17 Best American Restaurants in Selinsgrove

“Why on earth would you close at 2 on a Friday ….people work and can’t get the experience if you close at 2 every day this is mind blowing to me….we wanted to come for dinner but ended up with no choice to go to the Squeeze In bc we wanted hotdogs and they are open to serve you for dinner not just lunch….i think u should work on this at least be open later on a Friday and Saturday“

“Great mom and pop restaurant with a friendly atmosphere and cozy setting. Much better than a typical chain restaurant, you get home cooked quality food! Also very tasty ice cream and great specials.As shown in my photo, I got the fried haddock with mashed potatoes and broccoli salad.“

“Without question the VERY best place to go in our area for breakfast! They have all the classic menu items, but I'm partial to their "mess", SO good! We've been coming here for years and we won't stop, great service, friendly faces, you can't beat The Pepper Tree!“

“Good food, good service. There is a nice Wednesday special where you get an 8 ounce steak and two sides for $12. You can never go wrong with a baked potato with butter and sour cream and a Ceasar salad as sides. The Chilli is pretty good too. But the best part of any meal at Texas Roadhouse is always the rolls and butter.Our server was on the ball and made frequent trips to check on us even though it was busy.ALSO, if you join their rewards program, you get a free appetizer during your birthday month (which it is for my wife).Overall a very pleasant and enjoyable night out!“

“Very cute little brewery! Liked the old pub feel inside and the beautiful courtyard outside. The live music on a Saturday evening was great for a cozy atmosphere. ✨️ we ordered the pork sandwich and the blt with beer cheese Mac n cheese on the side. Yummy!“

“I've always loved dynamic wings and this will be my new favorite takeout spot. I stopped in for the first time and ordered 2 orders of wings, lg frie, funnel cake fries, and even got two fresh bakery items in the little shop, all for only $27! I was absolutely mind blown at the price and quality of the food! Portions are so nice, there was that much leftover food I gave a whole meal to my family member. Love the store that you can walk around while you wait and the employee was so kind and brought order to the car. There's no place like this anymore, it's amazing 5 stars ?????“

“Came here for the wings and they were great! The wing quality was great and consistent and the flavor I tried (mango habanero) was great as well. Order for pickup can be made and is perfect for a stop going north bound on rt.15. The atmosphere was nice, both customers and employees were friendly and gave a welcoming small town vibe. Wish I could of stuck around for a beer.“

“My husband and I went out for a lunch date and he decided that we were going to go to Perkins we had wonderful food and our the people who took care of us definitely were a blessing that day. The young girl Amanda I believe her name was definitely deserves five stars herself such a Sweet disposition so attentive and just very kind. Thank you for caring about customers and for blessing us on our visit Wednesday.“

“I chose this hotel originally because the reviews were more positive than those for the chain hotels where we usually stay. That was a good decision--this place is amazing! I was originally apprehensive about the tech check-in, having read a poor review. But we had no problem, and the tech check-in proved to be a benefit. The best things about this place: it's smaller than a chain hotel and more like a country inn, so it's elegant, quiet and personal. The rooms are larger than a chain, CLEAN and comfortable and very well appointed. The furniture is upscale/classy. We were able to get a room with 2 separate sleeping areas each with its own queen bed and TV (think "snoring mitigation" :o), and the price was LESS than a single room/2 queen beds in a hotel chain! Once we stayed here once and met the great ladies running the place, we cancelled a Hilton reservation and rescheduled instead for here on our return trip. This will be our go-to hotel whenever we're in the area from now on.“

“My favorite local pizza place. Service is always fast and the food is amazing! I'm pretty sure it's all brick oven pizza I could be wrong? But it tastes like brick oven every time and I love that. Couldn't recommend these guys enough! Plus they deliver to port trevorton!“

“Longhorn is our favorite steak houseAbsolutely love the atmosphere, the steaks are cooked perfect EVERYTIME , The broccoli is my favorite side dishTAYLOR & JIMMY are my favorite serversIf you go request Taylor or JimmyYou won’t be disappointed10 stars“

“We were part of a party of 19 and were seated upstairs. As could be expected, especially with the size of the party and the wait staff dealing with lots trips up/down a long staircase, patience was needed. But the our servers came through with flying colors. They were pleasant, very accommodating and busted their butts to give us A+ service! The food was top notch. The clams casino was the best I've ever had an so was the crab cake. Everyone was very satisfied with their meals. We will definitely eat their on future visits to Susquehanna U.“

“I ate here last night for a holiday dinner and left my charger by mistake cause with all the people in our big party i left in a hurry long and short i called and they found it for me and set it aside it was a 65ish dollar charger block and cable so they really helped me out overall for quick service and good food i rate yas 11/10Parking: as someone with an older father i thought id mention the nice reserved parking spots near the door for disabled people and those who cant walk far smart planning on the restraunts part“

“Everything would have received a 5 star rating. However, because the cooks can not read the tickets correctly, I have chosen a 4-star review. I did a pickup order, and while ordering 1 of the sandwiches, it was supposed to be well done. It was severely pink in the middle. I understand that the staff were busy. However, that is not an excuse to justify not correctly following the ticket. Other than that, the food was delicious.“

“Thank God, a Buffalo Wild Wings with good service and an actual manager that actually cares about Customer Service. What a breath of fresh air. These guys are doing a great job thank you to Tim the manager and Jacob at the to go take out section.Made the dinner of Pleasant experience for us to just kick back at our hotel thank you thank you thank you keep up the great work you guys rock“

“The place was busy. Food was very good. There was a mistake on my order.And they actually took it off the bill which I thought was very kind because they really didn't need to do that.I gave atmosphere a 4 because the place was dirty on the floor. I think that's because they're busy but there was a lot of staff there. I'm surprised they don't have somebody cleaning up as they go.They did have a couple of special needs staff members which I thought was fantastic.“

“I LOVE this place. But today the girl that takes your names needs a new attitude. She was not very pleasant for being the first person you encounter once inside. We were seated at a booth next to the bar where the waitresses put dirty dishes and get the condiments. The top of the bar was full of fruit flies!!! The lights behind the bar also need some cleaning. I think it just needs a deep cleaning. The food was very good so I really hate to do this, But it does needs a little attention.“