18 Best Italian Restaurants in Whitby

“We had an amazing lunch, the service was excellent and the food was delicious. we'll definitely be back.“

“Brutal, service rather lack of, is absolutely horrible. Do not go unless you have a few hours! So poor.“

“My first visit to your restaurant...and it certainly will not be the last! Exquisite! Michael....thank you for a beautiful dining experience.“

“The food is excellent! We love getting family combos for our family gatherings and skip the cooking and just enjoy ourselves. It is so delicious! We especially love the lasagna as well as chicken rose penne. The shepherds pie is excellent too. Honestly everything tastes great!“

“Amazing food! T is Super friendly and helpful and accommodated my requests. Staff is really friendly also! Thank you!! If you haven’t tried wings from here and reading this, you have to try them!! Thank you T !“

“The meal was the most authentic Italian meal we have had in a long time. The sauce was perfect! Highly recommend and don't forget to have the homemade pasta!“

“Another delicious meal thanks to Chef José and his team! Gracias!!“

“Cassidy was our server- A+.
Food arrived slightly less than hot -
Overall food was tasty 8/10
Atmosphere was a bit loud due to the open concept…
We would return when not as busy as it usual would be on a Saturday evening…“

“On Thursday, September 18, 2025, at 12:30 pm, after a mix-up with our reservation at a nearby restaurant, we decided to try Tuscan Wolf Pizzeria. At first, it didn’t seem particularly remarkable, but we were pleasantly surprised. Our waitress, whom I believe was named Lianne, was incredibly friendly and took the time to carefully explain the various menu options to us. The pizza was outstanding and truly reminiscent of what you’d find in southern Italy. We highly recommend this restaurant to anyone seeking excellent service and an authentic Italian pizza experience.“

“Mancini's is the best place for pizza in Whitby 'Hands Down'...changed from other places that took half the weight out of their product, like we wouldn't notice! We changed to Mancini's and won't go back!! Very clean and lovely family business, Thank you Mancini's !! Susan and Bruce Whitby“

“pizzas are always fresh , vegetables are fresh their wings are cooked perfect , I recommend this place 💯.“

“We ordered the oh rasta chicken penne for a dinner party and it did not disappoint! The serving size was amazing; it was advertised as serving 10 and it easily served 15 of us with lots of leftovers. We are looking forward to going back and trying out some other menu options!“

“The quintessential hole in the wall that delivers deep and well thought out food. Colin - Chef/owner is a top fella! Very accommodating“

“We ordered out from Navona Pizzeria Oshawa and we were so pleased with the quality of food. They have a variety of food that is made fresh on site. We have used delivery for a few orders. Both drivers are so nice and super fast. We have also done pick up and the owners are so friendly. The employees are so kind and very helpful. Our pizza was so happy with the food quality. We love the pizza, wings, lasagna, breadsticks and cheesecake.“

“I don’t usually write reviews, but after several visits to the Pizza Pizza location in Whitby, I genuinely felt this team deserved one. In a time when great customer service is becoming harder to find, this restaurant consistently delivers an experience that goes far beyond expectations.

First and foremost, the pizza is simply outstanding. Every order has been incredibly fresh, perfectly baked, and full of flavor. The crust strikes the ideal balance between crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, while the cheese is always generously layered and melts beautifully. The sauce has a rich, well-balanced taste that complements the toppings instead of overpowering them. Whether it’s a classic pepperoni, deluxe, veggie, or one of their specialty pizzas, every bite tastes like it was made with genuine care and attention.

What impressed me even more is the consistency. Many restaurants can make a great pizza once, but this location does it every single time. The quality never seems to fluctuate. The ingredients are always fresh, vegetables are crisp, meats are flavorful, and everything is evenly distributed across the pizza. It’s clear that the staff take pride in their work rather than simply rushing orders out the door.

The customer service is truly exceptional. Every staff member I’ve interacted with has been warm, friendly, patient, and professional. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with genuine smiles and positive attitudes. They take the time to answer questions, offer recommendations, and make sure every order is prepared exactly as requested. Even during busy hours, they remain calm, organized, and courteous to every customer.

One thing that really stands out is how much they care about customer satisfaction. If you have any special requests or dietary preferences, they listen carefully and make every effort to accommodate.“

“I’ve been coming here regularly, and it’s always a great experience. The staff are consistently friendly and greet you with a smile, the restaurant is always clean, and the pizza is always fresh and delicious. Highly recommend!“

“This is the first time we are experiencing taste of Cucini Xpress in Whitby.We ordered Fried rice & it was fresh & taste good. I recommend Cucini Xpress to Sri Lankan foodies to experience Sri Lankan taste..I wish them All the best!!✨✨“

“Today I picked up a catering order from this location based on referral from my team, drove from Pickering and I got to say, the drive was worth it… first I got an amazing price on 8 extra large pizza compared to Pizza Nova, secondly the value and pizza itself, just amazing. Let me put it this way I was not embarrassed in front of my guests… this store delivered way beyond my expectations so thank you. Was there met two gents Noor & Masood who were working, you guys are amazing thank you!“