15 Best Sandwich Shops in Lancaster

Bobby Bay's Sandwich Shop Sandwich Shop •
1878 Lincoln Hwy E, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Nashville Hot Sandwich
Bobby’S Cheesesteak
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Crispy Chicken
French Fries
Tuscan Fries
Loaded Fries
Chef Salad
Johnny Boy
Don Parma

“My wife and I stopped by on Friday evening. The house made 10" rolls are legit and made the sandwiches. I had the Johnny Boy and the meats were high quality and the truffle oil complimented the sandwich. Only minor (very minor) issue was that the thick cut mozzarella at times overpowered the meat. But only a minor issue. My wife had the Caprese sandwich and enjoyed it thoroughly. We will be back as the menu looks amazing and I need two work my way through a few other selections.“

4.9 Superb63 Reviews
Savoy Truffle Sandwich Shop • $
398 Harrisburg Ave #250, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Pulled Pork Grilled Cheese with Fries
Pulled Pork Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Strawberry Shortcake Jar Cake
Birthday Cake
Loaded Fries
Egg Cheese
Bagel

“This is the best grill cheese sandwich in Lancaster! Perfectly made w/ gooey cheeses on sourdough bread. Also tried a twinkie cupcake which was moist & sweet! The service was quick & easy. Cute place w/ several small tables & chairs to sit & enjoy some tasty treats. Will come back & try a breakfast sandwich!“

4.6 Superb61 Reviews
Prince Of Subs Sandwich Shop • $
147 S Prince St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Catfish Fillet and Roll with French Fries and Cole Slaw
Fried Jumbo Butterfly Shrimp
Fried Chicken Wings
Philly Cheesesteak
Italian Sub Small
American Sub

“Prince of Subs is hands down the best place for chicken in Lancaster. I always get their chicken, and tonight I wanted to try some other things. I got their cheesesteak, steamed shrimp, soft pretzel, and egg roll. Everything was excellent. The shrimp was steamed perfectly and they were jumbo sized. The cheese steak was perfect with just the right amount of meat. The roll was excellent and not soggy. The egg roll and soft pretzel were delicious as well. I don’t think there is anything at Prince of Subs that isn’t good. I love this place!“

4.6 Superb43 Reviews
Captain Gus's Steak Shop Sandwich Shop • $
600 W Orange St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Large Cheesesteak
Cheese Burger
French Fries
Cheese Steak
Fish Sub

“Went there today for my first time and the people working were very nice! Had a large cheeseburger sub with a large fry and large drink and it was awesome! I'm telling yall if ur in the area please check this place out. This spot is amazing!“

4.3 Superb46 Reviews
The Grille Sandwich Shop • $
241 W Roseville Rd, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Sandwich and Cheeseburger Hoagie
Philly Cheese Steak Hoagie
Cheeseburger Hoagies
Chicken Cheesesteak
Philly Cheesesteak
Pastrami Sandwich
lg Cheese Steak
Cold Sandwiches
Waffle Fries
Cheese Fries

“I finally made it to the Grille after hearing how good it was, and my only disappoint ment is that it took too long for me to eat there. It was delicious. I got the Staten Island which was Prosciutto, hot cappocollo, hot sopresatta, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, artichoke hearts, vinaigrette. My wife got the Fifth Avenue which is fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, tomato, vinaigrette. She loved hers as well. We split the sweet potato fries, that comes with a sweet,almost syrup like sauce that we enjoyed very much. The food came out very quickly and everything was very fresh. The staff were very friendly and the restaurant overall was very clean. Definitely one of the better sandwiches I've eaten in Lancaster in the 20 plus years I've lived here. A bonus is that it is byob and there is a great beer shop that shares an entrance with the Grille that has a huge selection of single cans.Vegetarian options: Sandwiches and salads“

4.3 Superb45 Reviews
Speed's Sandwich Shop • $
318 E King St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Cheese Steak
Cheesesteak and Fries
Philly Cheese Steak
Original Steak Sub
Large Cheese Steak
Steak Sandwich
Cheeseburger
Italian

“I remember coming here as a teenager and it was always the best cheesteak/cheeseburger sub in the city. Since then it's slowly gone downhill with the taste, presentation and environment. Sometimes the burgers are burnt or the cheesesteak has no flavor etc. It mostly has to do with the idiots that have been hired in the past but still has downgraded. I wish it was the old speeds to be honest. I really miss that. It's still really busy all the time though so I know they get good business“

4.2 Good46 Reviews
Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
1581 Fruitville Pike Suite 2, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Ranch Cheese Steak
Chipotle Cheese Steak
Mikes Way Italian Sub
Italian Sub Mikes Way
Turkey Sub Mikes Way
Mikes Italian Sub
Chicken Cheese
Cheese Steaks
Chips & Drinks
The Super Sub

