16 Best Italian Restaurants near Bixby

“12-20-2023. Oh my word! So delicious! About 3pm. Late lunch, early supper. We order and take home. The Ken's sauce is a bit spicier. We like it the best. We have had chicken bites/chunks all over town. These are still our favorite. They also offer dry rubs for their chicken chunks/ bites. We like them deep-fried and dipped in hot honey. My husband craves them! Always clean and we are very happy customers. If you aren't happy about something, tell them right then. They will do everything they can to correct it. Don't wait and complain. They can't keep up some times. Great staff. Happy customers, happy life?“

“Our party of four stopped here for brunch. The restaurant was largely full but we were seated promptly. Our server was excellent. Very friendly and knowledgeable. I ordered the meatball hoagie and had a choice of french fries or in-house made chips. The server steered me towards the fries and they were Shoestring style and lightly seasoned. I thought they were great. The meatball hoagie was very good and had a very nice roll holding it all together. The temperature of the meatballs, sauce and cheese was barely adequate however,. Had I not been with a party of four I would have sent it back to be remade hotter. For dessert we all tried the Creamsicle gelato and could not have been happier. It was so smooth and creamy. Overall the prices here seem very reasonable and it's a nice atmosphere.“

“First time visiting with some family and this place was amazing!The atmosphere was quiet and relaxing. Our waitresses was very knowledgeable and helped with recommendations based on food preferences! The raviolis were amazing, the sauce was perfect! The cannolis were so tasty and sweet! Will definitely return back next time I come to town.“

“Excellent customer service from the manager, Danny! Our pizza came out with a slight bubble in the crust, and he instantly let us know that they were making an entirely new pizza for us to take home. We hadn’t complained or expected a new pizza, but he really went above and beyond for us. The food was excellent as usual - highly recommend the cheesy mushrooms as an appetizer!“

“The grilled organic chicken sub sandwich is perfectly seasoned and on the absolute best sub bread around! Definitely my favorite sandwich here!Other favorites are the cabbage rolls, hummus and pita bread. The taco salad is great too. I haven't had a chance to try very many items yet because I most always go for the grilled chicken sub.They do a ton of business during the lunch time with dine-in and carry-out and sometimes it's a 30 minute wait for your order, just FYI. Just know this going in and if you are in a big hurry then wait and go on a day when you have more time. Good tasty homemade food and nice owners.“

“Easily the best sandwich spot in town. Their hoagies are like none other, and the staff is very kind and friendly. After coming here, it's hard to think about eating a sandwich anywhere else - the hoagies are too good! We love coming here for lunch, and I would recommend to anyone looking for a good lunch/sandwich spot.“

“They have a great pie...the wife had a veggie and I pepperoni....I thought by the way people were eating this pizza by folding it over....it was going to be tuff like a lot of the NY pizzas are but I was pleased to see that this wasn't the case the foundation (crust) was thin but tender and crunchy. The toppings were good and the wife also could not find falt with her pie.....however, pizza is everywhere...that the great thing about pizza...it's all different but good...but, we both thought for what you ended up getting was good just ridiculously over priced.“

“Oh my goodness, guys! You won't believe it! This is my very first visit to Hideaway, and let me tell you, this pizza is legit New York style! We drove all the way from Fort Worth, not knowing what to expect, but boy, oh boy, our stomachs hit the jackpot here! It's like a match made in pizza heaven!“

“Classic regional pizza chain that is a fixture in Tulsa, with multiple locations.Our server was a bit too chatty and wasn't as attentive as we've had in the past.Overall, still a good experience and surprisingly reasonably-priced. For instance, bottomless fountain drinks, with a take-home, souvenir cup, are only $2 69, instead of more than $3 elsewhere.“

“Our recent visit to Andolini's Pizza in Broken Arrow was nothing short of exceptional. From the moment we arrived, we were greeted promptly and ushered to a table in a prime location within the restaurant.Our server, Ava, brought an infectious energy to our dining experience, providing attentive and top-notch service throughout our meal. Her enthusiasm and attentiveness truly enhanced our visit.Now, let's talk about the food - absolutely delicious! I couldn't resist trying the garlic knots, and they exceeded my expectations. Each knot was drenched in olive oil and generously topped with Parmesan cheese, creating a mouthwatering combination of flavors.Overall, our experience at Andolini's Pizza in Broken Arrow was outstanding. From the welcoming atmosphere to the delicious food and excellent service provided by Ava, it's safe to say we'll be returning soon.“

“Chloe Williams was our server and she's just delightful, she's the one with the bubbly personality and blue hair bandana :) 10/10 I was shocked to learn she's only started working there a couple weeks ago!! Total natural. If you want to have an extra happy experience, definitely ask for Chloe lol“

“I went to thus Bill and Ruth's the other day. I didn't get the gentleman's name, but he was so sweet. He helped me figure out what I would like. The sandwich was amazing! Thus was wayyyyyyy better than any subway. It was uo there with jersey Mike's, but they made different types.He had this special sauce you can add that was amazing, and also some jalapeño sauce! Absolutely amazing. While I was eating, three people, I presume as regulars because they knew each other and knew what to order right away. Definitely will.be going back when that food is on the mind!“

“Birthday lunch with my sister. We stayed for hours talking and catching up. The food was amazing the service was amazing and the server in particular made the visit top notch. So thank you, Mister-- we will definitely ask for you by name when visiting again. Thank you for being so kind and making our sister visit a great one!“

“One of, if not the best, authentic Italian restaurants in Tulsa. Has been in the same South Tulsa location since at least the 1990s, and they have a second location cost to downtown tulsa, which speaks to the quality of the food and service. The free bruschetta appetizer is truly the best around. The lasagna is very good, and the Asparagus is always prepared perfectly. Low lit dining room with VERY comfortable booths that are more like a high back sofa, which is perfect for a relaxing meal. Relatively quiet dining room, even when crowded, so you can have a close conversation without yelling. Great for a romantic date night or special occasion. If you have not tried this restaurant, I would highly recommend you do so.“

“I’m not an Olive Garden fan but my family is. Got to the restaurant in time for the Lunch menu and it was sufficient amount of food.Salad and breadsticks are always a part of the meal. The food was good and the server was excellent. The calamari appetizer was very good.“

“Lovely service (seriously best I've had in a while). Destiny and the manager took good care of us, the food was hot, great flavor profile (Margherita pizza, mozzarella rounds and cookie with ice cream). Food portions were good. Restaurant was busy but chill, not overwhelming or too loud. Would definitely recommend :)“