34 Best Pizza Restaurants near West Newton

“1st time trying this place after recommendations from my friend who grew up with it.Had the 8 cut with anchovies and mushrooms. And I can easily say it is a fantastic and delicious pizza!! Love the dough and the use of Colby is a great idea. Definitely will get this again and again!!“

“If you have a big order and you’re anywhere close to this place, just make it here. They do a great job. Getting big orders out the door on time and very organized and I’ll help you get it in the car. Good prices in really good quality stuff.“

“The owner/manager (??) is an incredibly nice and gracious man. We were riding the gap/towpath and it was raining and cold. We were hungry and wet. Couldn't have stopped by a better place. He made us feel right at home. Oh..and the food was delicious. Thank you!“

“"Rockway Pizza: Where Pepperoni Knots are the Twist You Never Knew You Needed!I stumbled upon Rockway Pizza craving something different, and boy, did they deliver—literally! The Pepperoni Knots had me tied up in deliciousness from the very first bite. The portion sizing was spot-on, leaving me feeling satisfied but already planning my next visit. And as for the taste? Let's just say my taste buds did a happy dance that could rival any TikTok trend. Rockway Pizza, you've officially become my new twist on pizza night!"Did I make this using ChatGPT you may be asking yourself, maybe ?‍♂️?‍♂️?But no seriously you need to try this place out it’s fantastic and the service is amazing, not even to mention the atmosphere with a classic pizzeria vibe and like classic jazzy music“

“Stopped here for a quick lunch on a Saturday. Server was attentive, food was hot and fresh and atmosphere was relaxed. We had a large pizza and some sandwiches. Appreciated that there was a vegetarian sandwich option and that the menu was simple and easy to figure out. They know what they do best there and they keep it at that. Something I admire.“

“I’m actually writing this review and I haven’t even been there yet! Just based off of the looks and the look of the food it looks absolutely incredible! The look of the atmosphere looks awesome due to the spooky theme! I can’t wait to try it and have a date night with the other half!“

“Valley Pizza is exceptional! It took us awhile to find a pizza place that was beyond okay. This is pizza that is perfect.Valley Pizza is perfect because they offer so many different ways to specialize their pizza's to different tastes. My kids prefer the pepperoni pizza with sweeter red sauce. Their crust is made fresh and cooked to perfection.The white pizza is excellent. I love it. We order the standard white as it comes off of their menu. Tomato & spinach. Delicious.“

“Incredible pizza for the price its pick up only but the owner Jamie is a really nice fellow who loves to talk to all the customers on pickup cant beat a large pepperoni for 8$ always quick and ready within 45 minutes a local must try pizza joint !“

“Been here twice so far, both times in their new location. The first time we got two different pizzas for take out and took them down to the park a few minutes away and ate them for lunch. I can't remember exactly which ones they were, but they were pretty good. I think one was a margarita style and that one was good. The other one I think had pepperoni or salami on it and it was not my favorite, the meat was very strong, it tasted a little aged or maybe even old. I will avoid anything with that on it from now on. The second time I ate here was eat-in. I wasn't feeling adventurous so I just got the 50/50 burger, the meat was 50% beef and 50% pork and wow was that a satisfying burger. The toppings were super basic, not even any tomato, I think it was just cheese and lettuce, but the flavor of the patty made up for the lack of toppings. It was very flavorful and had a great texture. I will definitely get that again. We also got the buffalo cauliflower for an appetizer and they were really good. I'm not one of those people who thinks that buffalo cauliflower is somehow comparable with actual Buffalo wings, but good Buffalo cauliflower is its own thing and it's delicious, so I would get that again as well. I also appreciated that the bathroom was spotless, I think there's a lot to be said about the attention to detail that a restaurant staff has if their bathrooms are clean and attended to. It's a small dining room so I'm sure on a busy night there will be a wait, even though it's a little out of the way of the main road, but it's worth the drive and the wait. I will definitely be back.“

“Good food and kind staff. Eat here once a week and never get tired of there food.Parking: There is a huge parking lot along with plenty of street parking all around icebergs, but you do have to pay for it during weekdays until 5:00 after 5:00 it is free and it is also free on weekends before and after 5:00.Kid-friendliness: There are arcade machines for kids to play along with plenty of kid-friendly drink and food options.Wheelchair accessibility: There is a ramp to get to the front door. And, it is all one story.“

“This was a very last-minute option, but I have no regrets whatsoever. Searching for some late night eats, this establishment was open. Plenty of parking, a good amount of seating, and friendly staff here to serve you. I was skeptical on the food, but our server mentioned a special on a pizza, which we jumped at. There was even a special on a sandwich which was very good and not overwhelming. I just had to get their chips and homemade French onion dip. I’m not much of a potato chip person, but here, they had me. Consistency was great, not crazy salty, and perfect dip. Seriously, I could eat those bad boys all day. It’s one of the places where you aren’t expecting much but they hit you in the sweet spot. I didn’t realize how hungry I was, and I kept eating. American style bar/ restaurant, homely and filling. I’m sure if you are from around these parts, you have probably heard of or been here before. If you haven’t yet, just go. Give it a shot. Or two.“

