For my birthday this year, I was treated to something special when my partner stumbled upon the Wooster Cheesecakery, an online-only bakery that's truly a hidden gem. Run out of the owner's home, this place may not have a storefront, but it more than makes up for it with its delectable cheesecakes.She ordered me the Reese's Peanut Butter and Chocolate Cheesecake, and it was an absolute delight. From the moment she placed the order, the communication was great, and the cheesecake arrived beautifully packaged right to our car, ensuring it was in perfect condition. The presentation was top-notch, and the taste was even better. The creamy texture, the rich chocolate, and the smooth peanut butter all combined to create a mouthwatering dessert that was the highlight of my birthday.If you're looking for a unique treat or a special gift, I highly recommend checking out the Wooster Cheesecakery. It's a testament to the fact that you don't need a fancy shop to produce high-quality, delicious desserts.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Julia F.
Absolutely delicious and amazing service! We wanted a fun surprise for finding out our baby's gender, and Chris helped us out in the form of a delicious and beautiful cheesecake. It was perfect! We were even able to pick up on short notice. We will definitely be back for future birthdays and celebrations. Thank you for giving us such a wonderful experience!
christine wills
I have tried the Turtle, Eggnog and now the Pumpkin. I am blown away by how creamy and tasty all of them have been. Never tasted a better Cheesecake!! I will be trying them all. The owner is such a wonderful man too!
Terry Singer
I am gluten free and the plain cheesecake is the best that I have EVER had! My daughter makes homemade raspberry sauce to drizzle on top and it is the BEST!
Audrey F.
I ordered a cheesecake from this person that makes cakes out of his house. I had to order from the website. I ordered on Oct 22 for a cake delivery on Oct 27th. On the 27th I waited until the delivery time had passed and called the number on the website. He answered the phone and when I told him I was waiting for an order, he said he didn't have any orders and that he was on vacation. He said his site should not have accepted an order. I had already checked my credit card bill and had been billed for the cake. He was extremely rude and said "there's nothing I can do because I'm on vacation!". I told him I would want a refund, to which he replied "I can't do anything as I'M ON VACATION". He didn't bother to tell me when he might do a refund. I reached out to him through Instant Messenger several times with no response. On November 15th, he replied on Messenger that he had refunded me on November 7th. Today is November 22nd and I STILL don't have the promised refund! I'm having to dispute it with my credit card...
Todd DuFore
Very good and rich cheesecake, best around I would say, even better than juniors from new york! Even the food critic thought it was great. Thank you for the last minute order fullfillment, will buy again.
Shannon G.
Carrot Cake Cheesecake was a hit! I highly recommend Cheesecakery of Wooster. They are large cakes, and melt in your mouth.
Joey Davis
The cheesecake was amazing! The owner was also accommodating and worked to get me the cheesecake around my schedule! Highly recommend!
Amazing!!! I’m sure everyone will flock to the cheesecakes and they are AWESOME, but you’re missing out of you don’t have the pineapple upside down cake. I would kill for that ANY day of the week.
Susan Danley
Always great cakes
Megan Zimmerman
I don't ever take the time to write these and I probably should, especially with great experiences! I live in Denver, Co and my Mom's visit got cut short with me and her grandson, because of a family emergency back in Wooster. When I asked my Mom what she wanted for her birthday, she said cheesecake! I immediately googled cheesecake bakeries in Wooster. I came across The Cheesecakery and decided to go with The white chocolate raspberry cheesecake. And boy did they not disappoint!!!! My uncle, who picked it up, sent me a picture, it looking amazing and delicious! My Mom was surprised and so happy she got her cheesecake! She said, it was one of the best cheesecakes she had ever had! Thank you Cheesecakery for making my Mom's birthday special at such a hard time:) we will definitely be back!!
For my birthday this year, I was treated to something special when my partner stumbled upon the Wooster Cheesecakery, an online-only bakery that's truly a hidden gem. Run out of the owner's home, this place may not have a storefront, but it more than makes up for it with its delectable cheesecakes.She ordered me the Reese's Peanut Butter and Chocolate Cheesecake, and it was an absolute delight. From the moment she placed the order, the communication was great, and the cheesecake arrived beautifully packaged right to our car, ensuring it was in perfect condition. The presentation was top-notch, and the taste was even better. The creamy texture, the rich chocolate, and the smooth peanut butter all combined to create a mouthwatering dessert that was the highlight of my birthday.If you're looking for a unique treat or a special gift, I highly recommend checking out the Wooster Cheesecakery. It's a testament to the fact that you don't need a fancy shop to produce high-quality, delicious desserts.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely delicious and amazing service! We wanted a fun surprise for finding out our baby's gender, and Chris helped us out in the form of a delicious and beautiful cheesecake. It was perfect! We were even able to pick up on short notice. We will definitely be back for future birthdays and celebrations. Thank you for giving us such a wonderful experience!
I have tried the Turtle, Eggnog and now the Pumpkin. I am blown away by how creamy and tasty all of them have been. Never tasted a better Cheesecake!! I will be trying them all. The owner is such a wonderful man too!
I am gluten free and the plain cheesecake is the best that I have EVER had! My daughter makes homemade raspberry sauce to drizzle on top and it is the BEST!
I ordered a cheesecake from this person that makes cakes out of his house. I had to order from the website. I ordered on Oct 22 for a cake delivery on Oct 27th. On the 27th I waited until the delivery time had passed and called the number on the website. He answered the phone and when I told him I was waiting for an order, he said he didn't have any orders and that he was on vacation. He said his site should not have accepted an order. I had already checked my credit card bill and had been billed for the cake. He was extremely rude and said "there's nothing I can do because I'm on vacation!". I told him I would want a refund, to which he replied "I can't do anything as I'M ON VACATION". He didn't bother to tell me when he might do a refund. I reached out to him through Instant Messenger several times with no response. On November 15th, he replied on Messenger that he had refunded me on November 7th. Today is November 22nd and I STILL don't have the promised refund! I'm having to dispute it with my credit card...
Very good and rich cheesecake, best around I would say, even better than juniors from new york! Even the food critic thought it was great. Thank you for the last minute order fullfillment, will buy again.
Carrot Cake Cheesecake was a hit! I highly recommend Cheesecakery of Wooster. They are large cakes, and melt in your mouth.
The cheesecake was amazing! The owner was also accommodating and worked to get me the cheesecake around my schedule! Highly recommend!
Worth every penny! Yum!!! ??
Worth every penny! Yum!!! ??
Restaurantji Recommends
Amazing!!! I’m sure everyone will flock to the cheesecakes and they are AWESOME, but you’re missing out of you don’t have the pineapple upside down cake. I would kill for that ANY day of the week.
Always great cakes
I don't ever take the time to write these and I probably should, especially with great experiences! I live in Denver, Co and my Mom's visit got cut short with me and her grandson, because of a family emergency back in Wooster. When I asked my Mom what she wanted for her birthday, she said cheesecake! I immediately googled cheesecake bakeries in Wooster. I came across The Cheesecakery and decided to go with The white chocolate raspberry cheesecake. And boy did they not disappoint!!!! My uncle, who picked it up, sent me a picture, it looking amazing and delicious! My Mom was surprised and so happy she got her cheesecake! She said, it was one of the best cheesecakes she had ever had! Thank you Cheesecakery for making my Mom's birthday special at such a hard time:) we will definitely be back!!