“Great bar, great nights, great music and great drinks!! Love this place. Good Good vibes and sing alongside! It made the week. Even lost my jacket and they were VERY helpful. Hard working bartenders and excellent music and choices of music. U can be inside or outside. Away from the noise or a part of it and ohhhh the views!!! FUN and don't forget all the people were NICE!!! ( and Dock games too!!)“
“I visited the island for 26 days in August/September. After trying every bar, pub and restaurant on the island, the Old Island Pub is the only one that kept us coming back time and time again. Everything on the menu, yes even the hot dog is expertly prepared. Time and experience has gone into crafting these menu items. The pub fries are a work of art and are a must order. Good food takes time so if you're in a hurry or are Hangry and ready to throw a fit you might want to go elsewhere. Aside from the food, the bartenders and crowd that gather here are genuinely awesome and make the OIP the ideal place to go if you want to get a taste of life on the island. We made friends here that we will certainly be back to see.“
“Fire banana mudslides. We always come here after a long day at the beach and it never disappoints. It's fun to look at the big yachts docked along the marina, and take in the scenery at the harbor. They always play great music and it's a peaceful vibe. Glad this place is finally on the map.“
“BIBH was everything I hoped it would be and much more. The staff was excellent, engaging, and friendly creating a family like atmosphere! The rooms were full of modern amenities and decor! I suggest a balcony room as the sunsets are amazing! The food is unbelievable! This southern boy loved the pork grilled cheese and the smell of the grilled street corn alone will make your mouth water! If you don’t finish off every meal with their Key Lime Pie you are missing out! There are definitely NO BAD DAYS at this one of a kind hotel!“
“We came to block island early in March and every where was closed except this place. So glad they were open. Such good food and service. The Salmon BLT was something else. I've never had anything like it. So fresh. The bloody merry was very good. The lady was so nice and friendly and they had sport games on too. Thank you for the nice experience!“
“I came here as a kid and returned as an adult and I’m glad to see that it remains the same as I remembered! Drinks were good as was the dinner!A big thanks to Tori who was a great server and navigated the food orders of our two toddlers like a pro. Hopefully it won’t be another 25 years til I’m back next!“