Dickey's Barbecue Pit

2481 Lincoln Hwy E Ste 5, Lancaster
(717) 435-8444

Recent Reviews

James H.

This location is permanently closed. It is now BOB'S Barbecue.

ScottnSam H.

I suppose this is going for the new restaurant also which is bobs bbq . I will say it was alright there. The girls working had to keep asking what we got again, they were out of coleslaw and said they didn't have enough green beans to fill the order. Then we discovered our food was just sitting on the counter and no one let us know. Just seemed unorganized. So sorry!

R B.

Closed, it's a different restaurant now. Not a Dickys anymore, no sign so don't know what it is.

Lacey L.

Had the giant baker , which is a huge baked potato, fully loaded with shredded cheddar cheese, bacon , green onion , butter and sour cream. It also comes with a side of fried onion tanglers. Easily the best thing on their menu that's consistent. One of my favorite cheat meals. You definitely won't be able to eat it all at once. Pro tip: Don't forget to slather it in sweet and spicy barbecue sauce.

A Rob

If you enjoy overpriced Luke warm food and terrible bbq then come here. Mac and cheese watery. Bake beans watery and both were cold. Brisket was dry with no flavor. Best part of the meal was the buttered roll. $16.17 total

stacie B

Rude employees who don't even know that they offer online ordering even when you pay and show them proof and an order number. This place is HORRIBLE.

Christopher Long

This was our worst food experience in recent history. The girl taking the order didn't know the menu. Our order was wrong, takeout so couldn't fix it. Food was barely warm, I threw the "burnt ends" (burnt dried brisket flat) away. Find the BBQ food trucks or drive to the closest Mission. Not worth your time or money. I can't remember the last time I threw away food that I bought...

Paul Anderson

Loved this place in the past but today our meats and side dishes were served cold for inside dining.

Dolph

I came here hungry.So I order 5 ribs with 2 sides.Caesar salad, and green beans with bacon.W/biscuitThe driest ribs I ever had to my recall. But had good flavor. It’s a travesty that I could not enjoy them at their best quality.Caesar salad was mediocre at best. The lettuce was wet, dressing undesirable.I did not see any bacon or taste any bacon in the green beans. Which was a big bummer.The bathroom was not the cleanest.I don’t think I will be coming back here again.

Susan Wurst

We came from Sinking Springs for a show at Lancaster Music Theatre...I was so excited because I couldn't wait to try Dickies Barbeque Pit. Well here we are..It is only 6:00 Thursday evening and ..They have No MAC AND CHEESE ..AND NO COLE SLAW....Now can someone tell me WHY...would you run out of the two best side dishes that would go with a pulled pork sandwich so early in the evening?? VERY VERY SAD!! HOW DISAPPOINTING !!!! .Needless to say...WE LEFT!!! WHAT A RUIN TO OUR DATE NIGHT!!!!

Aric Becker

Pretty decent barbeque. It wasn't anything amazing, but if your looking for something fast and different give it a try. I got the brisket, which in my opinion was good quality. The sides I got were coleslaw and Mac and cheese. Again, nothing special here, but It wasn't bad either. I would definitely buy it again. Prices are reasonable. All in all a good experience.

E M.R.M.

The service was good....the employees were nice and friendly but do not listen to the customer very well......on SEVERAL Occasions I have been here to the one on Lincoln highway in Lancaster Pa and each time I have asked for extra Pickles, and either they give 2 or 3 pickles slices or they dont give me any at all.......on the menu it clearly says that pickles and onions are included.....so why is there no pickles OR onions on my plate?? Even when I ask for them they "forgot".....other then that the food is good and the service is good......just if you love pickles as I do.....make sure you have a jar of your own..

Mark Hemelrick

If you love bbq this is your place to go.

Barbra Stone

Needs to be power washed inside.? Smells like an old church nursery. Trays were greasy from the person before me. The no wait was not true. Though there was no one sitting at the tables the line was out the door because of the slow ordering.Would be better after they streamlined the ordering and cleaned the place.

Joel R.

The ribs were absolutely terrible. They were dried out and extremely chewy; it was like jerky. Food was obviously reheated. The waffle fries were undercooked and limp. My pulled pork on my wife's sandwich was good, but the brisket had very little flavor, no beefiness. We were there on Saturday around 1 when every restaurant in the area was packed, but Dickey's never had more than 2 tables occupied while we were there.

Load More