Ice Cream Shops near Finleyville

“Don't order through the mobile app on your way to work if you don't know how busy they usually are. I'm not from the area. I don't know the hot spots yet. It was super busy. The staff was very nice after I complained about waiting (10 minutes after the time it said it was ready to be picked up. Which is understandable now seeing how busy they were) and wanting to cancel so I could get to work. They had the food ready instead, which was better than canceling! Thank you!Parking: Don't park by the drive thru, you'll get blocked in.“

“My baby shower was held at The Steeping Leaf. We visited twice before: once for an afternoon tea and once for lunch. Both times beforehand we were met by the owner to discuss the shower. The tea menu is extensive and each time we had excellent tea. All of the food is delicious! For the shower, once we had discussed what we were looking for (Mad Hatter Tea Party), the owner took it from there. We arrived for the baby shower and everything was decorated and set up. It looked incredible! The space is so inviting, the decorations were amazing, food was delicious, and the tea was great as well. I would recommend the Steeping Leaf for breakfast, lunch, afternoon tea, and special events. We will certainly be back!“

“Great ice cream treats and candy!!! So wonderful that you have non dairy ice cream ! My daughter was almost in tears because you had a non dairy option for her. We will definitely be back!!“

“The ice cream is great and the people are super nice. They always give you such a large amount for what you usually pay which is nice. Definitely will be returning ?Parking: Parking lot is a little bad if it's crowded, but usually fine“

“We stopped for the first time this evening. So glad we did! The maple bourbon pecan and the butter pecan were delicious!!! We will definitely be back to try other flavors. Excellent ice-cream! Support local!“

“This place has the best soft serve in the area hands down. They flurry flavors are more than any other place I’ve seen.The girls than man the windows are so sweet and always so efficient. I always put money in the college fund jars. They definitely deserve it and how can you not!“

“I love this place because of the quick and accurate service and the rotation of all of the delicious and addicting ice flavors; and not to mention the 30% off discount for all hospital workers when you show your work ID. Makes me feel a bit better for a healthcare employee who isn't getting hazard pay lol ??‍♀️“

“First time visit Wish I have known about this place before now Definitely will return ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Under new management and better than ever. I met the owner and he is very nice and very knowledgeable about his ice cream game. The prices are really affordable and the ice cream and the selection of different products will have us coming back all summer long.“

“Sweet, sweet shop. Perfect covered apples, and super friendly. Perfect place for giving season.“

“Al wealth management has a proven track record of success, with impressive returns and a strong commitment to risk management. Their AI-driven approach is cutting-edge and sets them apart from traditional wealth management firms. I've seen firsthand how their personalized strategies have helped clients achieve their financial goals, and I highly recommend Kristen Tanya“

“oh my God we love this place that's the best homemade ice cream shop in the Pittsburgh area y'all are running neck and neck with scoops and more but you're mainly my choice because you're close to my home and I've been telling all my friends and fellow ice cream lovers about you“

“Great ice cream and quick service“

“went today for the first time, was very impressed! staff is super helpful and friendly, and the ice cream is absolutely amazing! They also have dairy free and gluten free options.“

“I held my daughter's 2nd birthday party at Millie's South Fayette! The room itself is darling, and perfectly set-up to host family and friends for socializing, eating, and enjoying ice cream. The staff accommodated all my needs/asks and bringing in my own food was a great advantage. They even wrote a beautiful birthday message on the chalkboard! It was such a delightful morning, and an awesome option for a low-key and super SWEET party!“

“build your own ice cream cup. with all of the topping you can imagine it becomes more than a sweet treat! I can only wish we had a Sincerely Yogurt on rt 51!!“

“This place is the best it has that comfortable and very clean feeling but the staff is super amazing so is the ice cream! Brooklyn and all of the staff is incredibly happy and welcoming always like even if the ice cream shop is filled up with lines of customers! Thanks everyone yinz are awesome and the ice cream is some of the best I've ever had !“

“This Rita's is the best Rita's in this area. It's also the only Rita's with Chocolate flavored Italian ice in this area. I have a Rita's 10min away from my house but I drive 30min just to get the Chocolate flavored ice here. Also the owner is such a nice person!“

“Al wealth management has a proven track record of success, with impressive returns and a strong commitment to risk management. Their AI-driven approach is cutting-edge and sets them apart from traditional wealth management firms. I've seen firsthand how their personalized strategies have helped clients achieve their financial goals, and I highly recommend Kristen Tanya“

“The cookies at this location are always tasty and presented well. No complaints there. However, every time I’ve gone, they’ve been sold out of at least one flavor. Just a little bit disappointing, even if it’s not the employees’ faults! Otherwise, definitely recommend“

“Always great ice cream and the girl serving was very kind and hard-working!“

“Food is always amazing! The owner Jamie is so sweet! I love how she comes up with new ideas all the time. The staff is always friendly as well :) Definitely recommend it to anyone.“

“Me and my family live going to this location! They are always friendly and give us wonderful suggestions every visit. We never leave disappointed which is why we continue to return each year. Thank you to all the staff for the great service ❤️ ?“

“We got burgers and a blizzard for dinner and everything was excellent. The burgers actually had a slice of tomato on instead of the normal fast food burgers where finding the tiny slice can be quite challenging. Good grub, empty dining area = ultimate eating experience!“

“I came here while traveling and wanting something sweet and boy did get what I came for. I got a Chocolate waffle cone and it was 100% amazing definitely recommend if you like chocolate. The customer service was great and we were served relatively quickly. It’s great if you’re just looking for some ice cream on a hot day!“

“The service is wonderful. Everyone is so nice here and the ice cream is exactly what you hope it is - the perfect combination of icy and creamy.They didn’t have birthday cake so I got cake batter and I wasn’t disappointed in the slightest.“

“I absolutely loved the Gelati Italian Ice in Guava with Black Raspberry ice cream! The guava is simply sweet and not too sweet just the perfect amount. Super refreshing and a just right size was small. My boyfriend likes the cookies and cream concrete but said it was very thick!“

“Rita’s joined us for the 4th of July in our park along with our food truck night! What a great crew to work with!! They bring a nice variety of ice with them so there’s something for everyone! The price is very reasonable and the Ive was so fresh! Thank you guys for being a part of our community and having the friendliest staff ever!!“

“A good dairy queen with above average service. The food isn't as good as some other local small business ice cream shops but the service is above average and the atmosphere and location are central to a lot of other places making this an excellent place to go for ice cream!Parking: Parking is in an adjacent lot, business is on a steep hill so turning into and out of the lot can be difficult. Parking is free and plentiful though.“