8 Best Pizza Restaurants in Worthington

Dewey's Pizza Pizza • $
640 High St, Worthington

Customers` Favorites

Dewey's Calzone Comes with Mozzarella and Ricotta with Your Choice of Up to 3 Ingredients
Don Corleone Pizza
Dewey's Original
Pepperoni Pizza
Ryan's Inferno
Bronx Bomber
Veggie Pizza
White Pizza
Meatball
House

“Yesterday we had a pizza party at my home. I ordered a 17" half and half with a square cut. 1st half was a Don Corleone, the 2nd half was a Porky Fig. They made a mistake in the cut, so I had to wait 8 minutes while they baked a new pie. Then while I was waiting they gave me a gift card for their mistake. This I totally was not expecting. The pizza was awesome. The Porky Fig had a nice sweetness from the fig jam. The Don Corleone had just the right spice from the meat. Deweys has always had my favor taste buds, with variety of pizza option. Their salads are tasty also. Thanks DeweysParking: Curbside pickup was easy access.“

4.6 Superb45 Reviews
Amano's Pizza • $
220 Worthington Mall, Worthington

“I stopped in because I've been craving a meatball sub and I saw the head one on the menu. I never got that meatball sub because it turns out they also have a pizza buffet at lunch time at a price I just could not refuse.I like the pizza very much, even though it is a thinner crust then I usually prefer. So two thumbs up there.The pizza buffet came with a soup that was good, and a salad bar that was also better than I expected.To top it all off, they have Coke products, my favorite.Needless to say, I was very impressed.My celiac daughter enjoyed the gluten free pizza today.Dietary restrictions: They have a gluten free pizza“

4.8 Superb21 Reviews
Neighborhood Sbarro Pizza • $
2163 W Granville Rd, Worthington

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Meatballs

“Yall, I haven't had Sbarro pizza in YEARS!! We saw this one as we were coming back from a trip to Columbus a week or two ago and had to come back & try it. We bought us each a slice, just to try it because it had been so long & I wasn't sure if I'd like it. Yall it was so good that we went in & ordered two whole pizzas to take home! It was just as good as I remembered. We'll definitely be back.“

4.7 Superb23 Reviews
Pies & Pints - Worthington, OH Pizza • $
7227 N High St, Worthington

Customers` Favorites

Steak and Mushroom Pizza
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Char-Grilled Hot Wings
Pork & Pepper Nachos
Char Grilled Wings
Black Bean Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Italian Pizza
Spinach Salad

“Great dinner date with my son, easy to get into he shopping center (if not slightly confusing to find the entrance if you don't park in the right place). Our server was wonderful and attentive and our pie was delicious. Service was fast and great. Bathrooms were clean. ?“

4.3 Superb77 Reviews
Worthington Pizza Primo Pizza • $
895 High St, Worthington

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic Bread
Italian Sub
Meatballs
Pizza Sub
Salad

“Absolutely fantastic pizza - we had the pepperoni, and got a half BBQ chicken, half Buffalo chicken. Everything was wonderful. Very thin crust, and great service. There is seating inside enough for four people, and that's exactly what we had. The service was quick and excellent, especially for a place not accustomed to dine in. Prices were very reasonable, as well.“

3.8 Good39 Reviews
Borgata Pizza Cafe Pizza • $$
2285 W Granville Rd #113, Worthington

Customers` Favorites

Spicy Sausage Stuffed Peppers
New York Style Cheese Pizza
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Cheese NY Style Pizza
House Made Meatballs
Meatball Appetizer
Pizza by the Slice
Homemade Cannolies
Buckeye Cannoli
Caprese Salad

“Literally- AMAZING!!For my husband‘s birthday, I made a little mini pizza tour of New York style pizza shops here in Columbus. He’s from upstate New York, and pizza just isn’t the same around here… Until we found this gem. Incredible food, amazing staff & we cannot wait to come back! You have to try the cannoli it’s Scrumptious and the pizza is just about as close to New York as you can get without being there!!Everything we tried was amazing.And to top the experience off when the staff heard of what we were doing, they even brought out something additional for us to samples just so we could get a good taste of quality pizza. That’s what local shops are all about and we just loved it.!!!!“

3.8 Good65 Reviews
Marco's Pizza Pizza • $
1361 Worthington Centre Dr, Worthington

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Magnifico
Thin Crust Pizza
14'' Large Pizza
Cheezybread

“This is the only place I go to right now when I want pizza while working (really more of a go-to for sandwiches). The food is always hot, fast, and fresh. The employees are always busy, but also always polite. Can't really ask for more.“

3.7 Good29 Reviews
Jet's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
660 High St, Worthington

Customers` Favorites

NY Style

“I ate a pleasant lunch on 12-29-2023 at Jet's Pizza at 660 High St. in Worthington.One of the on-line sources that has information about that restaurant had said that they offer "delivery" only; another source had said that they offer "delivery and dine-in."I decided to visit there "in person" to find out whether or not I would be able to eat there.That location of Jet's Pizza has a middle-sized dining room that could potentially seat 25 people at a time. I asked the guy at the counter if I could eat there; he told me that I was welcome to eat there.My food choice had been "Boneless Chicken Wings with Mild Buffalo sauce." I had not wanted to eat an entire pizza that day so boneless chicken wings had been a great choice and had been quite delicious and had been quite filling.After I had eaten my lunch at Jet's Pizza, I walked half a block south to Dewey's Pizza which has a large parking lot where I would be able to far more easily be picked up by Uber for my ride home.If you are planning to eat at any location of Jet's Pizza [rather than carrying out your food to eat elsewhere], I recommend finding out in advance whether or not they offer "dine-in."The Jet's Pizza location that is closest to where I live [1242 W. Fifth Ave.] has an extremely-small customer area with a metal bench but has no other furniture in that area except for that bench.“

3.5 Good37 Reviews
Loading...

Taste More Cuisines In Worthington

map Map