We ordered from here last week , had my sons Birthday and ordered 3 pies , Absolutely loved it , Pizza was very tasty , tho it looked light on top the crust was excellent crisp to it , 7 Italians in one room and it is rare that we all loved the same place , but we did , My main Pizza place to order from weekly now ,
. Thanks to whole staff and owner for making my sons Birthday a great dinner ❤️❤️❤️
Andrew Kilpatrick
Family road trip from Williamsport to Old Forge just for lunch. Red and white trays of pizza were excellent. Even the music--literally every song was amongst our favorite songs. Special highlight? We got to meet Mary Lou, who took a break from making pasta to talk with us. Worth every single mile. We'll definitely be back! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Donna Salerno
There pizza is delicious and there homemade raviolis taste just like the ones I used to make. I buy them every Christmas for about 20 people and they all love them. They come in cheese and meat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patrick Hart
Very friendly staff and excellent Old Forge style
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Pizza, Red Pizza
Holly Cavalieri
Best pizza around ? love it there !!! Joe and Brian are the nicest people!!!!?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Old Forge Pizza, White Pizza, Red, Sausage, Red Pizza
David Perez
A lovely cozy environment to relax and have a delicious meal. The staff are caring and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spinach Pizza, Breadsticks and Marinara, Old Forge Pizza, Potato Gnocchi, Special Pizza, Red Pizza
Zachary Peterson
Walking in you are immediately greeted by a big smile and the smell of heavenly pizza. If you're here to grab a bite, take home a tray, or sit down with that special someone you will find it here. The music, atmosphere, and amazing staff will take care of everything.
Oh and not to mention everything is incredibly clean. You are able to see everything being made and you know quality when you can see it!!!
Zachary P.
Walking in you are immediately greeted by a big smile and the smell of heavenly pizza. If you're here to grab a bite, take home a tray, or sit down with that special someone you will find it here. The music, atmosphere, and amazing staff will take care of everything. Oh and not to mention everything is incredibly clean. You are able to see everything being made and you know quality when you can see it!!!
This is a takeout review. All food is eaten promptly in the vehicle. I ordered a pepperoni pizza. The crust had a beautiful crisp on the bottom while having a light and airy upper. The sauce was very good, and just the right amount of cheese. And the curled up pepperoni was simply icing on the cake. The guy running the place was very pleasant also. On a scale from 0-10, I would rate this 9.1.
Tony S.
Great service. Clean atmosphere. Excellent pizza. Wish we had time to order a few more items off the menu. Worth the detour during a recent trip to NY!
CJ P
It was my first time ordering a pizza from here. We got a red pizza with extra cheese, 1/2 pepperoni, and 1/2 mushrooms. It was very flavorful and was cooked all the way through. It was a thick and chewy (not in a bad way) crust. You could see they added extra cheese. They didn't skimp on the pepperoni or mushrooms. Definitely got a piece in each bite. I didn't get heartburn from the sauce, so I was glad about that. The price was about average. I think it was about $22 for a 12 cut square pizza. The guys working there were polite and friendly. I would definitely order from here again and would recommend it to my friends and family.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Red Pizza
James Pondish
We enjoyed a delicious pepperoni pizza pie and very close to my homemade pies. We would highly recommend Mary Lou's to anyone who enjoys great pizza.
Sparke Fitness LLC
Such a cool spot with fun atmosphere, great live music, fantastic pizza and friendly service. I loved that the owner came over to introduce himself and ask how everything was. We loved it, our kids had a blast and we will most definitely be back and recommend it to our Airbnb guests!
Yes. Get it. OF style pizza at its best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Pizza, Red Pizza
We ordered from here last week , had my sons Birthday and ordered 3 pies , Absolutely loved it , Pizza was very tasty , tho it looked light on top the crust was excellent crisp to it , 7 Italians in one room and it is rare that we all loved the same place , but we did , My main Pizza place to order from weekly now , . Thanks to whole staff and owner for making my sons Birthday a great dinner ❤️❤️❤️
Family road trip from Williamsport to Old Forge just for lunch. Red and white trays of pizza were excellent. Even the music--literally every song was amongst our favorite songs. Special highlight? We got to meet Mary Lou, who took a break from making pasta to talk with us. Worth every single mile. We'll definitely be back! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
There pizza is delicious and there homemade raviolis taste just like the ones I used to make. I buy them every Christmas for about 20 people and they all love them. They come in cheese and meat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very friendly staff and excellent Old Forge style
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Pizza, Red Pizza
Best pizza around ? love it there !!! Joe and Brian are the nicest people!!!!?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Old Forge Pizza, White Pizza, Red, Sausage, Red Pizza
A lovely cozy environment to relax and have a delicious meal. The staff are caring and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spinach Pizza, Breadsticks and Marinara, Old Forge Pizza, Potato Gnocchi, Special Pizza, Red Pizza
Walking in you are immediately greeted by a big smile and the smell of heavenly pizza. If you're here to grab a bite, take home a tray, or sit down with that special someone you will find it here. The music, atmosphere, and amazing staff will take care of everything. Oh and not to mention everything is incredibly clean. You are able to see everything being made and you know quality when you can see it!!!
Walking in you are immediately greeted by a big smile and the smell of heavenly pizza. If you're here to grab a bite, take home a tray, or sit down with that special someone you will find it here. The music, atmosphere, and amazing staff will take care of everything. Oh and not to mention everything is incredibly clean. You are able to see everything being made and you know quality when you can see it!!!
The Original Old Forge Recipe, Delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
This is a takeout review. All food is eaten promptly in the vehicle. I ordered a pepperoni pizza. The crust had a beautiful crisp on the bottom while having a light and airy upper. The sauce was very good, and just the right amount of cheese. And the curled up pepperoni was simply icing on the cake. The guy running the place was very pleasant also. On a scale from 0-10, I would rate this 9.1.
Great service. Clean atmosphere. Excellent pizza. Wish we had time to order a few more items off the menu. Worth the detour during a recent trip to NY!
It was my first time ordering a pizza from here. We got a red pizza with extra cheese, 1/2 pepperoni, and 1/2 mushrooms. It was very flavorful and was cooked all the way through. It was a thick and chewy (not in a bad way) crust. You could see they added extra cheese. They didn't skimp on the pepperoni or mushrooms. Definitely got a piece in each bite. I didn't get heartburn from the sauce, so I was glad about that. The price was about average. I think it was about $22 for a 12 cut square pizza. The guys working there were polite and friendly. I would definitely order from here again and would recommend it to my friends and family.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Red Pizza
We enjoyed a delicious pepperoni pizza pie and very close to my homemade pies. We would highly recommend Mary Lou's to anyone who enjoys great pizza.
Such a cool spot with fun atmosphere, great live music, fantastic pizza and friendly service. I loved that the owner came over to introduce himself and ask how everything was. We loved it, our kids had a blast and we will most definitely be back and recommend it to our Airbnb guests!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5