd, Gahanna - 6.83 miles

Customers` Favorites

Black Cherry Chocolate Chip Pint
Major League Sundae

“There aren't Graeter's where we live, so thought we would try it. Went about 9:30pm on a Friday night. Although it was busy, there was plenty of staff to get through quickly. Amazing customer service from them all. The ice cream was really good. I recommend the Lemon Meringue Pie for a refreshing treat! We also had a Cookie Monster Sundae, a Shamrock Sundae and a double scoop in a cup that received positive reviews from the family!“

4.3 Superb23 Reviews
Graeter's Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
1500 Cross Creeks Blvd, Pickerington - 2.91 miles

“We can't come to Ohio without MULTIPLE trips to Graeter's! We think it's easily some of the best ice cream in the country! Any of their "chip" flavors are phenomenal. My favorite is salted caramel chip or sometimes I go for the Black Raspberry Chip. I tried the Toffee Chip this time, and it was also good. My husband tried the hot honey flavor and it was very unique and he really loved it. (Spicy ice cream anyone?!)“

4.1 Good29 Reviews
Whit's Frozen Custard Ice Cream Shop • $
7520 Hill Rd, Canal Winchester - 7.83 miles

“This location is a walk-in shop. The staff is very nice! The frozen custard is great. My favorite thing to get here is the chocolate custard Sunday with fudge, caramel, and brownie bites. I think they have some of the best brownie bites in Columbus. I usually get a mini which is $4.75 and it is actually a decent size.“

4.2 Good21 Reviews
Graeter's Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $$
147 Easton Town Ctr, Columbus - 8.6 miles

“There are several ice cream flavors I like here. The peach is great, the chocolate chocolate chip is good but my all time fav is the black cherry chip. The ice cream surrounding the cherries has a good cherry flavor and it has huge chocolate chips that Graeters is known for. I go to the Gahanna location and everyone is friendly. They all say ,Welcome to Graeters . They have an outside eating area and the inside is decorated nicely., It's hard to stay away .“

4.4 Superb13 Reviews
Graeter's Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
2282 E Main St, Bexley - 6.67 miles

Customers` Favorites

Shop Our Flavors Online & in-Store
Double Scoop Waffle Cone
Ice Cream Cones Dishes
Medium Milkshake 20oz
Strawberry Shortcake
Chocolate Chip
Brownie Sundae
Turtle Sundae
Cotton Candy
Butter Pecan

“We are from Nashville, Tennessee and went into Graeter’s for the first time ever. Andrew was the most awesome human being I’ve probably ever met in my life. His constant smile and knowledge of different combinations of ice cream blew me away. He introduced me to a new way of peanut butter and chocolate. He was kind enough to warm both of them up and fold them in together on top of each other. Then he placed it atop some of the most beautiful creamery deliciousness I’ve ever experienced. God bless this man.“

3.8 Good47 Reviews
Whit's Frozen Custard Ice Cream Shop • $
220 Market St Suite B, New Albany - 8.74 miles

Customers` Favorites

Whit's New York Chocolate Chip Cheesecake Ice Cream

“First time at Whits and I was not disappointed! Delicious and such a cute shop in a great location. I got asked to describe it and said it was like a cross between Orange Leaf and Dairy Queen but with better custard and stand by it. So many fun topping options and their own creations and the custard is perfectly creamy, thick and flavorful. I did their take on a mixed custard with toppings and loved it! Perfectly blended and toppings well distributed throughout so you didn't end on a bunch of plain custard. The sizes are also big - the small was about the size of a medium blizzard at DQ for reference.On top of great product, being uptown New Albany, having very easy parking and so close to walking trails is perfect and really makes it all the more enjoyable experience! Will definitely be making a return trip!“

3.8 Good30 Reviews
Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream Shop • $$
1718 Hill Rd N Suite 107, Pickerington - 2.53 miles

Customers` Favorites

Apple Pie a La Cold Stone
Cake Batter Ice Cream

“I used to go to Cold Stone as a kid all the time (before I had any discerning tastebuds lol). Over a decade later, I found myself revisiting this place a couple of times. Their "creations" are what give them the edge over pretty much every other ice cream spot around town. You get smooth creamy textures, an abundance of toppings/flavors, so many good-looking options that you'll be standing around indecisive on every visit, and no creativity of your own is needed. They definitely stole part of my heart away from Graeter's, and I'm very glad I decided to re-live childhood memories at Cold Stone. Top-notch ice cream chain!“

3.8 Good22 Reviews
Dairy Queen Ice Cream Shop • $
364 Granville St, Gahanna - 5.34 miles

“My first job was a DQ member for 6 years. I can tell they care about speed of service, but the quality is a bit lacking - Blizzards with ice cream mess all down the side is not how they should be served.Parking: It's a very tight parking lot and drive thru easily backs up into the street.“

3.7 Good53 Reviews
Cold Stone Creamery Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
101 Mill St Ste 108, Gahanna - 5.77 miles

Customers` Favorites

Peanut Butter Cup Perfection
Apple Pie a La Cold Stone
Birthday Cake Remix
OH Fudge

“Walked in before the first time, the gentleman working behind the counter was talking to me and found out that it was my birthday in a couple days and gave me a beautiful Sunday for free. Couldn't ask for nicer people and a beautiful place to get your sweets and treats. PS it was one of the best Sundays I have ever had in my life.Kid-friendliness: Every kid in the whole world wants to come to this place. ?Wheelchair accessibility: Very large doors to get in and out of“

3.7 Good30 Reviews
Dairy Queen Fast Food • $
4263 Lancaster Ave, Obetz - 9.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Milkshake
Ice Cream Cone
Hot Dog

“Had fast friendly Service. Received food quickly. Restrooms were clean. Parking lot clean all around nice place.Parking: If you can't park there is a big parking lot across the street. I was in a big dump truck and trailer and was able to park.Kid-friendliness: Dairy Queen is always kid friendly. What kid doesn't love ice cream“

3.6 Good46 Reviews
Loading...
map Map