Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

Name: Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard
Address: 1568 N Susquehanna Trail, Selinsgrove, Pennsylvania, 17870, US
Telephone: (570) 743-1618
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.6

$$ • Ice Cream

Hours:
1568 N Susquehanna Trail, Selinsgrove
(570) 743-1618

Customers' Favorites

Italian Ice

Custard

Mango

Rita's Italian Ice Reviews

4.6 (85)

Write a review

June 2019

VERY DISAPPOINTED! Strawberry is my favorite water ice. Unfortunately, it’s not on the menu all season and isn’t always available every week. I work long hours so I generally don’t make it to Rita’s until 6:30 pm or later. At least 3 times this season (probably 4) they’ve had Strawberry on the menu, however, by the time I make it there strawberry is sold out. I know that they use leftovers in combination flavors the following day so why not make more strawberry? Or better yet, give customers the option to order, pay and pick up before the close of business that day? It may sound silly but after a stressful day, it’s a bummer to stop for a quart of strawberry water ice only to find out they’re sold out. ☹️

March 2019

My husband and I always liked going to Rita’s for a Custard Cone. The past two years now the sizes of the cones gets smaller but the prices keep going up. We always order a large cone and I might as well order a small or medium because that’s what you get every time anymore. We’ve gone back a few times this year thinking it might just be because the people are new or whatever but it never gets better they just keep getting smaller. This was my last cone I’ll ever buy from them. My husbands was even smaller. Such a disappointment.

More Reviews(85)