10 Best American Restaurants near Tyler Hill

Dutton's Tyler Hill Diner Diner • $
1360 Cochecton Turnpike, Tyler Hill

Customers` Favorites

Banana Pancakes with Sausage and Egg over Easy
Local Nebzydoski's Real Maple Syrup Lemonade
Homefries w Peppers & Onions
Mushroom and Cheese Omelette
Mexican Cheese Omelette
Chocolate Chip Pancakes
Family Cheese Omelette
Piece of French Toast
Loaded Hash Browns
Fresh Cinnamon Bun

“I don't know why I never wrote a review...have been here dozens of times and have brought many of my visiting friends and NO ONE has ever been disappointed! In fact,,,I think they visit me just so they can go to Duttons! ????Dietary restrictions: Vegetarian friendly, for sure!“

4.5 Superb35 Reviews
The Creek House Grill American •
19 Lower Main St, Callicoon - 5.54 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sandwich
And Whipped Cream and Maple Syrup
Gin Soda Lemonade
Dressed Greens
White Puddings
Creek Water
Beef Burger
Onion Soup

“This is sch a nicely renovated historic building. The atmosphere is friendly and inviting. The food was presented beautifully and was plentiful. Our bill was reasonable, and the waitress was friendly and informative without being intrusive. They offer drink specials and have live music on occasion. It's really a nice place to frequent.“

4.5 Superb71 Reviews
Pelkeys Tavern American •
553 Co Rd 94, Hankins - 9.97 miles

Customers` Favorites

Spicy Cheese Curds

“Great place! Food is always delicious, the company is great and the management and bartender are the best!“

4.7 Superb27 Reviews
Rafter's Tavern Bar & Grill • $
28 Upper Main St, Callicoon - 5.59 miles

Customers` Favorites

Caesar Salad
Wings

“Came out here from ri , was starving after the long ride and decided to stop here. looked like they were closing but they sat us anyways which was appreciated, we didn't even look at the menu the girl listed somethings that sounded good and we were like "yeah we'll have w.e that is " the burger sliders were so good and juicy , drinks were great , prices was fair. Hostess was nice and attentive. 10/10“

4.6 Superb27 Reviews
Blue Fox Motel American • $$
5670 NY-97, Narrowsburg - 9.98 miles

“Very cozy and intimate. The cocktails exceptional. As was the wine too! The food delicious from appetizers to entrées. And the roaring fire on a rainy night was beautiful. My husband and I loved the atmosphere and the service. We lingered and were not rushed. True gem!Food & drinks: Exceptional!“

4.4 Superb56 Reviews
Three Wishes American • $$
1418 Beach Lake Hwy, Beach Lake - 5.38 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana

“This is truly a hidden gem you can blink and pass it. I was hungry and pulled in on the journey from Long Island to my house in Honesdale. Where is fear is very charming and gives you the feeling of going back in time. I strolled in a little after 4 o'clock when they open and found out that they have an early bird for $15.99. I said at the bar and Ordered Cajun seafood. I cannot believe in this day and time how much food and of what grade quality I had for 1599. He dinner rolls or something you would have at a five star restaurant the salad was perfect and the seafood was perfect I am back here now one week later enjoying the same experience“

4.4 Superb20 Reviews
The Heron Restaurant American • $$
40 Main St, Narrowsburg - 6.44 miles

Customers` Favorites

Buttermilk Fried Chicken
Blue Cheese Deviled Eggs
Chicken Liver Mousse
Roasted Bone Marrow
Lemon Chicken Soup
Classic Heron Mac
Vegan Grain Bowl
Mac and Cheese
Truffle Fries
Chopped Salad

“I've been at The Heron 5 times over the past 7 years, 3 of them in the past half year. The quality of the food is really good and the portions are large. It's a bit pricey, but they don't skimp. The service is efficient and friendly. The atmosphere is nice, but a bit cramped since it's very popular. The hours are somewhat limited--it stops serving food by 8 p.m. Reservations are recommended!“

4.2 Good54 Reviews
Lakeview Pizzeria & Bar Pizza • $
23 Crestwood Rd, Lake Huntington - 6.01 miles

Customers` Favorites

Meat Lovers Stromboli
Classic Pizza
Cheese Fries
Zeppoles

“10 ⭐ atmospheric place. Its a place where you become family and friends.“

4.2 Good21 Reviews
White Owl Steak House • $$
318 Welcome Lake Rd, Beach Lake - 8.39 miles

Customers` Favorites

Double King Cut Prime Rib
Steak and Added Surf
Ribeye Steak Dinner
Baked Potato
Creme Brulee
Onion Soup

“White owl is a hidden treasure! Don't let the roads leading there discourage you. A short drive from New Yorks Sullivan county or NEPA; and well worth it! They have a generous bar so you can enter the dining room from the middle door and skip the crowd. Our server Riellie was friendly, professional and attentive. She explained the menu items perfectly. Our group had the Atlantic haddock, rib eye steak, ny strip and chicken schnitzel. Delish! Cooked and seasoned perfectly- we even raved over the fresh veggies! Perfectly portioned so we could enjoy a yummy dessert. Our Monday dinner out was fantastic! Can't wait to go back on a Friday or Saturday for their prime rib special! Our new love is white owl.“

4.1 Good74 Reviews
Morrissey's Tavern & Restaurant American • $
60 Brook Rd, Honesdale - 11.3 miles

“Hi i just wanted to say what a great time there the food was great and the bartend was fantastic quiet very charming and the deck was the best tables umbrellas on everyone with 4 chairs i was there on deck and a man came with dog the dog was panting the Bartender brought a bowl out for the dog so dog was in the shade the man was very happy i loved the pool tables and poker machines very good service i will be going back“

3.8 Good10 Reviews