My last few visits the pizza had been a bit overcooked and lacks the oils of real Brooklyn Pizza. We dined in and the temperature was frigid at best, even the pizza oven guy wore his hoodie...very uncomfortable atmosphere. Still close to the best pizza Erie has to offer.
Kevin Boxer
Great food. Love the Italian atmosphere.
Glenn McKnight
Classic NYC pizza. Big slices of hand tossed, plus excellent wings.
Kelly Mcknight
Ok place for quality Pizza. The service was helpful and kind. This place has a cool feel to it. This place has great reviews for a reason.
marc longstreet
Slow as hell! Ordered ahead and still had to wait. I don't get the appeal to this place interior is beyond bland. Would not recommend.
Nyla Upal
Good pizza, lots of ingredients (some fell off). Wings were also good
Jason Pauli
Brooklyn has one of the top 2 veggie pizzas in Erie. HIGHLY recommended.
Another MAD Creation
The pizza is absolutely fabulous! The crust has just the right amount of crunch vs chew and the sauce and cheese are perfect! Best tasting pizza in town!
Denise Altadonna
Great service, pizza was fantastic & reasonably priced. Will be ordering again from them.
Danielle Jahn
Excellent pizza! Great service. Very friendly. Would definitely order from them again.
I went to get a large Pepperoni Pizza with my wife. I was so hyped about it because they had recently opened again. And to my surprise coming home, it looked like a cheese pizza. The pricing was high but I figured that the pizza would be worth it, I was wrong completely. I had high expectations for them and was disappointed. If I go again, I hope that they get better, nice people but seem really cheap with giving toppings.
Michael McMillan
Great place for NYC style pizza! Worth a trip to or a stop on the way through Erie from Cleveland!
Jenna L.
We were staying over night headed or family vacation in upstate New York. After putting our toddler down we ordered a plain pepperoni pizza. They were awesome enough to quietly deliver the pizza to our hotel room door. I can honestly say it was the best meal we had our whole trip! We ate the whole large pie because it was addictive. The crust was firm and crispy without being overdone. The sauce and cheese were very fresh and tasty. Only sad we couldn't stop in and have another on our way back home.
Rudy Wilkinson Jr
Bottom of pizza was burnt and dough was much tougher than I was expecting with a NY style. Crust was hard as a rock. It looks like something that would normally been a lot better. Not for the only time we will have visited. :(
Robin Fox
You really need to address your staff.The guy who spins the dough is doing everything.The others are finding ways to do nothing.You are lucky you have such a responsible person working for you.
My last few visits the pizza had been a bit overcooked and lacks the oils of real Brooklyn Pizza. We dined in and the temperature was frigid at best, even the pizza oven guy wore his hoodie...very uncomfortable atmosphere. Still close to the best pizza Erie has to offer.
Great food. Love the Italian atmosphere.
Classic NYC pizza. Big slices of hand tossed, plus excellent wings.
Ok place for quality Pizza. The service was helpful and kind. This place has a cool feel to it. This place has great reviews for a reason.
Slow as hell! Ordered ahead and still had to wait. I don't get the appeal to this place interior is beyond bland. Would not recommend.
Good pizza, lots of ingredients (some fell off). Wings were also good
Brooklyn has one of the top 2 veggie pizzas in Erie. HIGHLY recommended.
The pizza is absolutely fabulous! The crust has just the right amount of crunch vs chew and the sauce and cheese are perfect! Best tasting pizza in town!
Great service, pizza was fantastic & reasonably priced. Will be ordering again from them.
Excellent pizza! Great service. Very friendly. Would definitely order from them again.
Restaurantji Recommends
I went to get a large Pepperoni Pizza with my wife. I was so hyped about it because they had recently opened again. And to my surprise coming home, it looked like a cheese pizza. The pricing was high but I figured that the pizza would be worth it, I was wrong completely. I had high expectations for them and was disappointed. If I go again, I hope that they get better, nice people but seem really cheap with giving toppings.
Great place for NYC style pizza! Worth a trip to or a stop on the way through Erie from Cleveland!
We were staying over night headed or family vacation in upstate New York. After putting our toddler down we ordered a plain pepperoni pizza. They were awesome enough to quietly deliver the pizza to our hotel room door. I can honestly say it was the best meal we had our whole trip! We ate the whole large pie because it was addictive. The crust was firm and crispy without being overdone. The sauce and cheese were very fresh and tasty. Only sad we couldn't stop in and have another on our way back home.
Bottom of pizza was burnt and dough was much tougher than I was expecting with a NY style. Crust was hard as a rock. It looks like something that would normally been a lot better. Not for the only time we will have visited. :(
You really need to address your staff.The guy who spins the dough is doing everything.The others are finding ways to do nothing.You are lucky you have such a responsible person working for you.