“Ate on the patio. Three of us and our dog. The food was great as was the service. We had perogies, huluski, cabbage roll, pulled pork, and Italian beef. It was all excellent. They not only allowed our dog, the server even offered to bring her water. Give Bubbas a try. Highly recommend.“

“Chef Salvatore of Salvatore's Pizza and Pasta - Brooklyn's Finest in Rostraver Twp, PA deserves praise for his delicious entrées and pizza. We were too busy to eat in, so we ordered takeout. Our order was substantial and offered three separate dinners for us to enjoy. The pizza was delicious! The handmade sauce and crust were delectable, and YES!!! I KNOW there are an insane number of pizza places within a 5-mile radius, BUT NOT ALL PIZZA IS THE SAME, and it's occasionally good to mix things up. Then there was baked ziti, chicken parmesan, meatballs, and garlic knots. Mouthful of Italian bliss!!! The chicken was tender and flavorful. The meatballs were out of this world. The baked ziti, spaghetti, and garlic knots were delicious. If you've been searching for delicious home-cooked Italian food, Salvatore's is a must-try! #ChefSalvatore #Rostraver #ItalianBliss #pizza #ziti #chickenparm #meatballs #homemade“

“What a cool find! I was in town for an afternoon meeting and stopped by. I highly recommend the Odinator. Great sandwich! Be hungry! They have the best homemade chips I've ever had. The fried zucchini was on point as well. Will be back for sure!“

“I love this place the food is excellent and the employees and the owners are very helpful friendly and polite. And another thing you don't have to worry about if this pizza joint is clean this place is spotless. I am definitely giving Benny's 5 star's if I could give them 10 they would get it from me. I would like to say thank you to everyone at Benny's for making excellent food and being very•a helpful friendly and polite. I will return for more food and making feel at home.Parking: There's a lot of free parking and handicap parking. Actually there is no bad place to parkKid-friendliness: And the youngins are more than welcome at Benny's. I'm 61 years old and I act just like a kid. And they love me,Wheelchair accessibility: There is handicap parking right in front of the restaurant.“

“Great family friendly restaurant with something for everyone on menu. Staff is friendly; food ready in only a short wait time.Parking: Many spaces; handicap spaces available directly in frontWheelchair accessibility: No barriers except no automatic exterior door“

“Great place. Just nothing stay in stock for long. There like really our only deli like place. So many people from our area depend on this place. Great employees and they follow most guidelines other then the temperature check, but this is my favorite because they try their best to have and keep supply and demand. A Lot without cars here in this town . so product leave a bit faster then others. Great jon Station“

“I'm from east pgh. And this pizza is just like vinnies...big toppings tons of cheese and the sauce is awesome the crust is great just all around gold...the hoagies,salads everything here is 110% delicious you definitely get what you pay for!!!...comfortis please don't change a thing!!!“

“An amazing little gem on the border of North Huntingdon and Rillton. Bright atmosphere, friendly, excellent staff and delicious food. We had take out pizza from their previous Hahntown shop, finally dined in at the new location today and we had the Autumn Salad, Meatball Hoagie and Buffalo Cauliflower. On a whim my husband ordered the brownie with ice cream, the best ever!! He can't wait to try their other homemade desert offerings on future visits.“

“Best pizza place around love ordering Christopher's pizza! Whether it's a small gathering or a whole party, they have plenty of pizza options and sizes. The haogies are also good I really haven't had anything I didn't like from this place. Highly recommend“

“Pizza Burgh, Pizza Burgh, PIZZA BURGHThis pizza was fire and before I jump into details let me tell you what I ordered, a large extra cheese and pepperoni hand tossed, baby just go get it ??? “17.99 two topping large special”Okay let’s get into it, I’m a pizza girl and I can say this is theee best pizza I’ve had in a while. I usually only get pizza that looks and tastes like this when I go out of town.From the crust to the toppings everything was fresh, just absolutely finger licking delicious. I ate more than I usually would!I didn’t pick up my Husband did and said everything looked very clean and he had wonderful + respectful customer service from “the man behind the counter”I will travel downtown to cafe milanos for pizza like this that’s my favorite place but I’m going out on a limb to say this might be better, I gotta see if yaw have a garlic butter sauce ?Being pregnant, moving, needing a quick and filling bite, having had to settle for little Caesars, Pizza Hut, palmers, broadway, fat Angelo’s (which has disappointed me twice) this is the best in the area! You now have a new family of forever customers.“

“We have eaten here many times and have always enjoyed the food.went for the pizza today and wow.this is by far 1 of the best.thick crispy crust the whole way across and enough sauce to get it on your cheeks with great toppings.i live 45 min.away and don't mind the drive for great food.“