“Went to Jersey Mike's since they opened first shop in pt. Pleasant, nj Was a great sub shop.This shop on Fruitville Pike is just like that one. Its got a wonderful staff and they make sandwiches like that first shop, plenty of meat or tuna or whatever you ask for.Alot of other Jersey Mike's are more concerned about weight of the sandwiches and actually weigh them in front of you. HOW RUDE!!WELL, you get a great sub here!!We drive 6 miles to get to this shop! Its awesome! Thank you for making your customers come first and not penny-pinching like other Jersey Mike's.!!“

4.1 Good46 Reviews
Bruno's at Greenfield Sandwich Shop • $
555 Greenfield Rd, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

13 Spicy Italian Hoagie 1 2 Hoagie
Pastrami on Rye
Roast Beef

“Very well priced, very good quality sandwiches and service! It's unfortunate that I'm not in that area very often, but if I was, Bruno's would be very near the top of the list! Clean, friendly staff, and fresh slice meats for your sandwiches! I would recommend to anyone! I will definitely be back for more at some point in time. I can only recommend the Roast Beef because it's the only sandwiche I ordered, they have numerous others to choose from.“

4.2 Good25 Reviews
Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
2232 Lincoln Hwy E, Lancaster

“First time here, and it is awesome.Parking space A+Clean inside and out A+Costumer Service A+Knowledge of product they sell explaining menu and obtions AA+Product quality A+Inside table & out door table..A++Time in line from start to finish 2 minutes.A+I recommend this place staff is friendly and willing to give the extra step.The employee that attended me is Jeremy, GREAT JOB Jeremy see you again I will be a regular costumer here.“

3.9 Good52 Reviews
Jimmy John's Sandwich Shop • $
1835 Oregon Pike, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Italian Sub

“I am type 2 diabetic. I always loved Jimmy johns before but bread has a lot of carbs and carbs is the main thing I need to stay away from.I recently discovered they have the "unwitch" sandwich and omg this is the best thing ever. It's delicious! I was able to get the bootlegger that I love without all the carbs. Thank you so much for offering this, it's so unique. I was surprised how even with the lack of bread it tasted great. Kicking ranch was delicious as well.Vegetarian options: The veggie is a great tasting sandwich. Highly recommend avocado spread“

3.8 Good30 Reviews
Isaac's Restaurant - Centerville Sandwich Shop • $
245 Centerville Rd, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Pterodactyl Sandwich with Tortellini Deli Salad
Our Famous Pepperjack Tomato Soup
Pretzel Roll Sandwich and Soup
Almond Pesto Tortellini Salad
Fudgie Wudgie Sundae
Club Sandwich
French Fries
Mallard
Phoenix

“Nice place, nice decoration, big portions. 4 stars because the tea was warm and the coffee was not tasty. I liked the aquarium with fish. Very friendly staff.Parking: Parking right next to the cafeKid-friendliness: There are chairs for children“

3.7 Good49 Reviews
Isaac's Craft Kitchen & Brewery - Downtown Lancaster Brewery • $$
25 N Queen St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Penguin Club

“Haven't been there in years since they closed our location near us. We were there mid day with a large party and they did not disappoint. Food was still as good as we remembered, we did think the French fry apps were on the smaller size. But service was great.“

3.7 Good30 Reviews
Isaac's Craft Kitchen & Brewery - Greenfield Sandwich Shop • $
565 Greenfield Rd, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Pepper Jack Tomato Soup
Smoked Turkey Sandwich
Reuben Sandwich
Finch Sandwich
Mallard

“I've had pretty good meals here. I was very disappointed, last night, I ordered the Grilled Honey Dijon chicken salad. Everything was great, except it only contained 3-4 pieces of sugar cubed sized chicken. Did the cook eat the rest? I even gave a 20% tip for carry out, it should have been caught.“

3.6 Good47 Reviews
PrimoHoagies Sandwich Shop • $
2085 Fruitville Pike, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana
Sharp Italian
Old Italian
Bada Bing
Hoagie

“Excellent sandwich shop. Hoagies, subs, whatever you want to call them, they’re fantastic. My go to is a chicken diablo, primo size, with onions, oil, and vinegar. so good. so spicy. so cutlety. so yummy. food took a few minutes to make, which is fine, I'm not a Karen or an impatient tutu like some of the other commenters who calls the employees lazy because they take the time to make the food right.this is amazing and they should have them eveywhere.“

3.6 Good28 Reviews
Firehouse Subs Lime Spring Square Sandwich Shop • $
120 Rohrerstown Rd #8A, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Firehouse Meatball
Firehouse Steak
Sub

“I have heard a lot of great things about Firehouse subs and I line that you can support our hard working firemen. This location is convenient and very clean with more than enough parking. My sub was good and the order was accurate. The workers seemed busy and that could be why they didn't welcome me. The bag of chips is small for the price. These last two point are why this place didn't get 5 stars.“

3.5 Good37 Reviews
Loading...
map Map