“We just moved up the road and found this gem. We have had them twice now. Both times we got a pizza and steak hoagie. Both fantastic. Looking forward to enjoying this place for many years. Also the guy working the register came from behind the counter to get the door for my wife when her hands were full. Its the little things. Thanks guys!“

“Being born and living in Texas I had my favorite restaurants on being a Italian restaurant being Antonio's now that I'm living here in Pennsylvania I have found my new favorite restaurant being so similar in everything that Antonio's has to offer I can honestly say that this is the Best ♥️“

“We ordered on the Toast app. It was easy. We got a large chicken bacon ranch pizza, a dozen of seasoned wings and chicken tenders and fries. The food was delicious and still hot when we got home. We live about 10 mins away from the Elizabeth location. Service was fast and friendly.Parking: It’s take out only, so the parking lot was nearly empty.Kid-friendliness: The kids menu has a lot of options for picky eaters.“

“My husband and I loved it. They were so nice, and the food was amazing. We absolutely loved eating there it just gave you a sense of welcome. It screamed family owned. Can't wait to go again. The pizza was amazing. It had the perfect crunch on the crust. The garlic bread loaf was a hit as well. The homemade ranch was great.Kid-friendliness: Kids loved the decorations on the wall and how their opinion on the food mattered. Great conversation.“

“I would like to start off with how easy Conner and his team were to work with. I placed an order for 280 people. We decided the best route was to order "The Big Ones" and breadsticks. The pizzas arrived hot, fresh, and right on time. Everyone had good things to say about the food. I would highly recommend them especially if you need good pizza at a reasonable price point to feed a large number of people.“

“I don’t know what that Tony guy is talkin about I just picked up two perfect pies!!! It’s no fluke it’s becoming a weekly tradition at my house. Wood fired pizza gets a little sear on it and that’s where that iconic flavor comes from if you want a pasty pizza grab a freezer made if you want a good quality fresh pizza hit up Peroney bros.“

“Good pizza and hoagies. We get a pizza and a few hoagies every time. For the pizza crust lovers, the crust is really airy and crispy with a good flavor. The hoagie bread is also crispy which compliments the fillings of each one. Sometimes they give a lot and sometimes it is a little skimpy but it's fine. ?‍♀️We always use the online ordering which gives us points when place an order plus coupons are available. The food is always ready by the time we pick it up. This location is better than their north versailles one. The other location we always have issues with so we just go to this one now.Recommend the ranchero, steak, and italian hoagies“

“My wife's favorite overall pizza, and my favorite local football pizza (don't know what football pizza is? Google one bite pizza reviews with El Prez).The thing about pizza is, that they are like snowflakes and all different. Folks are always trying to figure out who is the "best" but the reality is that pizza that you love is the "best for you". That's why there are so many out there. But you can't go wrong with Brooklyn's and I'm SOOO glad that they are back. We usually order the XL 3-topping with pepperoni and half mushroom half sausage because that magically appeases everyone in the house. The reason that I mention it is that I find sausage on pizza to be very hit or miss and Brooklyn's hits.Recently got a steak sub as well and I'll be ordering it again. Real steak, great roll...worth a try.Finally, the owners and the workers are super nice and friendly and always make you feel welcome when you stop to pick up. I mention this because, let's be honest, we've had places in PT that haven't always given us that and it's worth noting.Sorry that I forgot to take a pic, I'll update the next time that we order...which will be soon. Thanks Brooklyn's!“

“Pizza was great as always is from the location, hoagies were awesome as well. I love the pizza dough from here, it is so chewy and crispy and has a good flavor to it! The deliver driver was very awesome as well! He was very polite, and was even early from the time stated when I ordered! Pizza maker and delivery driver both deserve 5 *s!!! ??????“

“I order from here frequently whether it be takeout or delivery and/or breakfast, lunch, or dinner and I've never had a problem or complaint about the food or employees. Prices are very reasonable and the delivery drivers are always on time when I've ordered. The food was hot and delicious as well. My favorite lunch/dinner item is the chicken Broccoli pizza (highly recommend) as not too many pizza places around offer it.“

“I dogsit for a couple just down the street from here so I always order pizza when I'm there. The food is always hot and always made just how I ask it to be. The employees are always really nice when I come in as well, and they don't take long making orders unless it's a busy night.“

“Situated just within the bounds of White Oak, this pizza place has sat on my map of places to try for awhile. I don't usually hit up this side of town, though it looked like it was going to be worth it. If only for the competition it's got nearby.And it was an excellent time!Their traditional crust pizza was a good, enjoyable section of pizza. There are better pizzas out there in the Pittsburgh area in my opinion, but what you won't beat is the price. Their gargantuan pizza is HUGE, and for the price for just cheese or adding only Pepperoni? It's almost impossible to beat on value for a pizza that competes locally.Never mind they have quite the array of unique options, and cater to taste. Whether the options to specify how cooked their steak hoagies, or the Potato Pancakes served with sour cream that come by the BAG.This little corner of Pittsburgh pizza is going to give you your value and then some. On that alone, it's worth checking out!“